Subject: centrifugal clutch and gear box chatter.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/6/2011, 2:54 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


 When I first saw Bud Warren's centrifugal clutch something  in
 the back of mind was trying to tell me he did not build it.
 The parts looked too slick and too finished to be custom made.

 I think I figured it out. They are stock parts out of Center Force
 clutches. Of course Bud never talked about that.

 http://www.centerforce.com/clutches.tpl?subsection=clutchtypes#

 Ironically I have one in my my RX8. I love it. It works great.

 This will solve the gear box chatter problem if set up properly.

 The question is how thick must be the flywheel? That will
 affect the over all weight.

 BTW I don't think it was the cause of Bud's fatal crash.


 Paul Lamar


 Confusing pics though....  it seems you've got a few pics of
 subaru/eggenstein's --  did they use
 bud's drives?

 William Mason

 Yes. He sold several.

 --------------------------------------------------------------
 Center Force also make a compatible aluminum flywheel for the 13B.

 Paul Lamar


   There is another way to eliminate the gear chatter.  Throw the
 gear box
  out.  Mount an alternator on the eshaft,  a prop on a direct drive
 electric
  motor and all the drive line problems go away. Like a diesel electric
  locomotive. Any remaining problems can be handled in the software of
 the
  controller. The option of adding batteries would exist if you want
 to be
  way trendy.

  Murry I Rozansky

  As I said many times before on here electric drives of that type
 suck big
 time.  This is a recording :)

  The motor is 85% times the alternator is 85% the over all effciency is
  .85 times .85 = .72% over all. You are wasting 30% of your fuel.
  Locomotives do it for one reason and one reason only. High starting
  torque.

  Paul Lamar

  Hi Paul,  was meant to be a humorous.  If there are no torque
 reversals,
 it must be drive line resonance.  What else could it be? Has any one
 tried
 running with a solid shaft connection, no flexible element?  A soft
 enough
 coupling should work. A disconnect will of course and a Bud type is
 simple
 and compact enough to fit. If it does not cause operational or safety
 problems to idle the engine above the chatter speed, why is  gear
chatter
 getting so much attention?  Some of the couplings have a surprising
 amount
 of wind up at their rated torque.  I think some were over 10 degrees.
If
 chatter at idle, when there are very low loads does not damage anything,
 maybe the problem is of a more psychological or esthetic nature.
Tracy's
 damper design just seems overly massive to me.



  Murry I Rozansky

 Tracy's rubber bushings are so stiff for all practical purposes it is
 locked
 up. I suspect there would be no difference. Same gear box chatter.
 It is not unique to the rotary either. That is why Bud attempted to deal
 with it.  You have this huge flywheel on the out put end of the gear
 box called
 a prop :) Could be caused by a combination of many things. Slop in the
 splines or gear back lash. You will never get away from some wear or
 slop.
 Molt Taylor was the first to deal with it by using a centrifugal
 coupling.
 It was noticed by Allison on the shaft drive P39 back in the 1930's.


 The down side would be prop wind milling which would increase the power
 off stall speed. In fact that could have killed Bud if he did not
 realize it. It was a low altitude stall spin crash. You must land faster
 with a wind milling prop. If you do a wing over to turn around the
 prop might stop. Then again if it did not stop you would lose
 a lot of altitude.

 --------------------------------------------------------------

 This last chart shows for certain pitch ranges the wind milling
 prop is less drag than a fixed pitch prop. It may turn out
 to be that way if you have a fixed pitch cruise or top speed prop.

 I think one must test for this at altitude where is is possible
 to restart the engine or make the runway regardless.
 Since the prop must drive the gear box backwards wind milling may
 not occur using Tracy's gear box.

 Slipping is a similar high drag situation so by all means practice
 slipping on final. IMHO I would never try to make a conventional
 approach with a dead engine unless I was so far down wind and so low
 I had no other choice. In my opinion slipping is under rated.

 Paul Lamar


 I believe that Paul is correct is suggesting a free-wheeling windmilling
 prop is relatively low drag. Some of the X-plane users could probably
 give us a good analysis of the drag. The charts shown presume the prop
 is turning an engine, which represents a considerable load, increasing
 the drag. A lot of the drag from a loaded windmilling prop comes from
 spoiling the airflow over the wing in the wake of the prop.

 Victor Roberts



Hi all, I just had a thought.  The low rpm chatter may be from the prop
going forward when the mass of Tracy's damper is trying to go the other
way. Chatter is typical when the gear teeth change sides through the
clearance between the teeth in mesh.  Taking as much rotational inertia out
of the damper plate or going to a much lower flywheel effect coupler may do
the trick. Is there a simple way to test for the natural freq. of the
prop-gearbox-damper system without it being connected to the engine? That
will be the chatter freq. that can be excited by firing impulses even if
there are no torque reversals.


Murry I Rozansky

I want to emphasize for the new guys that chatter is not a real show
stopper and we have learned to idle above the chatter RPM.
There are some certified airplanes out there where you cannot
run the engine in certain RPM ranges due to prop vibrations.

Paul Lamar



Good point Paul.  I think all of the Rotax powered airplanes chatter
on start up..  As long as passing through that zone each
startup/shutdown doesn't damage anything, no-biggie.

This brings up another question (sorry)..  Does the RPM at which the
chatter happens vary much with airspeed?  Might be a factor in low
speed maneuvering.

Another scenario in which gear lash might come into play is when
transitioning from the engine driving the prop to the prop driving the
engine (going from cruise flight to a steep descent with the throttle
closed)..  I would guess that this would only be an issue if you
didn't smartly close the throttle..  If you slowly bleed the throttle
closed, you might go for some amount of time where the prop RPM caused
by the slipstream is precisely matched my the RPM of the engine..

I know that operators of the big aircraft that have gear reductions
are admonished to never allow the "prop to drive the engine" though
this rule may apply to radial engines that have master rods, or some
such thing.  I'd guess this is nonsense as there are numerous
aerobatic aircraft that have geared engines (think WWII fighters).

I can envision what is essentially a lashless gear interface.  One way
to do it would be to have helical cut gears..  One of the gears would
be split such that half of it would sit on a splined portion of the
shaft and be free to move along the shaft.  Its motion along the shaft
would be controlled by a spring or compliant material.  When the gears
are meshed, half of the gear would engage one face of the mating gear,
and the spring material would force the other half of the gear to
engage the other face of the gear.  It would be a bit draggier because
there would be more friction, but that might be worth it.


Matt-


I don't know about that. In all the rides in half a dozen different rotary
powered airplanes I have had I never experienced it in flight.
When I get the RV4 flying I might have more info.

Of course even the C182 shutters a bit on start up and shut down.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.