Subject: The realities of energy policies in Japan
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/13/2011, 7:20 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

-------------------------------------------------------------------
"IWAKI, Japan -An explosion at a nuclear power station Saturday destroyed a
building housing the reactor, but a radiation leak was decreasing despite
fears of a meltdown from damage caused by a powerful earthquake and tsunami,
officials said.

Government spokesman Yukio Edano said the explosion destroyed the exterior
walls of the building where the reactor is placed, but not the actual metal
housing enveloping the reactor.

That was welcome news for a country suffering from Friday's double disaster
that pulverized the northeastern coast, leaving at least 574 people dead by
official count.

The scale of destruction was not yet known, but there were grim signs that
the death toll could soar. One report said four whole trains had disappeared
Friday and still not been located. Local media reports said at least 1,300
people may have been killed.

Edano said the radiation around the Fukushima Dai-ichi plant had not risen
after the blast, but had in fact decreased. He did not say why that was so.
The pressure in the reactor was also decreasing after the blast, he said.

The explosion was preceded by puff of white smoke that gathered intensity
until it became a huge cloud enveloping the entire facility, located in
Fukushima, 20 miles (30 kilometers) from Iwaki. After the explosion, the
walls of the building crumbled, leaving only a skeletal metal frame.

Tokyo Power Electric Co., the utility that runs the Fukushima Dai-ichi
plant, said four workers suffered fractures and bruises and were being
treated at a hospital.

"We have confirmed that the walls of this building were what exploded, and
it was not the reactor's container that exploded," said Edano.

See the full article from DailyFinance: http://www.dailyfinance.com/

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Probably a good thing as now they can water bomb the metal container
to cool it off. We need to fly a 747 or 1011 water bomber over there :)

BTW I keep seeing on the news that it is impossible to get north.
Heck Japan is only 80 miles wide at that point. It is possible to
drive up the west coast and cut across. I have driven in that area
already. Doug takes the silly electric train everywhere :)
What happens when the lights go out? :) Duh! :)

Here are a couple of maps with the atomic plant in the lower right
corner. Red arrows.

Paul Lamar



Japan is remarkable.  They tackle huge problems with a remarkable
amount of dignity and minimum of fuss.  In this case, I think they
should fuss some.  This is a huge disaster.

There's a cool video here:

http://www.businessinsider.com/tsunami-japan-earthquake-video-2011-3

I interpret this is having been shot some distance from the epicenter.
I assume the "GPS" based system just uses the GPS signal to provide
an accurate clock so that seismic data can be correlated from many
sites in order to precisely locate the epicenter, and the progress of
shock waves radiating outward.  The system can then predict how soon
you'll feel the shaking depending on where you are.  GPS doesn't
measure shaking.

They got quite the bumpy ride there..


Matt-

There is an upside to this. New natural disaster scenarios will be added to
the design limits  for new reactors. For example: An earth quake AND
followed by tsunami that takes out the diesel back up generator.

Another possibility is a cooling water stand pipe with a hatch cover
that can
be opened and be replenished by a helicopter. Sooner or later,
in the next 100 years, nuclear energy may become absolutely necessary.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

More band aid engineering. Common approach when we humans get fixated on
a technology.  If Yamamoto san thought that way then this newsletter
wouldn't exist.  We would discussing ways to install bigger radiators
and quick acting sensors to prevent  pistons from going through the heads.

Things aren't so apparent as to why Japan chose nuclear power. The
details of that decision would read like a thriller. And it has nothing
to do with the belief that nuclear power is  economical, or even
desired. It isn't  and I'll leave the safety issue alone because that
always comes back to people arguing "acceptable risks."  I have noticed
a "not in my backyard" mentality from its most vocal supporters though.
The Japanese inherent  fear of atomic energy (quite understandable) has
been quelled only by the threat of energy scarcity and the belief that
there is no alternative.

But wait?. Japan sits on some of the most concentrated sources of
geothermal energy in the world.  Magma is close to the surface in areas
close to energy demand. Indication of geothermal resources abound.  Over
2000 natural hot-spring sources and scores of active volcanos. It's a
dream case scenario for localized power production under the control of
communities and/or competing corporations. Are we to believe that with
IHI' s boring expertise, Kyocera ceramic knowledge, and Toshiba,
Hitachi, and Mitsubishi's power plant engineering prowess that they
can't tap these resources? Of course they can.  Magma drilling (from the
USA) was doing contract work here in the early eighties.
Several pilot plants were built.  So what do Iceland, PG&E  in northern
Ca. and Ormat in Israel  know about geothermal that  the Japanese
engineers don't? Nothing.  The reason  geo thermal energy is not tapped
here is much darker issue. GE has play a small part but it was well
before the Bush years:)

The most powerful political lobby in Japan is not made up of the big
corporate manufacturers as you would think, but the four electric
utilities companies. It is not a joke to say they hold  power over the
manufacturing sector and the nation's energy policy.  They are the
modern equivalent of feudal lords and their fiefdoms don't even run on
the same frequencies. The east is 50Hz the West 60Hz.  Can you imagine a
federal government not being able to enforce one standard for
electricity in  it's own country?  Sure voltage varies a bit across USA
but the frequency is the same.

Building nuclear powered steam generators  are pork barrel projects.
They are a general contractors heaven.  Endless maintenance issues using
high cost alloys. Cost over runs are funded by  pliable tax payers.
Mention a safety issue and there is a knee jerk reaction for the central
government to supply the funds. Mention a safety  issue in August and
country panics.

Some background info:
Since late 1978 and earlier 1980  a major rift  happened with
bureaucrats in the ministry of industrial development, MITI.  It
concerned the energy policy to supply the apparent industrial boom.
Clearly half of the bureaucrats wanted to develop alternative means of
energy and the other half, nuclear power. They ended up doing both.
The  Sunshine Project started days after I arrived.  By dumb luck I
arrived in Japan and  was hired by Japan Steels to design and develop a
solar tracking device and other alternative energy items.  MITI (having
no connection with immigration) called me in for an Q&A session
wondering how the hell "I knew' about their pet project.  I hadn't a
clue what they were talking about until I read a headline in the
newspaper the following day.  "Solar Energy,  Government's Number One
Research Priority"  Eventually making friends with some of these same
bureaucrats I found out later that it was commonly understood I worked
for the CIA.  I didn't but in retrospect that explained the wire
tapping, the tails, and DARPA people who just happened to contact me for
sourcing advice on the latest electronics.  Iranian officials did as
well but that's another story.  Darn,  I could have made some good
money:) The early eighties were lean years for me attending the business
school of hard knocks:)

The bureaucrats and companies pushing alternative energy then and now
are very much like the engineers within Mazda's own company.  The rotary
development team had always  been the David to the reciprocal. engine's
Goliath.

Back to the present:
Many power plants are off line now in the north and presently Japan sea
side. Power shortages are happening. Last night news reported that many
factories will voluntarily stop production until the power plants are
brought back on. I assumed this was just in the affected area but other
reports say not.  The significance of this and the amount of money lost
should have executives screaming.  My predication. In the next few years
look for large manufactures to construct  their own electrical power
plants nearby there factories.  Sony and Panasonic have already started
on this approach supplying a large percent of their needs with green
solutions.

 Yesterday the remaining coolant that didn't leak out of the
containment structure soared to 2,700C degree . Water starts to split at
2,000C. Supposedly the freed hydrogen saturated the outer concrete walls
and after the concentration was high enough it self ignited.
Projectiles of concrete did hit the pressure vessel with the possibility
of internal damage to the control rods, though I think they might have
dodged the bullet this time.  The fact that the evacuation zone has been
increase from 3, then 10, and now 20 kilometers might indicate someone
is worried though.  Last night they filled what was left of the
containment structure with sea water.  ALL Japanese nuclear reactors are
place on the shorelines.  No need for a helicopter to lift  water but
one should have been requested to deliver  a skid  mounted gasoline
powered water pump. Firehouses in every community have them.  Economic
policy trumped common sense.  In an effort to save their investment
Tokyo Electric staff might have made a decision that will ultimately
destroyed it.

Now the television is showing many people boarding buses and sitting in
the parking lot with nowhere to go. This is because there has never ever
been an emergency evacuation plan drawn up.  You may think that in a
country that is famous for planning, this would not happen, but it's
true.  Change in Japan moves at glacial speeds until a wake- up event
happens.  With glaciers it's called an iceberg. Commadore Perry was one.
Defeat at WWII another, Miyamoto mercury poisoning and Kobe earthquake
others.  Lessons were learned though. Changes made.  Earthquake response
teams have been remarkably efficient in caring for the surviours.  Now a
can of worms has been opened and all of the hush hush accidents the
industry has had over the years will come into pubic awareness.  Paul,
another thing you may not know is that there is a growing movement
within the lower ranks of power companies to move away from nuclear.

I asked the head of Toshiba's nuclear energy program  30 years ago why
no Japanese power plant had an emergency evacuation plan. His answer
was, "It's not needed. Japanese technology and staff are superior to USA
and other nations.  An accident would be unthinkable and so we will
never allow them to happen." Granted this was a period when politicians
were writing books like "Japan is Number One" and small accidents did
happen and were never reported. The latest government spin?  It was the
stunami's fault;

Speaking of water:
Energy like water always flows toward the location with big money
resources. If this wasn't true than L.A would revert back to being a
desert and northern California would be entitled to use the water that
flows right through their communities.  The same pork barrel policies
are apparent in USA with its dams and water  projects.  For a
fascinating read, check out Marc Reisner's "Cadillac Desert.?The
American West and it's disappearing water."

Tsu rong in Japan



Bandwith...rotary...
Roger


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.