Subject: Audible landing aid
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/26/2011, 11:08 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Hi Mark S TX,

How is your audible landing aid working?

Here is one I found that looks pretty good.


http://www.bak-talk.com/**specifications.htm<http://www.bak-talk.com/specifications.htm


Paul Lamar

Paul,

My design used a bar LED to indicate distance above the runway. I didn't
really use it, or need it. Once I followed what my CFI taught me, to look
down to the far end of the runway, all was well. I found that I was too
busy looking out the windscreen to pay attention to the GPI indicator. So,
I removed the GPI (ground proximity indicator) from my panel. An audible
voice, or tone might prove to be a better way to go.

Mark S TX

What triggered my interest was I rented a car recently with a system like
this and discovered how well it worked with a change in tone
as you got closer to the object. I think it would be a huge advantage
for student pilots just learning to land. The question is: would they
come to totally rely on it and then be unable to land with out it?

I think I will get one for the RV4 and try it out.

Paul Lamar

Paul:
Mark is right, of course.  Once you learn where to look and how to adjust
your focus point, an aural GPI won't be needed.  As you mention, it might
have some role in the early stages of learning to land, but an RV-4 is so
easy to land anyway.  So why add the complexity?

In the early days of flying the B-767 we had the PNF (pilot-not-flying) call
out "Fifty Feet" on the radar altimeter as a clue to the PF (pilot flying)
to prepare to begin the flare at about 30 feet.  I would count 3 seconds
("thousand one-thousand two-thousand three") begin retarding the throttles
and initiate a smooth flare maneuver.  Later, they added a voice call out
from the GPWS (ground proximity warning system) at "50 feet," then "30
feet".  Soon we had call outs every 10 feet.

That automatic callout saved me some possible embarrassment landing to the
east at LAX after mid-night in very light rain--so light that I didn't see
the need for windshield wipers.  The optical illusion caused by light
refraction thru the rain fooled my eyes.  When the GPWS sounded "50 feet",
my eyes were telling my brain that we were at 200 feet.  Fortunately, I
believed the GPWS and began the flare at the "30 feet" call-out, and made a
good landing.

Another use of such a device is in changing from narrow runways to wide
runways.  When you are accustomed to landing on a 50 foot wide runway, and
change to a 150 foot wide runway, the optical illusion is to begin flaring
too high, and then dropping it in.  Again, that can be trained around, but
your aural GPI could be useful in these situations.

Just a few thoughts.

Tom Parkes

Thanks for your thoughts on this Tom as I know you teach future airline
pilots for a living.

I had a retired 747 captain tell me more or less the same thing.
The co pilot would call out 50 feet and the pilot would flare.

I am thinking down the road for a possible cheap auto land system
for experimental AC since the GPS can put you on the center line.
A sensor for altitude is $10 as long as as one can obtain the local
barometer. The GPS altitude is not very accurate.  The last ten feet
can be done with the proximity sensor.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

Some 10 years ago, as a student pilot, I was having a rough
time with my height over the runway perception. No problem for
an old electronics type, I cobbled up a cheap sonic distance
meter to provide a audible height indication. Tested it by
holding it vertical and walking towards a hanger door. At
about 30 feet I had a nice low frequency putt... putt... putt.
At 5 feet a high pitch scream.

Mounted it on the wing strut of a 172 and started doing touch
and goes. At about 30 ft I got my nice putt... putt, at about
15 ft it went crazy every pass. Back to the hanger door, every
thing was fine. I finally figured out that at about 15 feet
the sonic pulse it was making was being received and
triggering a new pulse just at it should but it was also being
reflected off of the lower wing surface, back to the runway,
and back up to cause another triggering. All the echoing was
confusing the sensor. Hanger door, no repeat echo, everything
was fine.

Before I could fix the problem my mind finally got the height
perception straightened out and I gave up trying to fix it. My
instructor never appreciated my effort at all and was greatly
relieved.

Fred O.

A couple of thoughts:

- If the visibility is good, you don't need it.  I understand that
Paul's talking about crummier visibility.  And night.  I like it for
that.

- If it's for autolanding, it doesn't necessarily need to make any
audible tone..  Useful for debug though.  It creeps me out to use a
home built device to control the airplane when close to the ground.
Especially for pitch.

- The echoing problem could be fixed by making the tones further
apart in time.  Delay.

- Not much use on a short runway where you have to put it right on
the end, immediately after passing over something rugged (mesa-top
airport)

- Little airplanes have relatively low energy, and can be flared
rather sharply compared to an airliner.  That can make the problem
easier to overcome.  As well, with little airplanes, you can get the
feel of the wing in ground effect, and that can help you determine
height above the ground.

I'd think any true autoland system might need to keep track of the
overall energy of the airplane.  Airspeed, descent rate, altitude (and
maybe power setting).  Each of these play into being able to flare and
making a good landing.  I wonder if an auto throttle might be the
easiest way to follow a glide slope and handle the flare.  With a
responsive piston or rotary engine, it's quite easy to modulate glide
path and even flare with appropriate application of power.  A little
blip of the throttle will bring about the flare and you don't have to
worry about stalling.  Doesn't work on a heavy airplane driven by a
slow to respond turbine...


I wonder if any tailwheel airplane ever had an autoland system.  I
sort of doubt..



Matt-


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.