Compression ratio and expansion ratio.
Yes, the ideal would be to be able to catch every piece of work in
the heat cycle.
If we would have a ballon of indestructable material, fill it with
gasoline and air to the ratio we are using in engines, ignite it,
let it go bang, and let it expand, until the gasses by it's own
expansion, reaches peak expansion. We would have a pretty big
baloon now. then we would get a period of contraction, that will
continue until the hot gasses has cooled down to ambient
temperature. When we are done with that we will hold a smaller
baloon with all the burnt gasses from the original gasoline and
air charge, that will have ambient pressure and ambient temperature.
The trick is to catch all that work in any engine.
Here we get in to the world of compromizes.
We usually only catch a small part of that cycle, the high
pressure part, we don't even think of trying to catch the
contraction part, and there is good reasons for it.
The longer on the heat cycle we want to catch the pressure, the lower
and lower pressure we have to recover. The lower in the cycle we
want to go, the more expansion space we need to accomodate, but
also increase the internal volume of the engine, to accomodate for
the last pieces of pressure we need to recover.
This part is important as it will determine the size of an
engine. Lower pressure recovery on the cycle will add a time
factor to it also, and each combustion cycle will have to be
slower, with other words big displacement and low RPM.
The bigger dispacement the better heat recovery further down on
the pressure scale. a pressure of 5 PSI will not do much work on a
small piston surface, but if the surface is big enough to throw a
party on it, those 5 PSI will do a good work on that surface.
See it like this, if you have 55 engines that have a one gallon
displacement ( pretty big to start up with, but ok just to show)
and we have an engine with 55 gallon displacement, (oildrum size)
one can think that 55 one gallon engines will be as efficient as
one 55 gallon engine, but the thermal efficiency of the 55 gallon
engine is so much better.
It is a surface thing.
Take a cylinder surface that gives a one gallon displacement, and
flatten it out...now take 55 of those surfaces, and compare it
with the surface of a ONE 55 gallon oildrum, and you will find
that all those one gallon engine surfaces combined will be so much
more than the surface from one single 55 gallon drum.
That is a lot of heatsurfaces that heat will dissaper into, making
no work.
For those that have some interest in this, you can go to any
search engine, and look up The Worlds Biggest Diesel Engine, and
you will see a 14 cylinder Wirthsilla ship engine, built in Japan,
that is so big that there are handlebars going into the crankhouse.
It's doing tops 108 RPM and will produce over 100.000 HP, but the
fact that will connect this engine with this topic is that it is
over 50% thermal efficient.
Compression ratio and expansion ratio is , granted, two different
things, but very hard to practically distinguish.
For a while in EU especially a couple of decades after the war, some
countries, especially then France and England, had a tax system
on cars that put them in different tax categories depending on the
engine size.
( French CV system, had a Citroen CV2...great car) , now Britain
at the time had their engine tax size based on the bore size, with
the result that out of Britan around that era there was a lot of
small cars that came on the market, with very small bore and very
long stroke, in order to try to get more displacement out of the
engine for any given bore.
That, on the first look, might look like the perfect way to get a
longer expansion rate, but it just showed that those engines were
running with very high piston speed., and was very limited
engines. Oversquared engines, ( stroke longer than the bore
diameter) , have inherently a higher wear and tear, especially on
piston, piston rings, and bore.
Undersquared engines, (bore bigger than the stroke) can rev
higher and still have decent piston speed, and will be able to
exchange gas more often, thus do more work, thus give more power,
thus can be made smaller and more lightweight etc etc, so engines
that are square or undersquare have more development possibility,
and the long stroked engines from the post war European tax
environment existed only because of tax incentives, and had less
technical base for it's existence.
There was if I remeber the timeline right, a debate 15 or 18
years ago on this particular issue in Hot Rod circles, where the
proponents of stroked engines held onto the position that they
were more "torque" engines, ( to translate, more efficent in
follow the whole heatcycle), and that lead to some to test the
theory back and forth ( hey it has been tested long before that,
but to some Hot Rodeers, you can't tell them anything, they have
to reinvent the wheel), and of course they came up with the
conclusion that was long known....a stoked engine is getting it's
increased power from increased displacement, not a better heat cycle,, if you
increase the dispacement from a bore or a stroke you will
get some smaller differences in engine caracteristics, but
basically you will get the same result.
Compression ratio and expansion ratio is so closely related that
it is hard to distinguish the two in practical applications.
Because of the fuel we use, we can't go up on the compression
ratio that much. A continous increased compression ratio will give
diminishing results. If you raise it from 4:1 to 6 :1 you will get
excellent return. If you rasie it from 10:1 to 12:1, you will
hardly get any return, still in both occasions you raised the
compression ratio two points.
A combustion engine runs ( depending on gasoline, rotary, or
diesel) in the 25 to 35% efficiency range , some better some worse.
It is a choice we are doing, if we want to catch high pressure
often, and release the remaining pressure, if we instead can
quickly grab another high pressure to catch for a while, that
makes for a small and compact source of high power.
Or if we want to try to catch more of the heat cycle, in a bigger
( much bigger preferably) and slower cycling engine.
We could theoretically make an engine that goes through the whole
heat cycle, and even catch the inherent energy from the
condensation part and thus get vaccum.
1 unit of water will produce a volume of about 1850 units of hydrogen
and oxygen gas. Feed it into an engine and ignite,...the hydrogen
and oxygen combines in a bang, and makes superheated steam, the
piston goes down, cools down the charge, and we get condensation,
and the original 1850 units of gas ( now burned and expanded even
more) will now go back to it's original 1 unit of water, and we
get a vaccum, that could act upon a piston to "suck it up" , to
TDC and we could start the cycle again.
Problem is, this is something that maybe has to be big enough
that you could walk on the top of the piston, and the cycle has to
be , maybe 2 or 3 RPM. Remember at the end of the expansion phase
the time factor increases, the fist part of expansion is a flash,
but the last part of expansion is a snail.
If we only catch the first part of the expansion, the powerful
flash, and can do it over and over, very quick, we will get a
small powerful engine ( that we can fly with)
So the point I am getting to is that while it is in itself a
worth while operation to try to catch as much as possible from the
heat cycle, ( and there is a lot of gizmos, hop ups and other
things out there from a horde of people, or companies that are
trying their best to do so, ) doing it in the engine itself, is
very hard, if the engine has to do what it has to do.
It's originally designed to catch only the very first part of the
powerful heat cycle. Even if there is more left of the heat cycle,
the design is not there to catch it.
If we want something that is designed with the effort of trying
to catch a whole heat cycle, you have to design something else. It
can't look like our small compact high rev high power piston or
rotary engines.
Most efforts on the aftermarket or industry developments are
aimed at either increasing the pressure, or to make the current
heat pressure window more efficent, not prolonging the effort to
catch the whole heat cycle.
Improvements can be made and are made, but the development seems
to be incremental, and in small steps at a time.
The piston engine that have had a 100 year development history
from Fords Tin Lizzy to todays engines have never in it's history
made a giant leap at any point in history. (you got 20 mpg in a
model T).
Despite electronics, better machining and better material, the effciency
numbers our forefathers was tossing to each other, is not far fetced
numbers today. The engines ARE better today, but there are no gigant
leaps here. the basic original design is pretty much the same.
Most engines to be practial for us has to be small, lightweight have
high rev, catch the high pressure part of the heat cycle, dismiss
the low pressure part, ( could be used to spool a turbo......why
not an alternator) , and continue to catch the high pressure part
of the cycle, and do it often....thus we have the powerplant we want.
So if we want what we want, we have to waste or sacrifice some
things....the low pressure...and as is easily recognizeable, it's
still part of the heat cycle that powers the engine. However the
heat cycle have now change personality, from being Arnold
Schwartsenegger in the engine, it is now a sick noisy smelly bum,
that is hard to get any work out of...so we waste him.
If it is unbearable to live with that,...well guess it is time to
order your Wirtsilla 14 cyl diesel, then at least you will get
over the 50% efficiency number.
Roger
We are not designing new engines here. We are mainly installing
Wankel engines in aircraft and dealing with the associated accessory
problems such as cooling, intake configurations, fuel systems and
ignition.
Something the average home builder must and can deal with.
Paul Lamar
Roger
A good explanation of the heat cycle... and the reason why Paul is so
adamant about
turbocompounding the waste heat of the exhaust cycle to get a 20%
increase in efficiency.
Dan F
I must admit we have been having some interesting discussions about a couple
of topics. This is in my mind how innovation gets a jump start.
The latest Road and Track has an article on the Hennesy Venom. Yes I know this
is about rotor motors in AC. Hennesy's crew had done one thing and were then
considering what next. The Lotus Exige came up and was at first passed by.
Someone did a drawing and a few days later they came up with the idea to put a
1200 HP twin turbo in. Now can you imagine that car with a turbo compound 20B.
Or get really silly and turbo compound an all Al 26B? Now that might give a
slight green tint to the skin!
Dale Davies
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.