Subject: 2 stroke oil in the oil pan new gear box
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/28/2011, 2:17 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 Don't forget the temperature factor. You could heat your
 steel test wheels to 500 F.

 I don't recommend 2 stroke oil in gear boxes. Use high pressure
 gear oil. It is designed for that purpose. Tracy is getting away with
 high temperature crankcase oil in his gear boxes which is a testimony
 for the durability of the Ford planetary set that is used in auto
 transmission. Auto TX's normally use ATF which I suspect is needed
 for the friction and clutch packs found in auto tx's.

 I also don't recommend it's use in the oil pan as two stroke engines
 do not have plain journal bearings. 2 strokes use roller and ball
 bearings. Oils are designed for specific purposes. Trust the oil
 engineers. They know what they are doing.

 Paul Lamar


 I concur with Paul, trust the engineers. Bean counters is another
 kettle of
 fish. Automatic oil is I believe a synthetic these days. The
 different specks
 are for different clutch materials. An old trick was to put 1 qt of
 Type F in
 the Hydramatics to get the clutches to grab a bit quicker. Kind of like
 a
 shift kit. It had a different friction coeficient than the Dexron. I
 would be
 inclined to use the appropriate Ford type oil in the PSRU. Due to the
 duty
 cycle being high in AC use compared to automotive, a fairly large
 cooler would
 be mandated along with a temp gauge. 250* F is MAX with 200* being
 optimum.

 Put the too smoke oil in the gas where it belongs and synthetic in
 the sump.

 Dale Davies

 Fair go fellers! Let's keep this a bit rational, where are the clutches
 in Tracey's PSRU???
 You want me to do the high temp oil film strength testing. Why? That's
 already been done in rotaries Down Under for many years with great
 success by running them on 2 stroke oil.
 I spoke to my Mileage Marathon Champion friend yesterday. He says that
 he was advised by Shell Oil Engineers many years ago that 2 stroke oils
 were best in rotaries. Perhaps the Oil Engineers do know what's best:).

 Look I'm not an Engineer, but even I know that point and linear contact
 bearings (as you rightly point out are used in 2 strokes) are more
 demanding of their lubricants than plain journal bearings.
 One of the surprises of our testing was that the oil film strength of
 the 90 gear oil was not higher than that.

 I am amazed and disappointed at these intellectually dishonest
 objections, they are side issues, If you want to debunk our honest
 findings repeat the tests - with heat if you wish, but I doubt if it
 will make much difference as as there was plenty of heat generated by
 increasing friction as the oil films broke down.
 Remember we only went to the trouble of doing these objective tests
 because the information was not available. There's plenty of hype out
 there to convince the gullible that one brand is better than
 another but
 very little real evidence.
 SHOW ME THE EVIDENCE.
 John Evans

 Nobody said Tracy was using clutches in his PSRU. What I said, or
 meant to say, or meant to imply, engine oil is not the best for gears.

 John, nobody is forcing you not to use 2 stroke oil in your rotary.
 I am just not ready to assume it is better for the rotary "crankcase"
 and therefor I am not going to recommend it. If you recommend it
 that is up to you. Racing is not exactly like powering airplanes.
 Thousands if not hundreds of thousands have been using Mobile 1
 in the rotary engine "crankcase" on the street and at the race track.

 If 2 stroke really was better why did Idemitsu spend millions
 developing
 rotary engine oil? Why not have Mazda just tell everybody they
 need 2 stroke oil for their RX8s?


 Paul Lamar

 Paul,
 I agree with you 110% on using the best synthetic oil (mobile 1 or
 amsoil)
 in the crankcase and mixing 2 stroke oil in the fuel to lube the
 apex seals.
 The gear reduction we are building will only be using Aeroshell 555.
 This
 turbine engine lube is also the specified lube for modern high loaded
 helicopter planetary gear reductions, and has similar viscosity to
 the ATF
 the gear sets were designed to run in. To run anything else seems
 silly...
 as many lives depend on this oil in gearboxes around the world.
 That's all
 the testing I need.
 That's my 2 cents.....
 Larry


 Fwiw, I loved the smell of blendzall coming out the exhaust of dirt
 bikes. Nothing like it., sort of like enjoying a good cigar.

 Larry, my next major aircraft purchase will be the reduction unit for my
 cozy 4. What exactly are you building? Will it be for a 2 rotor?

 Ed Carver

 Yes I need a new 2.85:1 for my RV4.

 Paul Lamar

 Paul and Ed,
 2.72 reduction gear drive. hydraulic prop gov, self contained oiling
system.
 Right now it only fits our engine configuration and would be lot of
work to
 adapt to a stock rear housing.
 Not impossible, just haven't gone there. Damper/flywheel assembly is
 different and would require a rebalance on your engine rotating assembly.
 The assembly will weigh a few pounds more than Tracy's unit, but needs to
 handle race power so the gear set and propshaft are much larger
accordingly.
 Been quiet.... been busy designing....
 Larry

Lots of OPINION, no EVIDENCE : ) Still waiting.
John Evans

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.