Subject: V8 powered fatal aircraft crash
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/30/2011, 9:43 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
 Accident occurred Saturday, May 07, 2011 in Conroe, TX
 Aircraft: WOODWARD HAROLD L RAVIN 500, registration: N913RA
 Injuries: 2 Fatal.

 This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain errors.
 Any errors in this report will be corrected when the final report
 has been completed.

 On May 7, 2011, approximately 0855 central daylight time, a Woodward
 Ravin 500 experimental amateur built airplane, N913RA, impacted
 forested terrain shortly after takeoff from Lone Star Executive
 Airport (CXO), Conroe, Texas. Visual meteorological conditions
 prevailed at the time of the accident. The personal flight was being
 conducted under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations
 Part 91. The pilot and student pilot rated passenger were fatally
 injured. The flight was originating at the time of the accident and
 was en route to Temple, Texas, for the airplane to be displayed at
 an aviation event.

 According to CXO tower personnel, the pilot was cleared to depart
 runway 14 with a right turn on course. The airplane departed and as
 the pilot began his initial right turn he reported smoke in the
 cockpit. The pilot was cleared to land on any runway and giving the
 wind as being from 160 degrees at 8 knots. The airplane was observed
 to perform an approximate 240 degree right turn and crossed back
 over the departure runway before entering the left downwind leg for
 runway 14. While on the downwind leg of the traffic pattern the
 airplane was observed flying, â<80<9Cslowâ<80<9D, wings level,
 at an estimated altitude of 700 to 800 feet above the ground. While
 approximately 4,500 feet along the downwind leg the landing gear was
 extended. Shortly thereafter, the airplane started a descending left
 turn towards the closer runway 19. The airplane overshot the
 extended centerline to runway 19 and the airplaneâ<80<99s bank
 angle increased. The airplane continued in the descending left turn
 toward the runway until approximately 300 feet above the ground. At
 which point the airplane appeared to â<80<9Cstallâ<80<9Dand
 impacted into forested terrain. A post impact fire ensued. Tower
 personnel reported that during the event they did not observe any
 smoke or flames coming from the airplane until impact.

 A pilot rated eyewitness located near the crash site reported
 hearing what he described as an engine that was
 Ã¢<80<9Cscreamingâ<80<9Dand varying in RPM. When he saw the
 airplane it was flying â<80<9Cvery slowâ<80<9Dat an estimated
 altitude of 300 to 500 feet above the ground. As the airplane made a
 high bank angle turn back towards the airport the witness observed
 the nose and left wing drop before the airplane went out of sight.
 Seconds later he heard it impact trees followed by an explosion.

 The airplane came to rest in an upright position about 1,600 feet
 out on the extended center line from the approach end of runway 19.
 The measured impact heading was 200 degrees magnetic.

 ------------------------------------------------------------
 Sounds like they will never know what happened.

 I am guessing. One possible scenario is the automotive clutch Bud
 used started slipping causing the smoke and the
 [WINDOWS-1252?]ââ?¬Å?screamingââ?¬Â engine. The clutch disk could wear
 rather
 rapidly due to normal high torque fluctuations at high continuous power.

 IMHO the TBO on an automotive V8 in aircraft use should be 300 hours.
 Any piston engine can develop a crack in the critical parts leading
 to a hand grenade failure without warning. The main purpose of the
 TBO is to magnaflux the critical parts to detect cracks early before
 the engine explodes. Through years and millions upon millions of
 hours of experience and detail refinement the TBO on aircraft
 engines has increased to 2000 hours.

 The TBO on my C182 engine was 1500 hours. By adding another
 torsional damper on the crankshaft the TBO was increased to 2000
 hours. However unlike a piston engine in a car the aircraft crank
 and rods are made of the finest material possible. Only the best
 methods of manufacturing and finishing are used.

 Parts in an automotive V8 are made as cheaply as possible as the
 average required power is only about 40 HP despite a 400 HP rating.

 We are so lucky the Wankel rotary does not see the same kinds of
 reverse loading on the e-shaft and the rotor that are seen on a
 piston engine cranksaft and rods. Fatigue failures of the e-shaft
 and rotor are unheard of.

 Paul Lamar

 It sounds like the pilot might have stopped flying the airplane, but
 instead was trying to save it. My training was that in case of fire,
 you get the airplane on the ground immediately, as you really don't
 know what's burning. I can understand the smoke could have been
 incapacitating, so that might have been the issue, but if it was the
 clutch burning, it seems unlikely somehow.

 Matt-

 I agree but people that build airplanes have so much invested in
 them (more than money alone) they appear to be reluctant to crash
 land straight ahead as we were all told to do in case of engine
 failure on take off. Here is a map of the area and there does not
 appear to be many clear fields other than on the airport itself. In
 the case of rotary crashes at least two fatals were caused by the
 pilots attempting to turn back. In both cases there were suitable
 fields straight ahead. One rotary crash was caused by engine seizure
 after the loss of all oil pressure due to a split cheap oil cooler
 and the other an interruption in the fuel supply due to a poorly
 designed fuel plumbing system.

 IMHO there is another more subtle factor. One is naturally reluctant
 to do a 180 and land downwind on a controled airport or busy
 airport. We had an incident at SZP where a pilot had an engine
 failure in a Bonanza and successfully made a 180 and landed down
 wind. He slammed it in so hard on the 2500 foot runway it bent the
 spar and broke the motor mounts totaling the airplane but he was not
 hurt. He skillfully ground looped it when it looked like he was
 going to run out of runway at thew other end. I was standing 50 feet
 from the point of impact.

 I think people should practice 180's at altitude with the engine at
 idle. Just to get a feel of what the airplane will do. Note the loss
 of altitude.

 Paul Lamar

 --
 Persons close to the parties blame it on a bad oil line connection
 to the engine....not the clutch......FWIW.... Marc

 Why the "screaming" engine? Or did it sound like that all the time?

 Paul Lamar


 Re: Matt's comment about clutch burning unlikely. Yes unlikely, but
 possible.
 Hi-way haul trucks have got the brakes on fire coming down long hills. I
 worked on a Ford 1/2 ton that had stopped on the side of the road.
 Questioning
 the driver/owner he said it slowed and stopped going. The engine ran fine.
 The
 fellow said when he looked under the truck there was fire underneath.
 When I
 removed the clutch cover, a couple of handfuls of clutch fiber came out.
 The
 flywheel, pressure plate, trans input shaft and the back of the crankshaft
 were blue from the heat of the slipping clutch. The trans input and the
 crank
 just had small spots. The fire was the release fork boot burning from the
 radiated heat. Surfaced the flywheel and put new clutch in. I also had to
 replace the trans input bearing as this fellow would shift into OD at
 40MPH.
 Ford dealer had replaced the noisy brg 3 times previous. Only 45K miles on
 the
 truck. He came back two weeks later to see if I had the clutch core.
 Said he
 was talking to his insurance agent and they figured the fire burnt the
 clutch
 out. There we go with the only thing more dangerous than a dumby, is a
 dumby
 that thinks he is smart.

 Dale Davies

 Burning brakes happened to me when I was driving a semi as a teenager.

 Paul Lamar



 Wouldn't the clutch gripping strength be stronger than the other
 components in the drive train? I'm thinking rev up and pop-the
 clutch.. And the clutch clamping surface is quite a distance from the
 center of the shaft, lowering the slipping force (torque) required.
 In automotive use, clutches fail when they are slipped, or engaged
 suddenly. If the clutch is healthy to start with (not worn out from
 miles or abuse), it won't slip. I think your 1/2 ton truck customer
 rode (left his foot on) the clutch pedal. That's a quick way to wear
 one out - abuse.

 As a side note, I went hunting a while back with a friend.. We were
 in his pickup, he was driving. I have never ridden with anyone that
 slipped the clutch as much as this guy.. I mean, probably half the
 time we were accelerating, the clutch was slipping. I could tell he
 was doing it by watching his leg/foot.. I have no idea how long that
 clutch lasted, but it couldn't have been many miles.

 I guess the crash airplane might have had the clutch
 linkage/hydraulics mis-adjusted so that it didn't allow the clutch to
 provide its full clamping pressure.. That brings up a thought...
 Maybe airplanes with clutches (or anything that could slip) should
 have a tachometer on both the prop and the engine.. And a little
 circuit that keeps track of the ratio between them. And which sets an
 alarm if there's any discrepancy between the engine and prop RPM -
 indicating slipping - which might not be immediately detectable to the
 ear.

 I understand that there may be torsional resonant loads at certain RPM
 ranges, but I'd guess that they would threaten the prop shaft, or
 output gear.. There's lots about this that I don't know - obviously.
 Predicting the RPM at which resonant forces build doesn't seem to be
 something that can be done by guessing or TLAR.. None the less, I
 think the torsional loads would tear the center out of the clutch
 before other failures, assuming proper engagement.



 Matt-


 Bud claimed the clutch damped the torsional pulses which implied it
 had to slip.

 Paul Lamar

Almost all automotive clutch packs have a spring loaded center section
intended to help soften any shock to the drive train resulting from
injudicious engagement of the clutch and/or throttle.  Perhaps this
action was what he was referring to when he said that the torsional
pulses were damped by the clutch.

I doubt that the clutch would slip in response to any torsional pulse
that could be generated by the engine.  What is far more likely is that
the spring loaded center section would fatigue from the varying forces
resulting from the referenced torsional pulses.

My thought is that a damaged oil line would allow the clutch to be
contaminated resulting in excessive slippage under full load resulting
in functional failure.  The oil leak probably occurred before the clutch
was engaged as the symptoms appear almost immediately after take off.

I'm not familiar with the crank design on the Chevy engine involved but
I do know that on some Chevy crank flanges the bolt holes provide a path
for engine oil to leak from the crank case if one of the bolts becomes
loosened.  Those engines require the application of some type of
anerobic sealing compound, i.e. "Loctite", on the threads of the
flywheel bolts.  Were the crank bolts lock wired?  Did the sealing
compound fail?

 Mark LaPierre

"What is far more likely is that
the spring loaded center section would fatigue from the varying forces
resulting from the referenced torsional pulses."

Has happened in Ken Welters rotary powered Coot.
Tracy uses rubber bushing which makes more sense.
Here too is a rubber damper in Randy Lewis's belt drive PSRU.
I don't know where it came from.

An ounce of rubber is better than a Pound (British monetary Pound) of
engineering :)

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.