I emailed Rexnord rep to see if he had any fluid coupling ideas
for me...guess not...
Begin forwarded message:
From: Brian Clark <
Brian.Clark@rexnord.com
Date: August 24, 2011 2:14:57 PM CDT
To: gene kahn
Subject: RE: question about fluid coupling
Gene, spoke with some engineers about your application, the HP is
no problem, but the max speed for a fluid coupling is 1800 rpm.
If you are looking for soft/start flexibility you might want to
look at a inverter for the motor. Thanks Brian Clark
Brian,
I am investigating the use of fluid couplings for applications
of up to 600 HP, at 6-8 thousand rpm. The diameter could
be up to 14 inches or so, and the length [the thinner the
better] could be up to 6 to 8 inches. Do you have anything
like that? Thanks.
Gene Kahn
If one reads the article on the Fluidamper harmonic balancer that
someone put on this cite, it says the silicon in it never wears
out and heat doesn't bother it. It will turn to several
thousand rpm. Seems like the silicon is coupling one piece of
metal to another to allow minute rotatational reversals. Hope
someone can use engineering voodoo to make something like that work.
Van
Hi, there are such couplings used in some all wheel drive cars/trucks.
Murry
Hi all,
Paul has mentioned that fluidamper type dampers have so far been
designed for "crankshaft" type applications. I took that to mean lower
frequency range, stronger torque pulses and probably larger amplitude
torsional twisting of the crankshafts. The Fluidamper article
says that they have designed their product specifically for DIESEL
engines, which we know operate at lower rpm range from piston
gasoline engines, and could also exhibit different torque pulses
and crankshaft twisting depending on the specific design.
All I was thinking is that the basic idea behind the fluidamper
might be adapted somehow for our uses...for smaller, more frequent torque
pulses etc. Perhaps a stock fluidamper could be drilled and
lightened, or different fluid could be substituted, etc etc. If
not, there is so much talent on this newsletter we could possibly
design our own from scratch. Even if we have to buy a new
fluidamper, cut it open to see how it is made, it could be done.
Paul tells us that our big problem is with "gear chatter". I do
not know if the primary source of gear chatter is intrinsic to the
gears themselves, or if they chatter a lot more with whatever
torsional vibrations come from the rotary itself [probably both].
If some come from the rotary itself, perhaps those could be
largely attenuated by some adaptation of the fluidamper or
whatever. If some gear chatter is intrinsic to the gearbox itself,
then that might have to have its own separate solution...immersing
the gears in viscous oil to simply damp the vibrations, or perhaps
by changing the moments of inertia of the gears through addition
or sub- traction of weight in gear(s), or changing the materials
out of which one or more of the gears are made ($$) thereby
altering the torsional coefficient and affecting the primary
frequencies of vibration etc.
I also was thinking that we have not actually tried Paul's new design
damper/flexplate. Heck, the stock flexplate sort of works, but develops
cracks over time. Could be worse. And we don't have much time using
the aftermarket flexplate. I thought the idea of using larger
rubber bushings was good, and Paul's redesign great. If heat dissipation
is a big issue for the rubber pieces, perhaps a housing could be
designed allowing an oil spray to be directed onto the rubber bushings
and collected for circulation through a heat exchanger.
Just food for thought, I hope.
Gene Kahn
I have total confidence in the engineers on this cite that they will
figure out a way to use fluid/viscous couplings if it is even
remotely possible. Just seems to me that if silicon is impervious
to heat and wear (as per Fluidamper ad), then silicon sure is worth
pursuing as the coupling agent. Only question is, why is it limited
to 1800 RPM. If you could just build a BIG fluidamper type PSRU
(forget about the harmonic balancing aspect and just use the design
aspect) filled with a very stiff silicon so that there wasn't any
slip but only allow micro rotational reverses (like the rubber in
the current damper/flexplate allows) it would work???? But, I don't
know if I'm all wet.
Van
Gene, Fluidamper also sells a line of automotive torsional dampers for
racing and another for street, as well as the heavy duty engines dampers.
These are designed for specific applications due the the specific torsional
demands of a particular engine. The diameters, inertia ring mass, the
clearances and I think the fluid are tweeked to remove the torsion at design
RPM range.
All wheel drive vehicles have a different system like a limited slip
differential, but the silicone fill lubricant causes them to lock up more as
the speed difference increases. Not quite what I see as needed.
RE the fan clutches, Dodge Diesels also use this drive system
Van, the Rexnord couplings are designed for industrial applications which
is what will limit their RPM capacity. I have had to remove and install
numerous Fluidampers on heavy duty engines. Some of the Detroit Diesel 16V
engines use two on the front of the crank. They build these using what starts
as two 8V blocks but are machined differently so are really 16V blocks. One is
the front and the other the back. They also build a 20V with a 8V in the
center and a 6V on each end. Anyway, these engines run to 2100RPM in
continuous operation limited by the internals. The race 6V engines are
modified to run to 3600RPM with the stock damper. Injectors to 220mm cubed
instead of stock 90mm units. Lots of cancer causing smoke like the pullers.
These dampers would not be easy if at all possible to modify.
As regarding gear box chatter, search Lycoming redrive early failures. They
found light throttle on approaches was causing chatter and early failure. To
improve gear box life the pilots were trained to load the gear box; either
with power to take off or cruise, or closed throttle for landing.
Dale Davies
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.