Subject: 2 stroke oil in the oil pan
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/26/2011, 12:31 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



 I am aware of the fragility of the oil lines used by Mazda from their
 oil metering pump to the point of injection, but is that a good reason
 to do away with the pump for aircraft use? I suppose if you're a belt
 and braces (suspenders) person it might be a good idea to run the pump
 and add oil to the fuel as well. I understand that some 2 stroke oils
 remain mixed better than others so surely the pump could be more
 reliable, particularly if the Antipodean habit of using 2 stroke oil in
 the sump is followed. There seems to be some strange belief out there
 that 2 stroke oils are in some way inferior to the usual heavily
 advertised engine oils that leave all sorts of deposits when burnt.

 John Evans

 That is one good reason but another is mixing spreads the oil
 better in the rotor housing. There is no doubt in my mind
 that synthetic oils, and two stroke oils are in that category, are
 better. If in doubt give it the 500 degree F oven test.
 The apex seals run 500 F at full chat.

 Paul

 Our house is regularly inspected by the neighbor's cat, his name is
 Diesel, but as I don't feed him I haven't any cat food tins.
Furthermore
 my courage fails me when I contemplate the oven test you recommend:).
 I'm not sure of its relevance anyway.

 Two stroke oil is designed to burn cleanly and leave minimal deposits,
 some are better than others in this regard.
 "Crankcase" oils on the other hand are not designed to be burnt in the
 quantities required in a rotary so they do tend to leave deposits.
 Antipodean experience shows that under racing (or for that matter road)
 conditions 2 stroke oil is satisfactory in rotaries, and is apparently
 generally used.

 Of course there is the possibility that conditions are different in the
 Southern Hemisphere, perhaps it's Coriolis effect? Seriously, there
 remains the possibility that motor racing does not raise the tip seal
 temps as high as aviation use, but then dyno tuning would be similar to
 aircraft use, so why doesn't 2 stroke oil gum up the tip seals as
in the
 recommended oven test?

 I know it's inconvenient to have someone asking these questions, but if
 this site is to have any resemblance to using "scientific method" we
 must be prepared to put up with this and enjoy the challenge of
bouncing
 stuff off each other.
 John Evans

John,

Since you don't have a cat and you are not brave enough to
cook some oil I suggest another test.

Heat a small chunk of steel in the oven at 500 F
for half and hour.

Remove the steel.

Quickly Measure the temperature with one of those
low cost infrared thermometers.

Quickly poor a teaspoon of oil on the steel while measuring
the temperature.

Note the temperature of the steel one minute later.

The main function of the 2 cycle oil is to cool the apex
seals.

Try any oil you wish including used cooking oil.

Make sure you test 5 W Mobile 1.


Paul Lamar



Paul,It seems to me we are talking about two different oil
requirements in a rotary engine. The sump oil being indemso (sp?) for
lubricating bearings and removing heat from the rotating assembly, and
2-stroke oil for combustion chamber lubrication.


I see where the
temperature of apex seals goes up depending on lubrication quantity. It
looks like from the above attachments that the temperaturerise is the
result of metal to metal contact between the cast iron seal and the
chrome liner. Intuitively the oil film layer separating the parts is not
replaced as fast as it is consumed. I like the idea of mixing the oil
into the fuel because it has a chance to coat the entire exposed metal
areas in the combustion area. Of course some of it never touches any
metal and just becomes additional fuel.

Just looking at animations it
isn't clear about the lubrication of the side seals useing the stock oil
injection pump alone. These seals must also avoid metal to metal
contact. The only apparent source for their lubrication seems to be the
film left by the wiping action of the oil seals on the side faces of the
rotor. Without the injection pump this would remain the same, and with
fuel mix would give a marginally better lubrication. The fact that side
housings have a wear pattern in the area where combustion/expansion
strokes occur indicates that more lubrication would be a benefit. I like
the "blendzall" 2-stroke oil because it stays in suspension better which
is probably not a concern in a car driven daily but in an aircraft
depending on how the fuel is picked up in the headrer tank it might be.


Without a header tank the oil at the bottom of the tanks would be
injected leaving less to remix with the remaining fuel.
 It is my understanding that the stock injection pump function
is to allow a measured amount of oil to be drawn in by the engine at the
injector orifices and that it doesn't actually put pressure on the oil.
If this is correct could we still attach pressure taps for an
EC-3to this location and get a useable signal since the oil is pretty
much incompressable and directly exposed to the pressure pulse.


 Is the pressure tap location chosen to avoid the resonant pressure
waves running up and down the intake runners giving erratic signals
depending on whether a high or lowerpressurearea is at the tap when
the sample is taken.Is a representative PULSE what we need or
a CONTINUOUS signal like from an intake manifold at some point away from
the intake runner. If a MAF sensor is used the signal is continuous. I
can see a pulsed signal working with a MAP sensor as long as the sample
point is timednear theaverage point of the rising and falling
pressure which would require the computer to count teeth on the trigger
wheel for a sample point. If the sample is just taken at a fixed
frequency it seems difficult to predictthe fuel requirement.If the use
of the injection pump makes this sample point unuseable then it is a
matter of balancing the benefit of the oil compared to signal quality
from a different sample location.

 For a carburetor installation with the injection pump left
functional is there a tested method of supplying the metering pump from
a tank of 2-stroke oil rather than the oil coming from the engine oil
pressure feed. Would this require something like a holly gear pump type
fuel pump or just gravity feed.Personally I would prefer fuel mix and
the injection pump. The idea being that oil through the injection holes
would be scraped up by the passing seal with a large percent of it
getting on the seal.Useing both lubrication sources in a car
installation has been reported to have 300kmiles before overhaul and
with the higher continuous load of an aircraft installation
 this seems to be of even more benefit.

george grimes

We have had people forget to put oil in the fuel and then fly
the airplane 500 miles with no apparent damage. In other words
they continued to fly the airplane.

Idemitsu formulated the oil for both purposes. Mazda cannot expect
to have car owners mixing oil with the fuel or having a separate
reservoir for 2 cycle apex seal oil.

Therefor Idemitsu is probably not ideal for either purpose.
Jack of all trades master of none.

It is well known that
Mobile 1 works well in all sorts of engines and it is a full
synthetic. I use it in my piston engine cars as well. The wife
is not allowed to drive the RX8 so she has her own car with
Mobile 1 in it. I have not tested other brands of synthetics using
the 500 degree oven bake test so I can't comment.

There are hot spots
in any engine well above the oil temperature. One of the main
ones is the exhaust valve stem temperature. The temp of the metal
can be up to 1400 F. If Mobile 1 can work in this environment it
will work anywhere.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.