Paul,
I was looking at the Sonex site and the info they have regarding their
AeroCarb and AeroInjector products.
Among the items in their FAQ page (
http://www.aeroconversions.com/products/aerocarb/aerocarbfaq.html#aeroinjector_efi
):
"Can I Install the AeroCarb/AeroInjector on a Two-Stroke Engine?
Answer: The AeroCarb/AeroInjector is not a good fit for two-stroke
engines because of their reliance on oil mixed in the fuel for
lubrication, and we do not sell the AeroCarb/AeroInjector for two-stroke
Installation. Back in the 1970s and 80s our company used similar Lake
Injector carbs with much success on the Monnett Moni and Monerais
two-stroke powerplants, but there is significant danger of instantly
seizing-up the engine if the mixture is leaned too much, and we've seen
less-experienced builders do just that. Even setting-up the
AeroCarb/AeroInjector to run a two-stroke engine for the first time is
very perilous, and once running, an instant of over-leaning will
immediately ruin a two-stroke engine."
--end quote --
I'm sure the folks at Sonex would like to sell as many of these units as
they can, so they must have a pretty good reason to tell all those Rotax
owners not to buy this product from them. Now, I know the Wankel isn't
a two stroke, but most of us are counting on oil in the fuel for
internal lubrication. Is there anything about the observation above
that might apply to efforts to build a successful injection system for
our engines? Maybe special considerations to limit the amount of
leaning possible so there's always enough lube entering the rotor
housing under any condition?
Just wondering.
Mark W.
We do it all the time. Most rotaries flying with Tracy's EFI mix
2 stroke oil with the fuel.
I have no idea what their problem is. Perhaps the aluminum
piston is seizing in the air cooled steel bore.
Paul Lamar
Paul, I think they are referring to the 2 stroke to almost instantly blow
a hole in a piston if it is leaned too much, as the oil smoke does not
seem to lessen (until the dreaded coast down with no compression), don't
ask how I know:-[ .
John Burey
There is something fishy with all this. 2Strokes are an animal of it's
own, granted, but fuel delivery to 2 strokes mixing oil in the fuel ,
have never been rocket science. If the sellers of this product have seen
pilots made a bad mix and burned up their engine, they could have done
so with any carb, or injection system.
It's a bit unclear if they don't sell them to 2 stoke applications, and
they are referring the rotary as being a two stroke, and thus will not
sell it for that application, based on no sales to 2 strokes. It didn't
come across that way, but as the problem are discussed on the same issue
with regards to rotaries, delivery of oil, ..I don't know if they
generalize that to any engine that have oil delivery with it's fuel.
I don't know why they would say that they don't sell the unit to engines
dependent on oil delivery with the fuel, as an explanation of why some
pilots have leaned their two strokes too much and burned up their
engines. That is two different issues.
I guess, if a dog has two ears, four legs, and a tail................a
zebra is a dog.
Dunno about this system, it is a throttle body type injection system,
....as such it is probably better than a carburetor, but port injection
will be much more efficient anyway however you slice it.
Any system that can deliver fuel as close as possible to the intake,
will , just by the nature of the beast, be the superior system, because
fuel and air is very hard , practically impossible, to lead together,
and at the same time maintain the original mix.
It doesn't matter if the throttle body is named Jet, Super, Quantum Leap,
and is made of titanium and gold and by Swiss clock precision
instruments, and designed ( with an engraved signature) by someone with
an Italian name. ....you still, with that system, have to fill the
intake manifold with air and fuel mix, and therein is the problem.
I don't say it is bad, it will beat a carburetor, and these people may
very well have a very good product per se, all I am saying is that in a
comparison between the two systems, a ported FI is superior.
Roger
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2010 All world wide rights reserved.