Subject: Large rotary engines for aircraft use.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/17/2011, 9:24 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Hello, and good day, Sir -

Would an engine like Rotary Power International's 3,000 h.p., 6 rotor
design
of the 580 series make for a good aircraft engine (equivalent to the big
radials of the 1940s)?

Besides the application of regular turbochargers, could a power-recovery
turbine help squeeze even more performance out of the above powerplant (and
what would the maximum power-to-weight ratio be)?


Many thanks,
Cindi

Do you have a couple of million to put them into production?

Paul Lamar


In a way Paul is right, although a little short in the way he said it.

I read an article on the new engines for the 777. In addition to the R&D,
tooling, etc to build it, the FAA required destructive testing of the
engines to simulate in flight disintegration, bird strikes, etc. The
article said that as of then 7 engines at a cost of 15 million each had
been destroyed. That is a direct cost of certification, and will be
incorporated into the cost of each engine forever.

The certification costs include certifying everything from materials to
manufacturing, everything. And while on the one hand it would appear to add
to the reliability of the engine- in so many ways it just adds to the cost.
My "certified" engine came with no guarantees- other than if the FAA thinks
I need to change something I have to comply or stop flying the plane. I
chose the latter. I just will not succumb to the thought that an engine
designed and built in the '60s is worth half of what a house is worth. And
for those counting, my Continental IO520D has appx 1500 hours on it. At 850
it had an OH. So, an engine that will cost me $35K to replace lasts around
800 hours on average. Not acceptable in my book.

The base rotary will cost around 5K, and Tracy has over 1800 hours on his.
At a cost of 5K, I can throw away the engine after 1000 hours for a cost
per hour of $5 per hour. Compare that to $43.75 per hour for the certified
engine and you can see where I am coming from.

Back to the subject at hand- a Certified rotary would be great- but to what
end? What would be gained by it?
I think we would benefit more from a track record of several planes with
many successful hours to show potential builders.

For the sake of argument- suppose one spent the money to certify the
engine. Then what? Then you have to get a certified airframe and establish
a program to have this new certified engine certified with a prop (have to
be certified together) and an STC issued *per airframe.*
This applies to each derivative of the Cessna 172 for example. You couldnt
just go get a 172, install the engine and after 40 hours say it works.
Nope.

So, what would be gained by certifying the engine?
I am just asking, waiting for another opinion.

Kevin Alderman


Right on Kevin.

BTW Mistral spent 10 years fooling around trying to certify the
rotary. We kept bugging them to sell us parts for the experimental
market.  They did sell a few and then refused to sell anymore.
If you are in the legitimate development stage and not selling parts
to the  experimental market you are just plain dumb. Here is a group
of people willing to risk their life and fortune to do the
best kind of end user testing possible for no cost to you adding to
your capital in the bargain.

I found out later the Swiss gov was giving them tax payer money as long as
they were in the R&D stage and not selling anything. The Swiss Solyndra.
Why produce anything when you don't need to. You are still getting a salary.

Remember Zoche was at OSH for years and years? "Production
next year." Even Burt Rutan was raving about it. They are still at it but
no longer at OSH. I went to Aero in Friedrichshafen last year and low and
behold there was Zoche.

http://www.zoche.de/

I think this practice is Euro wide.

Paul Lamar



The Zoche will be in production about the same time as Moller's aero-car
thingy.

Brian Trubee



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.