Subject: Epoxy and Ethanol Update
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/1/2011, 7:24 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


    Many thanks to everyone for their support and empathy of my nasty little
    situation. But life will continue, even though I might have to commit
    suicide to get better.

    After further inspection, I see some blistering in several areas on top of
    the wing. That means the alcohol has penetrated the wing skins to the upper
    fiberglass covering. That does it for those wings.

    A fellow Glass Gooser has offered me his wings, so I'm going to "rewing" my
    airplane.

    I used AdTech CER 112-2 epoxy and hardener that is supplied with the Glass
    Goose. I talked to the techs at AdTech and they confirmed that ethanol is
    very destructive to their epoxy. However, he said there are other epoxies
    that are very durable with ethanol. I'll certainly look into those.

    Sandy McNabb

    Good news for me Sandy. Makes me happy. I don't like to see that much effort
    and
    good workmanship thrown away. I would not give up on the bladder idea just
    yet.
    I should know in a week or two how difficult it is to bond neoprene.

    I had trouble finding the neoprene fabric  again on the McMaster web site.
    It is listed under Polyester, Polypropylene & Nylon Fabrics. Page 3201
    of the printed 108 catalog. McMaster has so much stuff things are
    sometimes hard to find. I ordered a 5 by 5 foot sheet for testing.

    Also use a small box wrench to tap on the skin and listen for a change in
    sound.
    Believe it or not this is a technique they teach to certified aircraft
    mechanics
    working on composite parts for airliners.

    If you have a sample of the foam you used in the old wings please soak
    it in auto fuel for a few weeks.

    Since you have new wings please cut apart the old wings and take pictures of
    the
    inside damage before throwing them away.

    BTW what is the rib spacing in the fuel tank area?
    I assume the top and bottom skin is double wall.

    Is there an illustration in the plans showing the basic
    construction? I would like to calculate what would happen
    deflection and strength wise if the sandwich skin was thicker to do away
    with the ribs. Perhaps a layer of carbon top and bottom on
    the skin will do the job. The C82 has no ribs in the 45 gallon fuel tank
    area.

    This whole issue is key to the acceptance of the
    rotary because one of its main advantages is the ability to burn
    low cost auto fuel.

    I'll pay to have a large chunk of those old wings shipped to me
    for R&D.

    Paul Lamar

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Hello Paul,

    I won't be giving up on the bladder idea or any other since I still need to
    solve the ethanol problem in a fiberglass fuel tank.

    Scott Gettings, another Glass Goose builder, put a fiberglass and foam
    samples in jars of diesel, avgas, and gasoline (without alcohol). The
    samples have been in the fluids for 7 to 9 years. He says the is very little
    to no damage to the epoxy.

    I will be happy to take pictures of the old wings and send you a sample to
    test.

    There are no ribs in the tanks, however the main spar runs through the
    tanks. The wing skin is a single layer of fiber glass on both sides of 3/8"
    foam...Typical Rutan design.

    Sandy McNabb

    Sounds like the Long EZ wing strake tanks.

    Well that sounds strong enough for bladders in front of and behind the
    spars. Most of the weight of the fuel is supported by the aero pressure
    on the bottom skin. Not all of course as most of the lift comes
    from the top skin.

    They can feed through  small holes in the root rib as I think
    that is what they do now.  The 6 by 12 oval holes can have a cover with
    a lot of small machine screws with nut plates to restore the
    skin strength. Just like a C182. I'll have some  material pictures by
    Monday or Tuesday.

    Paul Lamar




The Goose wing tanks are very tight, with a single outboard filler that handles all
the bays.  The tanks are lined with Jeffco prior to wing closure, but the
bonding process will allow some of the epoxy to be in contact with the fuel no
matter
what you do.  Fuel bladders would be very difficult in this small,
multi-compartment
tank system configuration - using a resistant sealer and resin in the wings would
be far easier.

As Sandy mentioned, my test articles have been in fuel for 9 years without any
damage to the Jeffco or bonding epoxy.  I have not tested them in gasohol.

Scott Gettings

Do you have a set of plans for the wings that can be scanned Scott?
If you mail them to me I can scan them and send them back. I'll pay postage.

There is a process called roto molding where the liquid sealer is placed
in the tank and then the tank is continuously rotated on at least two axis's
untill the sealer sets up. This process uniformly coats the interior
of the tank with a uniform thickness.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotational_molding

Paul Lamar


I screwed up. Neoprene is not good for fuels.

I got it confused with NBR / Nitrile or Buna N
Acrylonitrile Butadiene

Now I need to find a source for the NBR fabric.

--------------------------------------------------------------
GarLock is a division of Goodyear.

They sell gasket NBR material which has the needed characteristics
for fuel cell material.


http://www.garlock.com/ViewProduct?product=259&region=1

GoodYear also has some other divisions that may sell more or less
the same stuff.

http://www.goodyearrubberproducts.com/goodyear/AlphaCatalogs.asp

Paul Lamar



I have been working for Trelleborg designing seals for aerospace and
automotive... NBR is not fuel resistant. Is such case you need to use FKM or FVMQ

I suggest that you visit www.trelleborg.com for more info

Roderick Scotto


No doubt FKM AKA Viton is better but it is a lot more expensive.
http://www.fkm-ind.com/sheet_rubber.html?gclid=CMLf-O2A3qkCFQVLgwodP0_cYw
We don't need the 400 degree F temperature capability.

If it is good enough for Goodyear it is good enough for me :)


Paul Lamar

Yes we do, .025" Viton / Nylon,  how much do you require?

Pricing is so very dependent on quantities, We sell this by the lineal foot,

For small quantities, you should budget  About $300 / sq foot.

- -
Cary Kaufman
cary@fkm-ind.com
www.fkm-ind.com
+419-841-5676 Tel
+419-844-9900 Fax

That says it all about FKM AKA Viton. We are looking at $1.00 a square
foot for Nitrile.

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.