Subject: Apex seal motions and wear.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/18/2011, 3:38 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Hello Roger,

 The rotor accelerates and slows down as it rotates around the
 stationary gear and e-shaft. This acceleration and decelleration are
 much less that in a piston engine. Take note that the rotor is only
 rotating at 3000RPM while the e-shaft is at 9000 RPM. In a piston
 engine, the rods and pistons are reversing motion up and down the
 cylinder twice per revolution. The forces are outrageous! The piston
 that weighs very little in your hand is like tons at 7000RPM. It is
 trying to pull the rod apart or pile drive it shorter. The rod has
 force that is trying to make a skipping rope out of it.

 A Wankel is not basically a two stroke cycle engine. It has four
 individual
 events happening in different parts of the rotor housing. They are
 all happening at the same time. That is part of the efficiency of
 size advantage. Give another 100 years development to the Wankel
 which is the head start the piston engine has and you will likely
 see a different story.

 The Hydrogen economy is years (decades) away. The safety and
 infrastructure
 requirements are immense hurdles to over come. How often have you
 seen someone filling up their auto while dialing a cell phone? The
 explosive limits for gasoline are fairly narrow. H2 has a broad
 explosive limit range. If there were to be a leak while refueling it
 is pretty much guaranteed to have a Hindenburg incident at the pump.
 There was an oilfield worker around here entered a building with gas
 present in the atmosphere. The static charge in his coveralls
 ignited it and he was burned. He lived to talk about it.

 The only reasons to develope lighter rotors is to make the engine assembly
 lighter and to increase the RPM limit. With a Ti rotor, you could
 use a 3.3:1 PSRU and have the same internal stresses as there are
 now. That would give about 310HP for cruise instead of 250HP. I do
 not think the fuel burn would increase that much. Yes, HP is a
 result of the combustion, but experience with my RX3 and forgetting
 to shift tells me this is so.

 Dale Davies

 "The rotor accelerates and slows down as it rotates around the
 stationary gear and e-shaft."

 Not true Dale. No acceleration. Sorry:)

 Paul Lamar

 Sorry Paul,

 Incorrect description. As the apex seal passes over the rotor housing
 upper or
 lower areas, the surface speed will be slightly higher than when in
 the narrow
 part. The rotational velocity is constant. It is a function of the
 radius, as
 the radius increases the surface speed increases. This is very minor
 compared
 to a piston engine's piston speed change from 0 at TDC and BDC, and at 90*
 before or after.

 Dale Davies

 Yes that does happen.

 There are also inertial forces on the apex seal.

 That is why there is a small amount of wear
 on the apex seals sides and on the slots in the rotor.

 I think that wear is very little but it is there. Engines with
 300,000 miles on them probably have a measurably amount.
 High boost engines are more likely to accelerate the wear.

 The slots can be ground out for 3 mm seals instead of 2 mm
 seals.

 I have not run an engine for a long time with silicon Nitride
 seals but my guess is the wear would be less. I advocate
 chroming just the slot.

 BTW Some of the shade tree rotary racing mechanics
 very carefully close up the slots using a hammer to compensate
 for the wear :)

 Mazda induction hardens just ends of the slot in the RX8
 rotor. The entire slot could be induction hardened if found
 necessary.

 Paul Lamar

Many apex seals have measurable wear long before 300k miles.
The bigger problem seems to be Vee'ing of the slot in the soft iron
rotors, particularly with turbos.
I think Lynn has mentioned a few tricks to restore proper tolerances on
deformed apex slots if you really want to re-use rotors with out of spec
or Vee'd slot clearance - or an engineered hammer ;)

Cheers
Cary

The secret is use Mobile 1 as it does not gum up at 500 F.
What are the tricks other than a hammer?
I have not heard from Lynn for awhile. Lynn what are
the apex seal slot closer tricks?

Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,

I think the guys over in Oz widen the slots using spark
Erosion ( the finish is awesome ) I think the rotor may
Be cryogenically treated in nitrogen after.

Chris in NZ

The smooth finish in the slot is very very important
for good sealing.

BTW if you want to convinced yourself about synthetic oils
verses mineral oils put a tea spoon full in an empty cat food can
in the oven at 500 F for half and hour. No cat? No problem. use
a tuna fish can. Makes sure you do it when the wife is
not home and open all the kitchen windows :)

Here is our test for two cycle oils. Mix a teaspoon
full with a teaspoon of gasoline and light it. What is left,
if any, will wind up in the apex seal slots or stuck to
the rotor :)

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.