Subject: Harmonics and dampers
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/26/2011, 11:11 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


While poking about on the net, I came across this site. Paul, you
are probably aware of these people.  www.epi-eng.com   On the left
side of the site is a list of selections. In gear box products,
 there is a discussion of torsional harmonics. For me it has some
more information regarding what is going on, possibly with respect
to the flex plate failures and the forces involved. They speak about
NASCAR and F1 engines. I noticed that the F1 engines are not using a
CS damper as they are not needed. Only about 200 lb/ft torque.
(Maybe they could tend to come apart at 18,000RPM) Stroke is 1.5" so
force on crank is light compared to 3.5"  NASCAR engine. Probably
part of why the Mazda engine has not suffered e-shaft failures. The
short stroke does not apply a torsional pulsation into it like a
boing boing engine does. It is there, but not as strong. I wonder if
the flex plate would fail quicker if bolted to a piston engine and
flown the same as the rotary engines. Maybe the crank or rods would
be looking for air first.

Dale Davies

Been around for years. I have never seen one in an airplane
at any of the air shows. The gear box is well over 100 pounds.

The torque variation power stroke overlap of a V8 is why less than a
2 rotor never the less the V8 people tend to solve the problem with
a heavy flywheel.

I don't think any stock V8 car engine has gone beyond 300 hours in
an aircraft.

Paul Lamar


No arguments from me on this. Just thought there may be some interesting
information for some of us less knowledgeable to ponder.

It seems to me that the flex plate bolted to a piston engine, would not last
very long. Maybe Dave has the right idea to have more mass at the flywheel to
damp the torsional pulses. They are minor compared to a piston engine but at a
high continuous power setting they may be destroying the flex plate. Maybe a
stock flywheel is the answer as they have no lightening holes close to the
center that allow flex.

Maybe for those with a flex plate installed, it could be reinforced with a 1/4
or 1/2 inch disc. Make the ID the same as the reinforcement plate for the
bolts. The OD could be 1/4" less than the inside of the flex where the ring
gear mounts. Use a mill to make it and drill the holes.
1/4 plate disc would move the PSRU by that amount and possibly require spacing
it back unless the 1/4" can be taken up else where.

Dale Davies


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.