Subject: Crowning the sun gear
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/5/2011, 11:10 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


  Here is another possible approach to reducing gear chatter
  [attached file]  which would be located forward of whatever flex
  plate we end up with?.  the red drive gear is coaxial with the
  eshaft, which drives the green  internal gear directly, and the
  power is transmitted to the outer purple  gear via the black-colored
  rubber bushings.  Of course this is only a  representation of a
  concept where rubber bushings are placed as close  as possible to
  the source of gear chatter, which is difficult to do with  planetary
  gears.  Also, the purple gear would not have to necessarily be
   outside the green gear, but it could be placed forward of the green
  gear,  and its 'fingers' could extend between the rubber bushings in
  an axial  direction instead of the radial direction shown in my
  crude drawing.  This  would be analogous to the products shown in
  the attached Centaflex file.  [So have we agreed that Rhino2 is as
  good as any?  Anything cheaper?]

    This concept could be used to raise the prop thrust line, allowing
  more  room over the engine to consider using stock Mazda components such
    as water pump etc.

    Gene Kahn

    Excellent idea Gene!!!! Good work. All we need is a new ring gear
holder
    and slots milled in the PSRU housing. I think chunks of round
    silicone rubber rods will work.

    What is shown is an internal spur gear but it will work fine with
    a planetary. Much simpler than what we are trying to do now,
    Will require a new PSRU housing but that is no real problem.

    I think we can saw off Tracy's box and weld on a new aft section.
    Will stiffen the motor plate in the bargain.

    I will draw it up.

    I like Rhino but it is up to 4.

    Good work Gene. Why to think.

    Raising the trust line is not the way to go. Not needed and less
  cowl volume  for the cooling system. The RX8 water pump is no higher
  than the rotor  housing.  Been there done that.

    Paul Lamar

     Hi, a soft mount for the ring gear is an excellent idea,  I
  thought of it years ago. Found out that R-R used it in their Eagle
  of 1918.

  Murry I Rozansky

  Here is a Rhino 3D dwg hot off the press.
  The advantage over the R-R is silicone rubber.

  Paul Lamar



  What is the expected load on the silicone? I realize that you have put a
  number of rubbers in and the load on the ring gear is not the same as
the load
  on the sun gear. I do not think this will eliminate gear box chatter
after
  reading about Lycoming gear chatter related early failures. Solved by
not
  running at light load while landing. Gear clearance kept on one side of
gears
  or the other by the engine driving the prop or the prop driving the
engine.
  This design may reduce how the gear lash is taken up by softening the
hit when
  it does want to chatter.

  Dale Davies

  Yes we do not expect it to eliminate chatter. We must still idle
  the engine at 1800 to 2000 engine RPM.

  Paul Lamar

I was googling planetary gear chatter and came across this guy's article:

http://machinedesign.com/article/crowning-a-cheap-fix-for-gear-noise-
and-misalignment-problems-0212

I emailed him today and he emailed me back here it is.
gene kahn

-----------------------------------------------------
Fred,

I am using a Ford planetary set in a homebuilt application.
I experience gear chatter at about 1800 to 2000 rpm when
the system is basically freewheeling in this rpm range.  The
system does go as high as 600 HP input power, with a 3:1
planetary reduction.

Would your crowning idea be beneficial?  Could this idea
be limited to just the sun and ring gears...instead of also
having to redo the planets?

Thanks for your time.

Gene Kahn
--------------------------------------------------------
I'd have to see a print or sketch of the Sun, but depending on its
configuration it could be crown shaped or hobbed. It is rare to crown an
internal, but we did it to some helical internal rings because the
Chinese manufacturer of the external pinions refused to crown hob them.
Generally you would only crown one member-ot the planets and the
internals.

Fred Young CEO
WWW.forestcitygear.com

Well somebody needs to try it and see if it works. I doubt
it will cure gear box chatter.

Paul Lamar
--

Hi Paul,  I think that low rpm gear chatter has one of two causes;  low rpm
driveline resonance and/or torque reversals between firing impulses.  A
heavy flywheel will do the trick but is not a great idea for an aircraft.
As you can see in the Porsche graphs I sent you the SGF doughnut lowered
the resonant peak below idle rpm.and greatly reduced the amplitude.  I bet
they had idle gear chatter too.  If a soft, spring or rubber coupling has
enough travel to keep positive torque loading on the drive line until the
next torque pulse arrives, there will be no torque reversals and no gear
chatter.  A low rpm disconnect works but "less is more." and  " Simplicate
and Add Lightness"  are still good ideas.  Being able to buy at a
reasonable price and bolt in a soft coupler is the quickest way to get into
the air.  The problem is to find one soft enough to be effective, that can
handle the torque and rpm.


Murry I Rozansky

The 2 rotor has no torque reversals unlike a 4 cyl piston engine.

A car is a different situation. The engine is disconnected from the gear box
at idle. No real analogy. We tried a lower durometer and it made no difference.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.