Subject: torsional vibration
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/17/2011, 12:54 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Now that torsional vibration is being discussed let's get back to the
 single rotor version. Does anyone know what would be a satisfactory
 torsional vibration damper for these as they don't have the overlapping
 power pulses from the other rotor to smooth things out i.e. how much
 flywheel do they need?

 I note that Richard Sohn uses a Hirth reduction box on his - I think
 they use a rubber dough nut like the Rotax 2 stroke reductions?

 Are the rubber isolators used by Tracey suitable for the frequencies
 of a single rotor, let alone the increased amplitude with no
 overlapping
 power strokes?

 It would be nice if the collected wisdom on single rotors was available
 in one place, after all about 100 to 120 HP (Rotax 912 to 914
 territory) is commonly needed for very light aircraft. I must admit
 I'm not all that impressed with my 912, it only has 29.9 hours on it,
 the fuel pump failed - leaked oil, coolant seems to ooze out
 everywhere, and after all it still has exhaust valves to fail. I've
 just discovered a pinhole exhaust pipe leak that was burning the
 paint on the engine mount, it's not that far from fuel and oil
 lines. Just what I need, an in-flight fire:( I think my old Subaru
 E$A 81 is better engineered and cheaper.

 John Evans
 (Heretic)

 I think you are going to have to make your own.
 Tracy's system works well for a two rotor but a one rotor
 fires half as often. Tracy's system allows the engine to idle
 down to 1500 RPM. That should be your target idle RPM.

 I would use his general design and increase the diameter
 of the rubber bushings and use a lower Durometer rubber.
 Silicone rubber is called for as it has a higher heat tolerance.
 A lot of heat will be going into the rubber.
 You can make the bushings out of silicone rubber sheet
 from McMaster. Allow a bit of expansion room.

 There may also be an off the shelf off road rear wheel
 motor cycle part that might work.

 The Centeflex is too stiff and they don't make a much softer
 one.

 Paul Lamar

 Don't forget that the rotors still have longer time per cycle than a
 piston
 engine. 270* instead of 180* that helps torsional vibration.

 Check Chrysler products for a damper similar to the one in
 Attachement 4. It
 is used on the drive shaft instead of a U-joint. Chrysler 300, Jeep
 Gr. Cherokee.

 Dale Davies

 Generally that type is too stiff. The have a resonant frequency around
 2000 RPM. A two rotor is firing 4000 times per minute or
 66 CPS or 66 Hertz in the metric system. The one rotor would
 be half that.

 Paul Lamar


 So is Richard using the Hirth "doughnut"?

 John Evans

 Yes I think so.

 You could pack it in dry ice and drill six 1/2 inch holes
 to soften it up.

 Paul Lamar

 There are a lot of doughnuts available (bolt patterns, circle diameter)
 various vehicles (BMW, mercedes) and engineered (lord...) versions for
 industrial equipment.Look up "guibo" or "flex disc".
 I've heard many of the cheap automotive knock-offs do not last as long.
 Many of the automotive versions are fiber reinforced and quite stiff.
 With some googling you should find catalogs from manufacturers such as
 "Lemforder" with a selection of off the shelf sizes, materials and
 durometers.

 For all of the weight freaks out there.
 I looked at additional weight savings as part of a custom redrive using
 a flex disc or bushings bolted to the rear counterweight with a button
 race clutch /ring gear and starter. I never found a perfect match that
 did not require some customization.
 If someone is doing custom rotors, this might be the opportunity to
 redesign the rear counterweight for a different bolt size/pattern with a
 more secure through nut and bolt configuration.
 You could probably save another 5+ pounds in the process. Even more
 with one of those machined adapter plates, a custom casting or an
 adapted S5 auto transmission bellhousing.
 BTW, those flexplate bolts can back off. The amount of energy is
 impressive if they decide to depart and go airborne. Lock wire or
 Loctite them.

 Cheers
 Cary

 Lemforder wants to sell a car part number with no specs
 on the rubber coupling. We need input on stiffness and max torque.
 Same thing for guibo which apparently is the BMW coupling.
 Same thing for flex disc. They just want to sell you a new one.

 We need OEM type data. Perhaps you can find it and send
 a link.

 We can get that type of data from Centaflex.
 http://www.centa.info/?show=downloads&c=mx#
 <http://www.centa.info/?show=downloads&c=mx#
 <http://www.centa.info/?show=downloads&c=mx#
 <http://www.centa.info/?show=downloads&c=mx#

 There might be something in there somewhere but it is
 wearing me out converting metric to English :)

 CENTAFLEX design X

 We need about 300 newton meters or about 200 foot
 pounds. That indicates a size 16 which has a max RPM
 of only 6000. That is the size Rotomax used and it is
 no where near soft enough or fast enough for a
 p-port one rotor. (7500 RPM)

 Give them a try. They are the world leader with
 a dozen variations


 Paul Lamar


 Paul

 This idea will require a little engineering but may save a little
 weight.
 Is there an advantage to putting the flex part on the e-shaft and
 coupling that to a (lighter) flywheel attached to the PSRU input shaft?

 Dan F

 Fly wheels always help but unfortunately they weigh.

 The prop acts like a huge flywheel on the end of a shaft and
 that becomes part of the problem.

 Paul Lamar


 Paul

 Guess I should think more, then type :) It is the harmonics we must
 control.
 Would the above idea make this easier? PowerSport solved this by using
 short,
 stiff (and somewhat heavy) parts. I prefer about 14" from the endplate
 to the
 (pusher) prop flange which fits the planetary design very well. Should
 we be
 concerned about 2 vs 3 blade props?

 I talked to a vibration analysis company at AirVenture last year. About
 $6,000 for
 the equipment and training on-site. All harmonics are mapped, right down
 to the
 planet gear bearings. Does anyone have one of these units? A great
 way to
 proof a design before flying... and less expensive than ground testing
 for 200 hours.

 Dan F

 3 blade props seem to be smother.

 Air coming off the back of the prop is pulsing.
 With a fast enough pressure sensor you can see it.
 This pulse impinges on the windshield and transmits sound
 waves into the cabin. Moral thick windshields are quieter.

 Paul Lamar

Dan F, I'm not an Engineer and I don't know a lot about harmonics, but I
understand that the set up you propose would result in an awful dogfight
which would rapidly destroy any damper you put in there.
My understanding is that the role of the flywheel is to absorb torsional
pulses so that they can be smoothed out and given back as energy on the
output side, any professional opinions out there??
When I was a kid my Dad built his own lathe using treadle power, he
would pump the treadle with his foot to put the energy into a flywheel,
this would give him a few seconds to concentrate on his turning job
before he had to pump it again.
As Paul has pointed out a torsional vibration damper absorbing energy
gets quite hot - the energy has to go somewhere, so in that case it's
lost as heat.

John Evans
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.