Subject: Too much mass on the left?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/17/2011, 12:15 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,

I live in central Ca, closest airport is Columbia, next closest is
Angels Camp or Calaveras airport.  Closest town is Sonora.

You showed a model of a rotary that has two counter rotating rotaries,
...no that's not what I ment.

I ment the forces that are occurring in one unit.

I ment the forces that are occurring between the components of the basic
unit.

One centershaft....one eccentric shaft....one rotary.

If two units are mounted opposite to each other, they will off course
balance each other out. they will balance out in the same sense as if
we were to put pistons in a piston engine opposing each other, but the
reciprocating force is still there, and if there is a reciprocating
force , even if they balance each other out, it is a force that will
increase with RPM, and that is the issue here.

.....so sorry you misunderstood me here,...no I am not talking about a
possibility to balance out an engine with an opposed piston or rotary,
 lets go back to ONE rotary.....I am looking at the forces that is
existing in it's basic configuration.

Put it in left position, and put the rotary with the flat side towards
left,  ( two horns out) and you will have more mass to the left of
the CENTER ROTATING SHAFT than you will if you put the rotary in the
position where it has one horn out.

Paul, it's of no use to say that you'r sorry that I don't understand,
and refere me to more pictures or models those will only will reinforce
my observation.

You have been working with this for years and years and years, and have
come to an understanding of this engine that may be granted to very few
people, and I see something that, as I see it, is contrary but obvious
and uncompromisable.

With the long and exhaustive experience you have with the rotary, I am
up against authority here, but still, as my observation differs, I can't
deny my own understanding of it.

I think we are passed videos and plastic models, and need to talk. The
blog is just too limited at this stage. ( I also want to ask you about
the 555 system a bit at the same time)

Because of what I work with, I am up very much at night, sometimes to
early morning hours...do you have a phone number I can reach you on.

Roger

They don't counter rotate. They both rotate in the same direction.
The two rotor is basically two one rotors 180 degrees out of phase
on the same eccentric shaft. They static balance each other.

There is no difference in the way they work. The forces are
the same. The one rotor is easy to balance as the two counter
weights just balance the weight of the rotor and the eccentric
lobe. There is no couple. The only forces we must deal with are
centrifugal forces on the rotor moving in a circle around the
center of the e-shaft.

"Put it in left position, and put the rotary with the flat side towards
left,  ( two horns out) and you will have more mass to the left of
the CENTER ROTATING SHAFT than you will if you put the rotary in the
position where it has one horn out."

Yes but that does not matter. I say so what? :)
The eccentric lobe will be out there too.

I suddenly see your problem understanding this.

You are forgetting the one rotor balance weights on the other side
of the e-shaft  center. The one rotor balance weights are always
opposite the eccentric lobe. When you put one horn out so
too will be the balance weights but no eccentric lobe.

Unfortunately there are a lot of one rotor animations out there that
don't show the counter weights so it is easy to get confused.

The CG of the rotor and it's total mass is all the e-shaft sees.
The rotor is balanced about its center at the factory.

Why a triangle is in balance about it's center is another subject.

I don't know of anybody in that neck of the woods with a rotary.
Perhaps I am wrong and somebody will speak up that has some
engine parts they can show off.


Paul Lamar

Hey Roger,

What you are seeing is true.  Parts of the rotor do experience
acceleration and deceleration in relation to the rest of the engine
assembly.

Try to think of it like a tire on a car.  The tire rotates about it's
center of gravity, if it hasn't lost one of it's balance weights ;-) ,
causing no vibration in the vehicle.  If you pick a spot on the surface
of the tire as it turns and trace that spot as the car goes by you can
see that the spot starts out next to the ground and is thus not moving
at all in relation to the ground.  When the tire rotates 180 degrees
that spot is now on the side of the tire that is opposite the ground.
If the car is going 60 MPH then that spot will be moving forward at 120
MPH relative to the ground.  There is a large acceleration of that one
spot as it rotates up the back side of the tire.

Now the spot must decelerate from 120 MPH back down to zero in the next
180 degrees of rotation.  The energy absorbed by the acceleration on the
back side of the tire is exactly equal to the energy paid back in the
deceleration on the front side.

This effect can clearly be seen in a video of a tire taken by a camera
attached to the vehicle.  At speed the tire is far from round as it
responds to the changing forces.  The rear side and front side of the
tire bulge while the top and bottom are compressed.

The same effect is present inside the rotary engine.  The rotor is
spinning about it's center of gravity, just like the tire on the car,
while at the same time it is orbiting around the center of the E shaft.
There is no vibration imparted to the E shaft, same as there is no
vibration imparted to the axle shaft as the car goes down the road.  The
forces within the rotor are in symmetry.

There is a force applied to the E shaft.  It is the centrifugal force
generated by the mass of the rotor orbiting around the E shaft.  The
rotation of the rotor about it's own center of gravity has no effect on
the E shaft.  As far as the E shaft is concerned the rotor could be
fixed to the E shaft and rotating with it.  Of course that wouldn't make
for a very efficient engine as the rotor would just be describing a
circle.  Consider the rotor to round like the tire.  The E shaft doesn't
know that the rotor is a triangle.  It just feels the unchanging mass of
the rotor pulling on the shaft.

The force applied to the E shaft is always directed through the
eccentric from the low side toward the high side.  In a single rotor
engine that force is balanced by placing counter weights on the E shaft
in front and behind the rotor in such a way as to avoid creating a
couple.  In a two rotor engine the rotors are 180 out of phase.  The
result is a couple were the forward rotor would be pushing the front of
the engine assembly up while the rear rotor would be pushing the rear of
the engine assembly down.  This couple will rotate with the E shaft, not
the rotors.  It is balanced again by placing counter weights on the E
shaft front and rear.

Again, like the tire, parts of the rotor experience acceleration and
deceleration relative to the rest of the engine assembly but do not
experience any acceleration/deceleration in relation to the rest of the
rotor.  The rotor is just spinning around it's center of gravity just
like the tire.  It's tough to get your head around.

Mark LaPierre

That is a great explanation Mark. Thanks.

I am going to add that to How The Rotary Works and give
you credit for it if you don't mind. If you do mind I'll
just plagiarize it :)

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.