Subject: article in Kitplanes Why not the rotary
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/14/2011, 10:34 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Paul,

The rotary engine have a lot of advantages in it's simplicity, but how
does it stack up in efficiency?

How far do we get on a gallon of gas ( assuming the same displacement)
in comparison with a piston engine?

Will it ever be en engine that can favorable compete in cars ( or
airplanes) that will give us those high numbers in MPG.

I am pretty good with that we will have a very compact powerplant that
can crank out a lot of good power, but what I am getting at, the
survivability, and the social acceptance of the rotary has to come from
fuel improvements over the current piston engine, not necessarily in
power improvements.

I think that it just can't be equal with what is now on the market, but
actually has to show a distinct edge before they will start to retool in
Detroit.

Even if the rotary is the better engine, ...three moving parts, ( who
can argue) ...that in itself will not change the course of it. History
has shown many times that a lesser good system can indeed be the winner.

110 V system sucks, but it won....BetaMax was a much better system than
VHS,  VHS won ... town center trolleys system was dismantled in
favour of the piston driven diesel bus.....etc etc...

Unless the rotary can give that edge, I am afraid that it will continue
to be a marginal engine, no matter how good it is per se.

If we swap a piston engine for an equal rotary and are getting 65
instead of 40 MPG...thats most probably the way this engine needs to go,
pure efficiency .

A development that I don't know if it is fully possible....maybe....the
rotary is not without it's faults.

The buzz word right now is "Alternative", and if a steam engine can be
made to run on wood and water, that will put it on the "alternative"
category and given it an edge right there.....( even if the efficiency
sucks, but hey....we cheated the Arabs...so in that sense,  it IS an
alternative....thats how the thinking goes when it comes to alternative)

Stuff like that is what's is looked upon right now, as an oil based
combustion engine is today connected with a negative.....for all the
right and wrong reasons.

I think that the rotary engine is looked upon with the eyes that it is
"just another way to burn decomposed dinosaurs" , and is in the
"negative" category..the category of engines we want to get away from.

For the rotary to move into a positive, , into the "alternative"
category, it has to do a pretty good jump in efficiency.

Next hurdle if it does that, is to overcome the idea that it is
basically a 2 stroke, and about as efficient.

So I think it has quite a way to go , it might or might not blossom into
something and get a new birth in the future, unless hydrogen fuel cells,
or other technologies are taking over....who knows.

I do believe though that a lot more research and developments has to go
into this engine, an edge that the piston engine has been favoured with
for a hundred years, and it is a matter if the resources and the
industrys ( especially the automotive) interest is there, to put a bet
onto this engine, a doubtful proposition at best, considering how much
know how they are already sitting on, when it comes to the piston engine.

Lacking those big resources, the development may probably come from
racing industry, enthusiasts, and other intelligensias, and as usually,
improvements from that arena, have a tendency to get in on the
established market that way, via the back door..that I can see as a
possibility.

How it needs to be improved...that's another story, and a big scope,
highly time and resource intensive, but as with any other combustion
engine, it's a matter of how thermal efficient one can make it.

As with the piston engine in the Hot Rod field, tinkerers did a lot of
developments, that developed into a ...first a sub culture,... then
finally into an established industry...and out of that industry, today
the improvements are pretty much a bolt on thing, straight out of the
box,  we all know what Edelbrock and Holley is.

...so with this rotary...we will see what gives.

Roger

Well according to Mazda they have solved the efficiency problem.
They now claim the new rotary is more efficient than the piston
engines they sell. We shall see.

For 50 years they have been building the same geometry.
Equivalent to the bore and stroke ratio. Not only that the displacement
has not increased. Nor has the compression ratio by much.
Compression ratio is a major factor in internal combustion engine
efficiency.

The rotary power has gone up from 110 HP to 280 HP in the Mazda
3rd gen turbo. The max RPM has gone up from about 6000 to 9000
in the RX8 engine.

Both Mazda (16x) and SuperTech in Germany changed the rotary geometry
to allow a higher compression ratio. SuperTech is claiming
diesel category BSFC's of .34 running on heavy fuel.

Low RPM torque has always been a desirable feature in car engines.
The US car manufactures have always known that and that is why
they build high displacement, low RPM, light duty push rod engines.
Same goes for light aircraft engines although of much higher
duty cycle. The Europeans on the other hand go for lower displacement,
high RPM engines, with dual over head cams and 4 valves per cylinder
and put the bucks into gear boxes. Due to the autobahn, with no
speed limits, the duty cycle of European engines tends to be higher.

Mazda is just now thinking of increasing the displacement from
2.6 L to 3.2 L in the 16x. In the mean time the Europeans have
developed the fast shifting, automatic manual transmissions without
the low efficiency torque converter common in the US.

The current Formula 1 engines are the epitome of this philosophy
with 19,000 max RPM, small piston engines and fast paddle shifting
transmissions.

Consequently there is a very interesting competition going on.

Paul Lamar

Additional thought:

Decades ago, after the first oil shocks, when gas went from 20 cents to
75 cents per gallon, there was lots of talk about alternative engines.
But I recall a brief article in Machine Design where the comment was made:

   If god landed on the white house lawn with a sheaf of blueprints
   under his arm and announced that they contained the design of an
   engine that would solve all our problems it would tie up the entire
   machine tool industry of the USA for ten years just to rebuild the
   factories that make engines for our cars.

The piston engine is really embedded in all our manufacturing processes
and factories.  Think of how much money sits in all the fixtures and all
the machine tools in all the factories involved in the production of the
so called small block Chevy engine.  I would bet it adds up in the
TRILLIONS area.  It is a huge practical problem facing any conversion.

Suppose just Jahns or Forged True were required to change from making
pistons to making Wankel rotors?  How long would it take and how much
would it cost?  How about changing Hastings from piston rings to tip
seals?  Etc, etc.

Formula 1 is much easier to change ..... a few hundred million dollars
is nothing in the scheme of things.  As old Senator Proxmire is reputed
to have once said, "A billion here and a billion there and pretty soon
you are talking real money!"  Maybe, if F1 can do a successful
technology demonstration, something will move but the inertia is HUGE!

Steve Dorr

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.