BTW Klaus built a short main wing span version of a Long EZ and it
was unable to take off. Does anybody know why? Hint: what happens to
the stall angle of attack as the aspect ratio is reduced?
Paul Lamar
Paul,
This statement is complete bullshit.
Where do you get the gall to publish something like this worldwide?
Steve Wolpin
I mis understood him initially. I asked him about it and he gave
me an indirect answer. I think he said something about not taking
off but he could have meant he did not try it yet.
I also asked him how many G's he was pulling at Reno and he told
me 3 G's. I was interested in that as I thought that was the main
rational for the short wings. To pull 3 G's you need a C sub L
three times greater. People have tried cutting the wings off
War birds and gone slower at Reno.
http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=898852
I brought up the subject of control authority.
The theory is short wings with a lower aspect ratio have a steeper
lift curve slope. If the area is also less, and it would be, the
required lift coefficient also goes way up. See the attached
chart from Von Doenhoff.
Therefor they need a much higher angle of attack to generate enough
lift to take off at a given speed. They also need more control
authority. They also generate more drag in the process so they need
more thrust. In addition the thrust vector angle is less favorable. Induced
drag is the main source of drag at speeds below minimum drag speed
at around 120 MPH or so. See the attached Crawford climb performance
chart.
Induced drag coeff = C sub L squared / ( Pi X AR)
Page 8.
On top of all that we have a limited runway length at SZP.
He then changed the subject and told me about the Long EZ flipping
over backwards when high speed taxied with out the main wings.
That was an entirely different situation. If the main wings
are not there there is no drag or lift from the main wings
of course and there is little or no limit to the angle of attack
short of the prop striking the ground.
I got clarification a couple of days ago from Klaus but then I had
to go away so I forgot to correct it. Sorry!
The truth is he did not put the short wings on yet.
That is where I found the gall :)
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.