Subject: Off topic: aerodynamics of amphibious aircraft
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/19/2011, 8:38 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

A question if allowed. What are the aerodynamic drag penalties or advantages
in this contrast.  Low wing monoplane on twin floats vs low wing monoplane
on single main float with small wign tip stabilizers (IE Grumman duck).  In
the former example the main float attachment scheme may be central pylon(s),
peripheral struts, and/or a fuselage width faired in structure.  My thought
exercise is prompted by the fact that, it would be easier to implement
amphibious tricycle gear on single float, and single float would be able to
handle higher sea conditions.  C.  Smith





D. F. Hoerner, in his book "Fluid Dynamic Drag" [possibly
chapter 8] shows data for drag between two identical struts
when flown at varying distances apart.  When the two struts were
about 4 of their own diameters apart, total drag for the two
was about the same as it would be for a single such strut
multiplied by two.  When the struts were moved closer together,
however, total drag increased over 'single strut times two.'
This is called interference drag, and exists between any two
aerodynamic bodies relatively close together.  I would guess
from this, that if your single main float had a substantial
cross-sectional area, that it would have to be farther from
your fuselage than would smaller dual floats, in order to
minimize this kind of interference drag with the fuselage.
Gene Kahn


Good job Gene

Paul Lamar

Thanks for the reference. I think I've heard of this phenomena before.
It's the reason for the dimples in the fuselages of execu-jets by the engine
pods.  Any other good title suggestions on the topic?  Hoerners book runs
around $150 and up.  Maybe I should build some models and little tunnel, see
for my self.  8-D

C. Smith

Hi, a float and fuselage are roughly bodies of revolution and not like two
struts or airfoils that are close and parallel so interference drag should
be a small factor.  My guess is the single float will have some what less
drag.  The devil is in the details; struts, wires etc.  In seaplanes
practical considerations are more important than drag.  Being able to dock,
fit a torpedo, fit on a catapult, etc. Twin floats are more stable on the
water and more available.  I personally like hull type but in the bush high
wing twin floats are the norm.

Murry I. Rozansky


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.