Subject: article in Kitplanes Why not the rotary
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/14/2011, 5:26 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


  dear Paul Lamar,

  I am mystified ..... with all the stated advantages, why has the
  rotary/Wankel, turbo compound engine not superseded the piston
  engine? It would have been ideal for say the Chevy Volt. Better
  than so called Atkinson cycle engines .......

  I know both Curtiss Wright and GM put lots of research dollars into
  the concept and gave it up. I don't know why.

  Do you?


  So please sign me up for the newsletter ..... perhaps I will gain some
  insight.

  Thanks,
  Steve Dorr
  Orlando, FL

  GM did not have the culture for it. They arrogantly thought they could
  do it better while Toyo Kogyo merely perfected something NSU already
  had working.

  Toyo Kogyo (Mazda) was a young company with out a lot of history so
  they were looking for something to put them on the map. Apparently
  the Japanese people value perseverance highly and have that never
  give up attitude. I also think the TK management was well founded in
  physics so they better understood the advantages. They also seem to take
  a longer view when it comes to business risk.

  CW was never serious about going into production. They wanted to
  get a contract from somebody to do it for them. I think they were
  manipulating the stock to make money on the side.

  Me too. It will take some R&D so car companies won't do it
  until somebody does it first.

  Pratt and Whitney is working on rotary TC here in socal at the
  Rocketdyne subsidiary. Even to the extent of filing
  one or more patents. Probably for UAV use.

  I gave a presentation on the piston TC subject to a collection
  of chief Formula 1 engineers. I offered a 20% improvement
  in BSFC while all of the other papers presented talked
  about a 2 to 3% improvement. It was well received and
  the FIA Representative said they would change the rules to
  encourage it soon. Formula 1 teams had been spending up
  to 800 million US a year. Much of it on engine development.

  The current vice president of the FIA is an old race car wing
  customer of mine dating back to the late 1960's.

  http://www.rotaryeng.net/Oxford-640-4802.wmv


  Paul Lamar

  Paul,

  The rotary engine have a lot of advantages in it's simplicity, but how
  does it stack up in efficiency?

  How far do we get on a gallon of gas ( assuming the same displacement)
  in comparison with a piston engine?

  Will it ever be en engine that can favorable compete in cars ( or
  airplanes) that will give us those high numbers in MPG.

  I am pretty good with that we will have a very compact powerplant that
  can crank out a lot of good power, but what I am getting at, the
  survivability, and the social acceptance of the rotary has to come from
  fuel improvements over the current piston engine, not necessarily in
  power improvements.

  I think that it just can't be equal with what is now on the market, but
  actually has to show a distinct edge before they will start to retool in
  Detroit.

  Even if the rotary is the better engine, ...three moving parts, ( who
  can argue) ...that in itself will not change the course of it. History
  has shown many times that a lesser good system can indeed be the winner.

  110 V system sucks, but it won....BetaMax was a much better system than
  VHS, VHS won ... town center trolleys system was dismantled in
  favour of the piston driven diesel bus.....etc etc...

  Unless the rotary can give that edge, I am afraid that it will continue
  to be a marginal engine, no matter how good it is per se.

  If we swap a piston engine for an equal rotary and are getting 65
  instead of 40 MPG...thats most probably the way this engine needs to go,
  pure efficiency .

  A development that I don't know if it is fully possible....maybe....the
  rotary is not without it's faults.

  The buzz word right now is "Alternative", and if a steam engine can be
  made to run on wood and water, that will put it on the "alternative"
  category and given it an edge right there.....( even if the efficiency
  sucks, but hey....we cheated the Arabs...so in that sense, it IS an
  alternative....thats how the thinking goes when it comes to alternative)

  Stuff like that is what's is looked upon right now, as an oil based
  combustion engine is today connected with a negative.....for all the
  right and wrong reasons.

  I think that the rotary engine is looked upon with the eyes that it is
  "just another way to burn decomposed dinosaurs" , and is in the
  "negative" category..the category of engines we want to get away from.

  For the rotary to move into a positive, , into the "alternative"
  category, it has to do a pretty good jump in efficiency.

  Next hurdle if it does that, is to overcome the idea that it is
  basically a 2 stroke, and about as efficient.

  So I think it has quite a way to go , it might or might not blossom into
  something and get a new birth in the future, unless hydrogen fuel cells,
  or other technologies are taking over....who knows.

  I do believe though that a lot more research and developments has to go
  into this engine, an edge that the piston engine has been favoured with
  for a hundred years, and it is a matter if the resources and the
  industrys ( especially the automotive) interest is there, to put a bet
  onto this engine, a doubtful proposition at best, considering how much
  know how they are already sitting on, when it comes to the piston engine.

  Lacking those big resources, the development may probably come from
  racing industry, enthusiasts, and other intelligensias, and as usually,
  improvements from that arena, have a tendency to get in on the
  established market that way, via the back door..that I can see as a
  possibility.

  How it needs to be improved...that's another story, and a big scope,
  highly time and resource intensive, but as with any other combustion
  engine, it's a matter of how thermal efficient one can make it.

  As with the piston engine in the Hot Rod field, tinkerers did a lot of
  developments, that developed into a ...first a sub culture,... then
  finally into an established industry...and out of that industry, today
  the improvements are pretty much a bolt on thing, straight out of the
  box, we all know what Edelbrock and Holley is.

  ...so with this rotary...we will see what gives.

  Roger

  Well according to Mazda they have solved the efficiency problem.
  They now claim the new rotary is more efficient than the piston
  engines they sell. We shall see.

  For 50 years they have been building the same geometry.
  Equivalent to the bore and stroke ratio. Not only that the displacement
  has not increased. Nor has the compression ratio by much.
  Compression ratio is a major factor in internal combustion engine
  efficiency.

  The rotary power has gone up from 110 HP to 280 HP in the Mazda
  3rd gen turbo. The max RPM has gone up from about 6000 to 9000
  in the RX8 engine.

  Both Mazda (16x) and SuperTech in Germany changed the rotary geometry
  to allow a higher compression ratio. SuperTech is claiming
  diesel category BSFC's of .34 running on heavy fuel.

  Low RPM torque has always been a desirable feature in car engines.
  The US car manufactures have always known that and that is why
  they build high displacement, low RPM, light duty push rod engines.
  Same goes for light aircraft engines although of much higher
  duty cycle. The Europeans on the other hand go for lower displacement,
  high RPM engines, with dual over head cams and 4 valves per cylinder
  and put the bucks into gear boxes. Due to the autobahn, with no
  speed limits, the duty cycle of European engines tends to be higher.

  Mazda is just now thinking of increasing the displacement from
  2.6 L to 3.2 L in the 16x. In the mean time the Europeans have
  developed the fast shifting, automatic manual transmissions without
  the low efficiency torque converter common in the US.

  The current Formula 1 engines are the epitome of this philosophy
  with 19,000 max RPM, small piston engines and fast paddle shifting
  transmissions.

  Consequently there is a very interesting competition going on.

  Paul Lamar


  Paul,

  Indeed there is interesting things going on, just hope to see the fruits
  of it this lifetime.

  The claim from Mazda that the rotary now are as efficient as the piston
  engine is encouraging, but as always...we will see.

  By running heavy fuel you will boost the efficency, the same as
  comparison between gasoline and diesel engine, don't know if they are
  running compression ignition though, like the dieselcycle on that engine
  you described, usually it is a bit hard to ignite heavy fuel with a
  sparkplug, so maybe they are actually running diesel compression.

  Higher and higher compression gives a diminishing point of return. Raise
  the compression from 5:1 to 7:1 and you will get a tremedeous good
  return, raise it from 7:1 to 9:1 and you will get a decent return, raise
  it from 9:1 to 11:1 and you will get a very small return.

  Part of the gain is not from raising the compression in itself, but the
  increased ability the engine will get, to clean out spent and inert gas
  from it's last work stroke.
  I can see two areas the rotary could need an improvement on, bigger
  stroke, the stroke it has is very small, and are depending on the
  difference in the center of the shaft to the center of the ofset roll
  shaft each rotor is spinning around.

  From what I understand you are saying, they are working out the
  geometry better now.

  The up and down bobbing triangular center body. it doesnt describe a
  true rotation, but changes it's position where the center of mass will
  be shifting between two extremes, and as I understand, it is made of
  steel, right now. If you take a body like that, everytime two of the
  three corners in the triangular centerbody , are on the outside, the
  force inceases.

  The energy it takes to change that mass back and forth between those two
  main positions, got to be huge, ..as Newton says, everytime you change
  direction, you pay for it in lost energy.

  I don't know how it compare with forces in a piston engine other than a
  lose comparison, as in a piston engine, the main mass that is
  reciprocating is a steel rod, and an aluminum piston, part of the steel
  rod is follwing the crank in a true circle, the crank itself is
  follwing a true circle. You spin that up to maybe 3000 RPM, on freeay
  speed, while the rotary has a much heavier piece that have a shorter
  stroke, but much heavier mass, and perhaps twice the rotation...force
  needed at twice the RPM is not linear, ...I dont know the exact number
  as the baseline is an estimate, but I dont think that four times the
  force is too much out of line.

  If a rotary would be connected up to an electric motor, and the force
  was measured to rotate it, the lower RPM bands would probably be very
  good, , but the force needed to spin it in the upper bands where the
  rotary works best, must be terrible.

  I can understand it is a matter of structural integrity, but the weight
  on that tringular rotor has to come down, and I don't know what material
  that is lighter that can substitute the steel and still dont have
  fatigugue problems, as it is a critical component.

  Titanium perhaps, or perhaps a steel casing filled with aluminum, either
  way, that up and down bobbing piece of steel is stealing a lot of energy
  to do that movement.

  True rotating parts can conserve and store energy, and even if a piston
  engine has a lot of parts to it that moves, actually most of it's
  rotating mass are both balanced and in true rotation, the majority of
  the moving mass in a rotary is not in true rotation,...therefore in
  direct correlation to it's mass and speed, it will steal rotational
  energy.... therefore to get a distinct leap of efficiency with the
  rotary engine, the mass of that part has to come down drastically.

  How to do it and still keep the structural integrity...I don't even want
  to think about it.

  I bet ya in fifteen years from now we can order from Edelbrock a rotary
  replacement that is made of a material we can't pronounce.

  Roger


  "The up and down bobbing triangular center body."

  There is no up and down Roger. A common mistake many make.
  The rotor CG orbits around the center of the e-shaft much like
  the earth orbits the sun. That is why it is sometimes called
  a planetary engine. Have you read the Kitplanes article yet?

  Here is a good one to read as well.

  http://www.rotaryeng.net/how-wank-works.html

  "Actually what is happening is the center or CG of the rotor is
moving in a
  circle around the center of the output shaft while the output shaft
rotates."

  "Since there are no reciprocation parts what so ever it is possible to
  completely balance the Wankel engine just like a turbine or electric
motor and
  unlike any piston engine despite some claims to the contrary. The
rotor is
  balanced around it own axis. The front rotor balances the rear rotor
as they are
  180 degrees apart on the output shaft. That leaves a small couple
which is
  finally completely balanced by the counter weights."

  Also go on youtube and watch many Wankel animations as there are
  dozens.

  The only limitations on the RPM of a rotary are due to centrifugal
  load of the rotor weight on the e-shaft rotor bearing.

  Paul Lamar
  --
I'm no expert, but the two areas in which the Wankel would need to be
improved to significantly improve BSFC are

 1) Reduction of waste energy in the exhaust (higher in the rotary than
in a piston, as evidenced by higher EGTs)

  2) Reduction of waste heat lost to the housing due to the relatively
inefficient shape of the combustion area (long, wide, and very thin in a
rotary= lots of surface area-to-volume, relatively compact and
cylindrical in a piston engine=less surface area per volume.

It seems 1) could be reduced by turbocompounding, and 2) might be
somewhat reduced by optimizing the engine geometry, but real
improvements here await development of a practical ceramic engine or
other material breakthrough  (or some miracle way of recovering that
low-quality waste heat in the cooling water--very unlikely).

Mark W.

The higher EGT is due to the fact there are no exhaust valves
to absorb some of the heat. The RX8 engine is proof as the exhaust must
make a right angle to exit so some of that waste heat goes
into the cooling system and the EGT is a couple of hundred
degrees F cooler.

In the R3350 turbo compound engine 22% of the total energy in
the exhaust went into the exhaust valve. Almost 50% of the kinetic
energy went into the exhaust valve. That is why a rotary is so
noisy. It is also why it makes an ideal turbo compound engine.

I am beginning to think the old surface area to volume ratio reason
is invalid. Both the 16x and the Wankel SuperTec engines have
worse  surface area to volume ratios yet are more efficient
than the current geometry.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.