Subject: 10:1 or 9.7:1 rotors?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/29/2011, 1:41 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,

  I'm looking into the possibility of using the '89-'92 year  9.7:1 rotors
  on the P.P test engine.  Do you happen to know the redline for
these  rotors?

   T.O. will be at 8300, but I would like the engine  redline to be
9,000  which is less than the Renesis engine I believe.

  I may have to have the 9.7:1 rotors lightened a bit.

  http://www.mazdatrix.com/faq/rotorwgt.htm

  I was going to go with  Renesis rotors for the 110 grams reduction
in  weight and the slight increase in compression ratio, but to use
them in a  13B engine I would have to incorporate lots of the
Renesis engine parts.  E-shaft, stationary gears, counter weights
etc.   The biggest issue is the  durability of the stock apex seals
going over the P-ports. The Renesis  rotors would have to be
machined both to accept a deeper 2mm apex seals,  and fix side
clearance issues encountered when used with 13B housings.

  Doug in Japan

  It is the rotor bearing that is the limit. As I recall the "windowed"
  version of the rotor bearing is good to 11,000 RPM with just about
  all stock cast iron rotors. The RX8 rotors are just a little bit lighter.
  Racing Beat uses a 3D NC mill to get a few ounces out of the stock
rotors  at great expense. M V squared over R.

  The 13B intake p-port, if anything, is better than 13B side input
port as  the  apex seals are cooled better. The worst effect on the
apex seals  comes from the p-port exhaust. Not the p-port intakes.
RX8 side exhaust  are  easier on the apex seals. The P-port RX8
engine IMHO is the best of all  worlds.

  If money is no object why fool around? Go with Iannette silicon nitride
  apex seals. Guaranteed to last for ever and be unbreakable.
  Dave Lemon at Mazdatrix melted a steel rotor housing liner by
running the  engine  long after all the coolant blew out. He took
the Iannette seals  out and is still running them to this day in new
engines.

  Paul Lamar

Paul,
The "window" bearings are the main bearings in the stationary gears.
For an engine that will see sustained high rpm, the high power RX8
stationary gears should be used. They incorporate many of the
changes used for years in racing. The rotor gear will walk out and
bind the rotor between the side housings if used for sustained high
rpm. there are a couple of methods to stop it with the most popular
being having racing beat snap ring the gear into the rotor. May not
be an issue on RX8 rotors (one reason to use them!) That's my 2
cents on making them last at sustained rpm. Can you do me a favor
and see if  Dave Lemon has a scrap late model (2010 or 2011) RX8
rotor housing he can sell me? Thanks, Larry

He usually has scrap housing of all types for sale at around $30.
562-426-7960

Paul Lamar

Larry,

I had a '73 RX3 with the 12A engine. Ran it all the time at 9000 RPM racing
Mustangs and Camaros with 350 cube engines. The car was less than 2100#. Being
young and excitable I banged it into 2nd gear downshifting at too high a speed
and spun the engine up to about 11,000RPM. The rear rotor gear walked out a
bit and it started to burn oil. I got a friend to help pull the engine with a
chain and 2 by 4. I tapped the rotor gear back in place and sanded the housing
a bit on 3/4" glass with emery cloth and then crocus cloth "glued" down with
grease. I did not even buy seals or gaskets. No problem and made a mental
note, no more +9000 RPM.

Doug,

Which PSRU are you using and what size prop? That RPM seems high unless you
are using a smaller diameter. As stated above, I believe the engine will have
no problem with the RPM you propose. What is the cost of Renesis rotors? The
RB lightened rotors are kind of pricey, but 2 pounds off the weight.

Dale Davies



Dale

Modified Bell 47.    3:1 ratio.     Prop MT, electric C/S.  76" dia. three blade composite .  My friends with the identical prop and airplanes but powered by Lycoming IO-540s,  consistently take-off with rpms of 2700 or above.  One person claims 2800 rpm.  MT claims they are good to 3,000 rpms but I'd imagine they would be less efficient at that speed.   Key point in the discussion is the PSRU ratio and prop type.  As Paul correctly stated he couldn't get the engine to reach 8,000 even without a clutch??     And he won't unless he uses a different ratio PSRU and prop.

With a 3:1 ratio the rotor is spinning the same speed as the prop.   2,733 rotor speed is an e-shaft speed of  8,200.  The engine is  just starting to wake-up and IMHO showing off its potential for a good aircraft engine.  Personally I'd rather see PSRU ratios in the 3.1:1 or 3.2:1 range.

I agree with Paul that to manage heat load and engine life, cruise should be around 6,000 rpm.

Mazdatrix has the Renesis rotors for sale at $651.  I don't know how much they would charge for milling the apex slots out deeper to accept a standard 2mm wide apex seal though. Perhaps you can ask.  Lighter is always better on any rotating mass but the Renesis rotors are pretty optimized 'as is'   Reduction of 0.2 lbs not 2 lbs is possible.

Regards

Doug in Japan

Mazda now has a set of 2 pcs seals that are not as deep for retrofitting
early engines.

Tracy current psru is 2.85:1 2700 RPM gives 7695.

Doug's transmission is irreplaceable for all practical purposes
and that includes all the parts. If you asks the helicopter guys you
get quotes of $30,000 for a Bell 47 final drive.

Most people use a 3 rotor for a big heavy Seawind. Doug is worried
that he won't get enough power with a two rotor to get up and off the water.

Paul Lamar


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.