Subject: One way and centrifugal clutches NSI PROBLEM
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/16/2011, 7:51 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



-----Original Message-----
From: Rotary Engine [mailto:rotaryeng@earthlink.net]
Sent: 15 August 2011 22:46
To: AAA Put this in the To box
Subject: One way and centrifugal clutches

   After reading about all the failures related to the damper, I started
   to research into the subject of torsional resonance and found this
   article on how they have solved their problem on Bede 5. The original
   PDF is rather long so I just copy part of it for you to take a quick
   look. You can find the original file here
   http://ibis.experimentals.de/downloads/torsionalvibration.pdf

   The part that I think is of most interest is reproduced here:
   "THE FREEWHEEL CLUTCH
   The idea for a freewheel clutch came from our machinist, Ray Johnson,
   and I must give him the credit. He came in one day and told me that
   when he was a kid, his dad had a thrashing machine on the farm They
   would run the belt from the tractor to the thrashing machine and it
   had a freewheel device on it so that any vibration coming from the old
   two cylinder John Deere would be somehow taken care of. The minute he
   said "freewheel clutch", it rang a bell. After previously seeing the
   oscillating torque reversals of the prop I knew we needed some way to
   allow a torque reverse to occur without the bounce back. I had been
   looking at centrifugal clutches, manual clutches, etc. that could be
   used to disengage and allow some slip. We even tried a test with a
   super loose belt with idler pulleys but the slop still wasn't enough.
   The torsional amplitude was just too great at the low system frequency
   we were dealing with.

   Immediately after Ray mentioned the freewheel clutch, I started
   investigating and found a Borg Warner clutch that was used in
   automatic transmissions It was a double cage, full phasing sprag
   clutch. The double cage caused all the little cams inside to engage
   precisely at the same time. I had previously had experience with
   freewheel roller type clutches at Avian but we had problems with the
   brinelling of the clutch races when one roller would engage before the
   others and momentarily take the full torque, causing eventual clutch
   failure. The double cage full phasing, sprag clutch solved this
   problem."

    From there, I wonder if Tracy's original design really works or not? I
   am not sure if enough on the subject of torsional resonance has been
   done. May be even a different approach is necessary?

   Also, from my readings, it seems that many people recommends more
   cylinders for smoother torque curve. In my simple mind, a smoother
   torque curve alleviates the problem. The 2 rotors have one firing
   every 180 degree, similar to a four stroke so torque curve is not
   smooth. (See information on EPI Inc. on this subject)  A 3 rotor is
   similar to an in-line 6 at 120 degrees so may be 20B is more
   suitable/reliable for aviation? A 4 motor would be even better. Many
   great airplanes in WWI are V12s and they would not have a lot less
   problem with torsional vibrations.

   I am not a mechanical engineer, so anyone out there please correct me
   as much as they can. I am not building yet, not even a license to fly.
   But sure hopes to find time to do it soon.

   Henry Nee

    Hi,  One way and centrifugal clutches can help if the system has a low
rpm resonance peak.  The drive is not connected or only 1/2 connected so the
build up of loads at resonance can not occur.  If you go through the
critical rpm only once on start up and shut down, clutches can work.  If the
critical rpm is in the operating range, they will most likely fail.
The NSI gearboxes used sprag clutches.   I have info on the effect of the
SGF coupling on the Porsche aircraft engine if anyone is interested.
Similar torque, rpm and  firing freq as a two rotor.  I have a Mercedes SGF
and the part numbers do not match the SFG chart.  Matching dimensions may
identify oem units.  Since they are normally used behind the cars gearbox
and see first gear torque, a unit from a pretty small engined car would be
likely the right size.  Finding a retail source other than car parts
departments might be a challenge.  I'll do a little searching.

Murry


Decades ago you could get a manual transmission car with overdrive accessory
.... and it had a one way clutch that might be applicable.  The older SAABs
with the 2 cycle engine also had one way clutches in the transmission to
prevent car momentum from spinning the engine on overrun since there was
little to no lubrication to the engine if the throttle was closed.  Either
of these parts might be used.

SD

Hi You Guys

Here's a picture of what happens when an NSI engine stops in flight.

The engine was stopped dead in flight due to the alternator bearing ceasing
( this was because adding the second belt NSI deleted the cooling fan,
bearing became too hot and ceased and in turn two belts and the ceased
bearing were enough to stop the engine turning).

Anyway my point is this.  with the engine stopped the freewheel was now not
locked up so the propeller freewheeled and being in windmill mode created a
HUGE amount of drag.

The pilot reported a rate of descent in the order of 3000 feet per minute,
from memory I thing he was only 2500-3000 feet.

I think this is the same type being discussed here, so thought you all
would want to know.

Kind regards Clive.


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.