Here is another possible approach to reducing gear chatter [attached file]
which would be located forward of whatever flex plate we end up with?.
the red drive gear is coaxial with the eshaft, which drives the green
internal gear directly, and the power is transmitted to the outer purple
gear via the black-colored rubber bushings. Of course this is only a
representation of a concept where rubber bushings are placed as close
as possible to the source of gear chatter, which is difficult to do with
planetary gears. Also, the purple gear would not have to necessarily be
outside the green gear, but it could be placed forward of the green gear,
and its 'fingers' could extend between the rubber bushings in an axial
direction instead of the radial direction shown in my crude drawing. This
would be analogous to the products shown in the attached Centaflex file.
[So have we agreed that Rhino2 is as good as any? Anything cheaper?]
This concept could be used to raise the prop thrust line, allowing more
room over the engine to consider using stock Mazda components such
as water pump etc.
Gene Kahn
Excellent idea Gene!!!! Good work. All we need is a new ring gear holder
and slots milled in the PSRU housing. I think chunks of round
silicone rubber rods will work.
What is shown is an internal spur gear but it will work fine with
a planetary. Much simpler than what we are trying to do now,
Will require a new PSRU housing but that is no real problem.
I think we can saw off Tracy's box and weld on a new aft section.
Will stiffen the motor plate in the bargain.
I will draw it up.
I like Rhino but it is up to 4.
Good work Gene. Why to think.
Raising the trust line is not the way to go. Not needed and less volume
for the cooling system. The RX8 water pump is no higher than the rotor
housing. Been there done that.
Paul Lamar
I want to go back and reexamine what is causing the gear chatter to
start with... Why doesn't my car suffer from this when I drive it at
low RPM? Does the RX8 do this? Can it be driven smoothly at an
engine RPM of 1000? If not, I maintain that something in the
gear/prop system is flexing at a resonance similar to that of the
torque pules coming from the engine.. I suspect the resonance
frequency of the drive train may be very low because of driveline and
suspension flex - corresponding to an engine idle speed that's
extremely low - below its minimum unloaded idle RPM.
Side question: The prop should be quite stiff in the lead-lag (to
borrow from helicopter main rotor terminology), but not as stiff in
the "flapping" axis. Does the flapping flexibility translate into
lead-lag resonance? If so, do props of different diameter/stiffness
have different chatter RPM peaks?
And another issue.. I believe somebody in the past made a PSRU around
the design concept that minimum gear lash would put any resonance out
of the operation RPM - Steve Beckham may have been involved? I asked
a long time ago about wear causing gear lash to increase, and how that
impacted resonant/chatter behavior.. Any thoughts? If this system
(spur gear?) doesn't suffer this problem, maybe it's because the
flexibility in the such a system is fundamentally different from the
planet gears that we're running..
Finally, is the chatter happening between the sun gear and the
planets? Or between the planets and the ring? Or are we hitting a
frequency where the carrier is involved in the resonance, causing
vibration between both gear interfaces (sun-planet, planet-ring)?
Maybe these questions have all been answered... But if not, I think
we may chase this without much success. However, if we can come to a
good understanding of the fundamentals, and robust system might be
fairly cheap and easily implemented..
If the automobile model is valid, maybe we just need something quite a
bit softer... Making something more robust, as was done with Dave
Leonard's system, might make things worse by raising the resonance
interaction frequency.. It might need to be, at the same time, softer
and stronger.
Regards,
Matt-
The RX8 does not do it if you merely take your foot off the accelerator
in low gear (man TX). It will merely move away at low speed.
However if you rev it to say 4000 or 6000 RPM and you step off the
clutch you can get severe chatter in the drive line. Higher revs
7000 to 8500 RPM results in no chatter just wheel spin while smartly
moving off.
Paul Lamar
Maybe the 4000 - 6000 RPM behavior is wheel hop.. I had an old Volvo
with 5-link solid axle suspension that did that.. Dump the clutch,
the suspension winds up, eventually breaks traction, unloading the
suspension, tire reconnects, repeat..
Matt-
Paul, I like Matt would like some discussion on the origon of planetary
chatter. The RX-8 manual transmission being a spur gear gearbox seems
irrelevant. Of more interest would be an RX-8 automatic. If it is slowed
down in gear with low power input does it also have chatter. If not could
the torque converter be the reason or are there other factors such as the
weight of the clutch packs and drums acting as a flywheel. If it is the
torque converter what is the real thermal loss of HP. The EPA mileage
estimates are usually about 1 MPG lower for a non lock up torque converter
compared to a standard transmission. This seems reasonable since the tube
running through the radiator end tank is the only cooling. Also the MPG for
lockup torque converters is usually the same as for standard shift.
In our case we have the ring gear mounted stationary so no
movement and no resonance contribution. The planetary is connected to the
prop which is a serious flywheel, however it is a splined connection which
depending on fit could be a contributing factor. The sun gear and input
shaft are also splined to the damper hub with some clearance. This
connection however does not have the benefit of lubrication. One possibility
is that the planetary carrier is not rigidly connected but floating between
the splined connections.
Jean Prudhome is mounting his planet carrier
integral to the prop shaft (no splines) and as a result may not have chatter
problems. For the rest of us a method of taking up the spline clearance on
the input/sun gear shaft might be of benefit. Some type of epoxy might be
a possibility, or chrome plating the shaft and or hub to fill the clearance
with chrome or even copper plating. If it is not the fit of the splined
connections that only leaves the planetary gears. If they need the current
amount of clearance then electroplating obviously wouldn't help, however
running a higher viscosity oil in the gear box would tend to cushion the
gear mesh.
If I remember correctly the Ford type F transmission fluid is
equivalent to sae 10 weight oil. Are we running a lighter oil such as 5W20
in the aircraft engines or a turbine oil due to the flooded rotor/
eccentric shaft and high RPM. I*n the borg warner 4407 I have a gerotor
pump between the sun gear shaft bearings and can use that to circulate and
cool the 85 wt gear oil. With Tracy's box being run with engine oil I would
think we would want to tap off that oil from the coolest oil location of the
engine, couldn't hurt.Possibly a small cooling core on the line from the
engine to the gearbox.Any heat rejected there would just be less for the
engine oil cooler to cool. Then there is a possibility of supplying the
gearbox and is it the optimum location and maintaining a particular quantity
of oil in the gearbox.
Another thing that concerns me is if we have chatter we can hear and
have to avoid it, are there resonance problems in multiples of the affected
RPM that we can't hear which could damage the gearbox, or are we never
running at that higher RPM node. If for no other reason than avoiding
replacing parts it would be nice to sort this out. We are fortunate that
Tracy builds such a reliable and flight proven gearbox and EFI system and
makes it available to the rest of us, however P-ported three rotors and
turbochargers
may dictate we need a better understanding of the gearbox.
george grimes
I think just a bit of beefing up of the weak spots is all we need.
A better flex plate incorporating the rubber bushings and a stronger
connection between the splined input shaft and the sun gear will do
the trick. Our man Dave Leonard will find out in a week or so at Reno.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.