Back in the days of Rotomax they asked me to help
them design and build a belt PSRU in secret. I did some dwgs
for them and here they are. Rotomax are no longer with us
after a widely publicized crash because they could not
understand or solve the rotary engine charge cooled problem.
Attaching a traditional SAE prop flange was the heaviest part about
my new Rotomax belt drive design.
It just occurred to me our new Ford C9 planetary
PSRU light weight method of attaching the prop to the shaft
can be used.
I added that to the 3D's at the end. The 3D dwg's say it all.
This method of attaching a prop was invented by Warp Drive to
my knowledge and is now supported by no less than Sensenich,
one of the oldest prop companies around. Ironically it was
used in the first Rotomax belt drive design. At the time I did
not recognize the advantages.
IMHO this is one of the most significant inventions in
prop hub design since the beginning of aviation. Not widely
recognized or appreciated yet. It looks too simple
as most good inventions are.
IMHO our planetary driven, large diameter aluminum prop shaft
PSRU design is in the same category. It owes it viability
to the invention of the large diameter ceramic ball bearing.
One new invention leads to another.
Dave Lemon,
This belt drive should be an option for your proposed new one
rotor, LSA aircraft engine.
Paul Lamar
Was there a photo or drawing file?
Bill Jepson
Lots of them. Where you trying to get them on your smart phone?
Paul Lamar
I did not receive them either. Forwarded an e-mail to a friend
and he did not get the print part.
Dale Davies
Here they are again.
Paul,
- Can you summarize the tradeoffs/pros/cons of this cog belt PSRU design
- compared to the new planetary gear design (expected cost,
reliability, - weight, prop hub location, etc). I'd previously
come to think of cog - belt designs as having important limitations
(e.g. trouble dissipating - the heat from belt flexing/friction
leading to reduced belt life) and - axial loads on the eccentric
shaft and bearings that made the approach - less desirable than a
planetary gear design.
Mark W.
Ha! That would be a lot of work.
To summarize see the jpg.
In other words the strength of a shaft goes up with
the diameter to the fourth power so it makes sense
to use a larger shaft. Previously the diameter of
shafts was limited by the size and weight of the ball
bearings required. The bearing ball diameter had
to go up due to the high RPM of the balls.
Ceramic balls can rev faster so the
ball bearings can be used in the thin category
with smaller balls.
My guess is the belt PSRU would be lighter and cost about the same.
However we are talking one rotor here and not 2 rotors.
However the box weight would be about the same for a one rotor
or 2 rotor while the belt would not be suitable for the 2 rotor
in the same size.
The belt shaft/bearing problem is solved by the thin section ceramic
ball bearings.
Go back and re read all the messages we sent out in the last month
or two on this subject. All of these issue were discussed. If you deleted
them shame on you :)
Paul Lamar
There are V8 engines with a belt PSRU that seem to be reliable. These units
do not fly at 6K RPM though. The RPM is less and thus the reduction ratio.
If the PSRU had its own bearings to support the belt reduction, it would
eliminate the axial load on the e-shaft at the expense of weight.
An advantage of a belt PSRU is that it can be used to move the prop away from
the ground. Another advantage is that there is no gear chatter.
Just my thoughts. I think the planetary gear reduction is the better way to
go for most people, provided the operation is adjusted for operating a geared
reduction AC.
Dale Davies
Paul,
FYI:
Speaking of light weight PSRU's, I'm not sure whether you're aware of David
Algie and his company, Algie Composite Aircraft. His site can be found here:
http://members.iquest.net/~aca/index.htm . David seems to be more active on a
Yahoo group at
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/algiecompositeaircraft/ and posts
updates nearly daily there. He has a carbon cased PSRU that can be seen at:
http://members.iquest.net/~aca/images/img04.jpg
According to the site bio, David Algie, the self described
'designer/builder/chief bottle-washer', comes from a 27 year background in the
Indy car design/fabrication world. He is putting together a pretty slick looking
carbon aircraft. The whole project can be viewed on their gallery page:
http://members.iquest.net/~aca/photos.htm
He is pretty innovative and comes from a similar auto-racing background so you
should be able to connect pretty well on some level. I met him at OSH a few
years ago and had an interesting chat over the course of an hour or so. He is
not a Moeller type. He has doggedly designed and developed a project on his own
over a number of years. His is a steep hill to climb but he has stuck with it
and built each section/sub-group with an end goal in sight. My guess would be
that most of the funding (if not all) came out of his pocket. At any rate, the
fit and finish on his work is like jewelry. Hope you find his sites interesting.
Regards,
Jack Hilditch
I'll pass. It is bad enough that aluminum goes away at 500 F.
Epoxy goes away at 200 F. The oil runs up to 250 F.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.