Subject: article in Kitplanes Why not the rotary
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/15/2011, 8:13 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,

Indeed there is interesting things going on, just hope to see the fruits
of it this lifetime.

The claim from Mazda that the rotary now are as efficient as the piston
engine is encouraging, but as always...we will see.

By running heavy fuel you will boost the efficency, the same as
comparison between gasoline and diesel engine, don't know if they are
running compression ignition though, like the dieselcycle on that engine
you described, usually it is a bit hard to ignite heavy fuel with a
sparkplug, so maybe they are actually running diesel compression.

Higher and higher compression gives a diminishing point of return. Raise
the compression from 5:1 to 7:1 and you will get a tremedeous good
return, raise it from 7:1 to 9:1 and you will get a decent return, raise
it from 9:1 to 11:1 and you will get a very small return.

Part of the gain is not from raising the compression in itself, but the
increased ability the engine will get, to clean out spent and inert gas
from it's last work stroke.
I can see two areas the rotary could need an improvement on, bigger
stroke, the stroke it has is very small, and are depending on the
difference in the center of the shaft to the center of the ofset roll
shaft each rotor is spinning around.

   From what I understand you are saying, they are working out the
geometry better now.

The up and down bobbing triangular center body. it doesnt describe a
true rotation, but changes it's position where the center of mass
will be shifting between two extremes, and as I understand, it is
made of steel, right now. If you take a body like that, everytime
two of  the three corners in the triangular centerbody , are on the
outside, the force inceases.

The energy it takes to change that mass back and forth between those
two main positions, got to be huge, ..as Newton says, everytime you change
direction, you pay for it in lost energy.

I don't know how it compare with forces in a piston engine other
than a lose comparison, as in a piston engine, the main mass that is
reciprocating is a steel rod, and an aluminum piston, part of the steel
rod is follwing the crank in a true circle,  the crank itself  is
follwing a true circle. You spin that up to maybe 3000 RPM, on freeay
speed, while the rotary has a much heavier piece that have a shorter
stroke, but much heavier mass, and perhaps twice the rotation...force
needed at twice the RPM is not linear, ...I dont know the exact
number as the baseline is an estimate, but I dont think that four
times the force is too much out of line.

If a rotary would be connected up to an electric motor, and the force
was measured to rotate it, the lower RPM bands would probably be very
good, , but the force needed to spin it in the upper bands  where the
rotary works best, must be terrible.

I can understand it is a matter of structural integrity, but the weight
on that tringular rotor has to come down, and I don't know what material
that is lighter that can substitute the steel and still dont have
fatigugue problems, as it is a critical component.

Titanium perhaps, or perhaps a steel casing filled with aluminum, either
way, that up and down bobbing piece of steel is stealing a lot of energy
to do that movement.

True rotating parts can conserve and store energy, and even if a piston
engine has a lot of parts to it that moves, actually most of it's
rotating mass are both balanced and in true rotation, the majority of
the moving mass in a rotary is not in true rotation,...therefore in
direct correlation to it's mass and speed, it will steal rotational
energy.... therefore to get a distinct leap of efficiency with the
rotary engine, the mass of that part has to come down drastically.

How to do it and still keep the structural integrity...I don't even want
to think about it.

I bet ya in fifteen years from now we can order from Edelbrock a rotary
replacement that is made of a material we can't pronounce.

Roger

"The up and down bobbing triangular center body."

There is no up and down Roger. A common mistake many make.
The rotor CG orbits around the center of the e-shaft much like
the earth orbits the sun. That is why it is sometimes called
a planetary engine. Have you read the Kitplanes article yet?

Here is a good one to read as well.

http://www.rotaryeng.net/how-wank-works.html

"Actually what is happening is the center or CG of the rotor is
moving in a circle around the center of the output shaft while the
output shaft rotates."

"Since there are no reciprocation parts what so ever it is possible
to completely balance the Wankel engine just like a turbine or
electric motor and unlike any piston engine despite some claims to
the contrary. The rotor is balanced around it own axis. The front
rotor balances the rear rotor as they are 180 degrees apart on the
output shaft. That leaves a small couple which is finally completely
balanced by the counter weights."

Also go on youtube  and watch many Wankel animations as there are
dozens.

The only limitations on the RPM of a rotary are due to centrifugal
load of the rotor weight on the e-shaft rotor bearing.

Paul Lamar

Just a comment here on "compression ratio."  My take is that it is
not as important as "expansion ratio."  If you look at the PV diagram
of the Otto cycle, that is where the work is done and the more you
let those hot gasses expand against the working surface (piston crown
or rotor face) the more work you get out of them.  Normally in piston
engine design both ratios are the same.  But you can play
tricks.  That is the trick employed by current manifestations of the
Atkinson cycle.  Build a piston engine with geometry that permits 12
to 14 to one expansion ratio and you get more work out of each
combustion event.  Then you trick the intake valve timing so the
effective compression ratio is enough lower to prevent detonation and
you are on the way to the efficiency of a diesel with light fuel and
a spark plug.

SD



Look up Mazda Skyactive G. 13:1 CR. The variable valve timing bleeds off
pressure at low RPM to control detonation. At high RPM the timing contains the
intake for more power. Supposed to be substantial power and economy gains.

Dale Davies

Sounds like WW I high altitude German fighter planes with two
throttle  levers :) Current race piston engines are running 14:1.

Same idea will work on the rotary. One just needs a valve
in the compression chamber that bleeds off pressure at
low RPM. That is also similar to the Atkinson cycle.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atkinson_cycle

Clever marketing and PR :)

Mazda already built and sold some of those supercharged piston engines
in the Millenia S but sales did not meet expectations and it was
discontinued.

http://townhall-talk.edmunds.com/direct/view/.ef21e99

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.