Subject: Combustion/ Mixture Pattern? Rotor-housing too hot?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/2/2011, 7:24 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 The attached picture is from my single rotor PP engine after
 about 10hrs running time. Most of the time was running at WOT and
 6000RPM. fuelflow was around 8gph.If this an indicator of
 mixture distribution at ignition, what does itmean? if anything.
 Has that been observed by anyone else?

 Richard Sohn
 N2071U

 You got me. I have never seen anything like that.
 What kind of oil are you mixing?

 Paul Lamar

 I am using 1.25oz/gal ECHO two stroke oil.

 Richard SohnN2071U

 It looks to me like there is silicone partly blocking the coolant
 passage to the left of the leading plug. There is a difference in
 the marking of the housing to the left of the plug. Almost as if
 there is damage to the apex seals as they cross the leading plug.
 Also of note is the burn mark before the trailing plug. Could
 this be blow by past damage to the apex seals? There is also a curious
 line across the housing just before the trailing plug. It also looks
 like the apex seals were not following the rotor housing after
 the minor axis indicated by the burn discoloration. How is the
 coolant flow with the new end housings? I would put a
 thermocouple in as per Paul's description to monitor the metal
 temp on further runs.

 Dale Davies

 Good call Dale. Richard is building his own end housings so that
 area may not be getting as much water as it needs. Could also be your
 water pump is not up to it Richard. As I recall the 2 rotor needs
 about 30 gallons per minute.

 Here is the picture from my book How to Cool Your Wankel.
 "installing a "cylinder head temperature" gage. This can be done
 by drilling a small hole in the rotor housing in the place shown and
 installing a thermal couple."

 BTW Mario called me from Germany this morning and took me to task
 for the careless use of the word "Wankel" since he now owns the
copyrights.

 It is like copy and Zerox.

 Paul Lamar

 Richard,

 Could the spark plug be kinda bottoming in the threads and
 distorting the rotor housing? It is polished right at the sides
 of the plug hole, but burnt farther out.

 Dale Davies

 --
Hi Richard;
The centerline smudge running left from both plugs is a sign of heat.
Were the smudges there previously?
It might be blow by, grooved surface, apex clearance?
Have you checked the rotor housing surface and apex seals with a ruler
and back lighting for flatness?

Those orings also appear to be too large.

Cheers
Cary

Richard,

Attached is a picture of a rotor housing that was severely overheated.
 It has a similar pattern that you're seeing.  I think the residue
 is  from burnt coolant.  From the looks of the TES o-ring, it
 appears the  teflon got very hot, possibly compromising the seal.
 Has the engine  been overheated?  What EGT do you see at WOT?

Mark S.

 Thanks for all the excellent responses.
 After doing some more checking on all the parts and indicators,
 it   appears to me now that high temperature in the plug area is
the most likely   culprit. The EGT at my test runs was pretty
constant 1600 to 1650F , and coolant temperature never went above
180F. One thing could have caused a local overheat is the fact
that I run all these tests at a atmospheric coolant pressure.
There was leak I could not find, so I started with the testing
anyway. However, when I disassembled the engine, there was a
damaged stud o-ring, which very likely was the reason for the
leak.  --

 Richard Sohn
 N2071U

 I would still install the thermocouple near the lower spark plug.
 You may have local film boiling in that area which is allowing
the metal to go higher than 500 F coking the apex seal oil. You cannot
 always rely on the pressure in the cooling system to reduce the local
 film boiling.

 I would also measure the coolant flow through the block with a flow
 meter set up just to be sure you are getting enough water flow. I'll
 loan you my flow meter set up  if you send me your shipping address.

 Paul Lamar

Richard,

What is the clear or opaque stuff by the seal? It looks like clear
silicone.

You state you test at atmospheric pressure and a damaged seal may
have   caused   the leak leading to over heat. In my experience,
leaving the rad cap   loose   will slow a leak. It would have had to
be quite low in coolant to   allow it to   get that hot. The water
pump is less efficient at atmospheric which could   reduce the
coolant flow. Monitoring flow with Paul's meter would be   highly
 recommended, especially considering the changes made. In
conjunction   with a   thermocouple any problems should be shown up
before it gets expensive   again.   I would try testing flow with
and without pressure to see what happens.

Dale Davies

  Hi Richard;
  As mentioned, a pressurized system (and other mods) will help with
local  boiling near the spark plugs, although your temps sounded normal.

  Paul's question about how much 2-stroke oil ash deposits are left behind
  is a good question.
  I have heard of people using a lot of different oils - they all
seem to  work as long as they make it to the engine ;)  Lower ash is
better - a 6k rev a day keeps the rebuild away :)

  Were the outer layers of your TES orings melted?
  Were the orings diameters bigger than when you installed them?
  inner oring (thickness) OD?  0.093"?
  What, if any, damage or problems did you find?

  Comments on the oil/coolant coking? deposits near the less cooled
  housing metal in the attached pic:
  One thought was that there were deposits well ahead of the
trailing plug
  (#1 in photo).  There were also deposits #2&#2 just below (left)
the rotor housing  centerline (these are rare)  The odd #3 and #4
deposits look like 2 lines above and below the edges  of a recess or
groove.  One thought was that your timing advance was too early.
 This might  prematurely squish the flame front.  Horizontal
centerline groove? areas  may have continued to burn but were
extinguished at the edge of the  groove in cooler areas of #3/#4
resulting in the horizontal lines in the  pic.  This might also
explain some of the possible heat issues.

  What advance were you using?
  leading/trailing split?
  dizzy/ignition system/FI ECU?

  If there was no damage, pretend I never made these alcohol induced
  comments.
  Cheers
  Cary

I am using a StreetFire MSD ignition with the timing fixed at 24deg BTDC.
Both plug fire simultaneously. The o-rings are MAZDA stock. Yes, the
Teflon was melted. There was no other sign of over heating on the
metal as far as I could see.

Richard Sohn
N2071U


Hi Richard,

What rotors and housings are you using, 12A or 13B?

Racing Beat tech tips shows 24BTC and 5BTC for 12A and 20BTC and 10BTC for 13A
for bridge or p-port running at 6K. Mazda recommends 20BTC for both leading
and trailing. Is it possible you have too much timing thrown in with the other
problems?

I keep looking at the rotor housing and the burn mark before the trailing
plug, and it's location. It appears to me that the apex seals may be damaged
in the center in alignment with the plug hole. It may be minute, but could
allow a small bit of combustion to blow back. This could cause high surface
temp at that point.

Dale Davies


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.