Subject: Re: Rotary p-port timing. #3
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/29/2011, 8:37 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



      These numbers for the Mazda P-port are bogus.
      As Paul has  pointed out, there is an overlap of intake timing between
      adjacent rotor faces.

      When the apex seal is in the center  of the port, two chambers are
   open
      to the intake. From this  position, after 360 degrees of shaft
   rotation
      the rotor face  which was just beginning intake before the rotation
      would
      still be half open to intake after the rotation. The intake  period
      exceeds 360 degrees of eshaft rotation.
      Reference these numbers to after TDC and it becomes apparent they
      cannot
      be true.

      The intake opening at 86  BTDC is 274 degrees of e-shaft rotation
      After  TDC.
      The intake close of 75 ABDC is 255 degrees After  TDC.
      This gives us 19 degrees of shaft rotation where neither  is open.
      For the exhaust, opening at 73 BBDC is 107 After TDC,  and closing
     at 65
      after TDC - 42 degrees of shaft rotation  when no exhaust occurs.

      It appears to me that the interior  circumference of the rotor housing
      is about 27 inches; so 360  degrees of shaft rotation is 9 inches. A
      two-inch port opening  then requires 80 degrees of shaft rotation to
      transit, so the  trailing port opening occurs 80 degrees ahead of the
      leading  port closing. The intake period including overlap is about
   440
      degrees of shaft rotation.
      The exhaust port appears to be half  the size of the intake, so 400
      degrees of shaft rotation from  opening to closing.

      Tell me where I am  wrong.

      Victor Roberts

      Are you referring to these numbers as being bogus?

      Mazda Factory Peripheral Port
      IO 86° BTDC
      IC 75° ABDC
      EO 73° BBDC
      EC 65° ATDC


      These are typical representations of timing numbers used  in rotaries.
      Notice the similarity to numbers for a "J" bridge  port.

      Racing Beat "J-Bridge Port"
      IO 115° BTDC
      IC 72°  ABDC
      EO 88° BBDC
      EC 57° ATDC


      The numbers used are  started at the nearest of four locations.
      A TDC or a BDC.  This to keep numbers small and understandable.
   This is
      adequate to lay out  markings to port an exhaust or intake or lay out
      your

      Pport boring location. And  recover overlap degrees,
      All of these numbers can  be resolved while looking at one rotor face.
      The two TDCs are minimum  volume right or left side and two BDCs
     maximum
      volume
      top (Intake) and bottom (exhaust).

      While it seems backwards, the Pport engines are more  tractable than
     the
      bridge ported side port engines. Although both have very  little
      torque right
      off idle we could drive the Pport to and from the false  grid with no
      problem where the "J" bridge ported were towed with a small  tractor.
      This to save
      the clutch. A Tilton of course.

      The Madeville modified factory Pport housings had  enormous
   rectangular
      intake ports and are also quite tractible at low RPM.



http://alex62.typepad.com/**imsablog/2006/02/mazda_rx7_**winni.html_<http://alex62.typepad.com/imsablog/2006/02/mazda_rx7_winni.html_






http://alex62.typepad.com/**imsablog/2006/02/mazda_rx7_**winni.html<http://alex62.typepad.com/imsablog/2006/02/mazda_rx7_winni.html



     )
      They ran unmuffled at most locations and even with no back pressure
      idled
      smoothly.

      The idea that much if any fuel will be lost to the exhaust system
   at or
      near  cruise RPM is not founded. It is my opinion that when muffled
      and at low
      RPM  exhaust pollution of the intake charge actually helps smooth out
      the
      idle in the  Pported engine.
      Lynn E. Hanover


      I understand the BDC and TDC references. I converted them to a common
      ATDC in order to make the relationships easier to calculate.
   Because of
      the 3:1 e-shaft to rotor gearing, each face of the rotor requires 360
      degrees of e-shaft rotation to pass over any given point on the
   housing
      circumference.

      I guess there is a question of what "port open" and "port closed"
     means.
      In my experience with piston engines, "open" means when the valve
   comes
      off the seat, and "closed" means when the valve returns to the seat.
      "Overlap" defines the period when neither valve was seated. For
     2-stroke
      engines, "open" and "closed" refer the transition from closed to
      partially open and open to completely closed, respectively.

      On a p-port rotary, does "open" refer to  the time the apex seal:
      A. enters the port ;
      B. clears the port; or
      C. some other time?
      What event defines "closed"?

      For an engine to have a volumetric efficiency of 120%, the intake must
      have been charged with pressure greater than 120% of ambient at the
     time
      the intake port closed,  or part of the intake air must bypass the
      intake stroke directly into the exhaust. It would appear most likely
      that an elevated intake pressure would both charge the intake above
      ambient, and force air into the exhaust during overlap, a period when
      exhaust back pressure is at it's lowest. Since most of the
   operation is
      at cruise power, it is this condition I am concerned with.

      I ask here because I have attempted to research these questions and
     have
      been unable to find the answers.

      Victor Roberts

      Here are some diagrams that might help.

      Paul Lamar


     Thanks - that helps a lot. I amend my opinion (not that it bears any
     weight ) concerning direct injection at the oil injection hole; it
     appears that as the exhaust port closes, about 40% of the included
     volume of the intake is ahead of the oil injection hole, and the air
     inflow might very well cause the mix to be richer around the leading
     plug.

     I'll shut up about this now.

     Victor Roberts





     Hello Victor,


     I'll give it a try too. We use these numbers:



     Mazda Factory Peripheral Port

     IO 86° BTDC
     IC 75° ABDC
     EO 73° BBDC

     EC 65° ATDC




     To define a bit more the opening and closing events look at it this
   way.
     The leading apex seal opens a port, while the trailing apex seal
   closes a
     port. That applies to both, the inlet and outlet ports.

     Looking at this scenario, from TDC at combustion the [rotary] piston
     travels around
     until the leading apex seal comes to the edge of the outlet port
   when the
     outlet begins to open. Using above numbers this is at 73 deg. BBTC.
   When
     the leading apex seal comes to the other side of the outlet port the
   port
     is fully open.

     The blow down occurs over the next stroke of generally 180 degrees
   minus
     the early opening of the inlet port which happens when the leading apex
     seal of that same chamber comes to the inlet port at 86 deg. BTDC.
     This is
     73+180-86 = 167 degrees later.


     When the leading apex seal crosses the other side of the inlet port it
     will
     be fully open and both ports, outlet and inlet, are fully open. This
     condition exists until the trailing apex seal has passed over the
   outlet
     port and closed it at 65 deg. ATDC. The beginning of closing is a bit
     earlier.



     The duration of both ports being open is between IO at 86 deg. BTDC
     and EC
     at 65 deg. ATDC or over 151 degrees. On the racing beat J-Port the
     duration
     is IO at 115 BTDC to EC at 57 ATDC = 172 degrees. For overlap only
   these
     two numbers count.



     IC determines the degrees of chamber filling in connection with rpm as
     well
     as IO due to its size needed for breathing.  EO should preferably be
     later
     for more expansion but due to its necessary size it sets the
   position and
     therewith the timing of EC as well.



     Due to these restrictions side ports are being used that however have
     higher flow restrictions.



     I hope that helps.



     Rolf


    You defined opening and closing in the same way I have understood them.
    The apex seal entering the port area is opening of the following
    chamber, and completing transit is closing of the leading chamber.
    Therefore, opening of the following chamber occurs prior to the closing
    of the leading chamber. When the apex seal in in the port, both leading
    and following chambers are open. One shaft revolution later, the
    following chamber is still open as it's trailing apex is now in the port
    and in the process of closing..
     Port opening occurs before port closing.
    I am easily confused by top and bottom and before and after, so I
    referenced all events to TDC and tried to follow them around beginning
    from the top.  So TDC can be represented by 0 or 360, and BDC is
    represented by 180.
    If we represent all events as ATDC, we get the following:

    EO 73° BBDC  = 107 ATDC  (180-73)
    EC 65° ATDC   = 65  ATDC

    IO 86° BTDC  = 274 ATDC   (360-86)
    IC 75° ABDC = 255 ATDC  (180+75)

    This has the ports closing before opening. Confining our discussion to
    pports, according to our agreed definitions this cannot be true. The
    duration of the intake or exhaust is 360 degrees PLUS the rotation
    required to transit the port.
    I apologize for continuing, I was going to let it drop as Paul's last
    post gave me the info I needed, but unless you can show me an error I
    continue to believe the port timing charts to be wrong.

    Victor Roberts


    Hello Robert,

   the answer is that a 4-cycle operations happens over 720 degrees.

   Best is to think of a reciprocating 4-cycle engine. I trust it makes it
   easier to understand.
   Per your distinctions of angles lets say we start out at TDC at firing
   when
   the power stroke begins and call that 0 degrees and count from there
   as you
   did.

   EO 73° BBDC  = 107 ATDC  (180-73)    (*this is correct*)

   EC 65° ATDC   = 65  ATDC (*this is a rotation later*,* should be 425
   deg.*)
   From EO at 73 deg. the piston goes to 180 degrees and then to 360 degrees
   and then travels another 65 degrees until the EC happens. The exhaust
   valve
   is open all that time.
   EC is at (360+65) 425 deg. Valve opening of outlet is over (425-107) 318
   deg.

   IO 86° BTDC  = 274 ATDC   (360-86)  (*this is correct*.)

   IC 75° ABDC = 255 ATDC  (180+75)  (*this is the second rotation,
   should be
   615 deg*.)
   From IO (at 86 BTDC) = 274 deg. the piston goes to TDC then to BDC and
   then
   travels another 75 degrees until it finally closes. The angular
   position is
   (360+180+75) =
   615 degrees. Duration of IO is (615-274) 341 deg.

   The inlet is a bit longer open than the outlet.
   Between outlet open and inlet open we have (274 - 107) = 167 degrees.
   (close to one stroke of 180 degrees, the blow down).
   Overlap when both ports (valves) are open is (IO - EC) (425 - 274) =151
   deg.

   I could provide a relation between port lip location and timing
   values. But
   usually one can't or rather does not change that anyway. It does involve
   some calculation and I rather not go there as it is the realm of engine
   designers. P-Ports cause limitations in port timing.

   Regards
   Rolf




Please put aside the timing chart.
Let us observe a port transition.
Begin with an apex between the spark plugs.
Rotate the eshaft so as to move the observed apex toward the exhaust
port. As we proceed, we reach TDC (0 degrees) and continue rotation
until at some point the apex reaches the exhaust port - we call this EO,
(exhaust open). DO YOU AGREE that EC (exhaust close) has not yet
occurred in this rotation?
As we continue rotating, we pass the center of the port, and the angle
ATDC is increasing. Continuing, we reach the other side of the port, and
we call this EC, exhaust close. Granted that it is a different chamber
that is closing, but this the shaft angle that will close the original
chamber on the next rotation.
If EO occurred at some angle, and EC occurs LATER in the rotation, how
can the angular notation of EC be a number smaller than that of EO (
both expressed as ATDC) ?

As the the suggestion that the duration of either port opening is less
than 360 degrees, consider the following:
An apex is in the middle of a port, so the chamber following the apex is
open to the port. Rotate the shaft one revolution, and the following
apex is in the middle of the port, and the same chamber is, and has been
continuously open to the port. Additional rotation is required to close
the port. Therefore, the duration of the opening is 360 degrees plus the
rotation required for the seal to transit the entire port.

Victor Roberts

Forget all this port timing stuff. It is too confusing and a waste of
psychic energy.
Think of it as a jet engine. Air comes in.... is compressed and explodes
in more or less a continuous process.
Nothing really  opens or closes in the piston engine analogy.

Paul Lamar

-- 
Paul,
I do not agree, the Apex seal controls the housing peripheral port timing,
and the apex seal sliding speed accelerates and de-accelerates, four times
per rotor revoloution, the average of course is equal to the one apex seal
travel around the housing, to a point the ports if bigger produce more power
for the reason that you state above and at steady state RPM does not needto
be any more sophisticated than that.
I noticed that you have deleted my earlier comments, any reason for this?

Bob
UK

Just a mistake Bob. Sorry. I'll see if I can find it.
Is this the one?

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not forgetting that the Apex seal movement is non linier to the eccentric
shaft, for a given rotation of the eccentric shaft, the Apex travels much
less at the minor housing axis, for port timing you must take this into
account, when trying to assess port timing verses crank angle.
I attaché a GWBASIC prog written by me over 25 years ago, when setting up
our Heller machining centre, the program got rid of the need for tool path
compensation, "as switching rapidly from inside to outside compensation
caused the Heller to crash", I also on later programs set the CNC path toa
linier along the housing surface rather than relate to the eccentric shaft
as the different cutting approach speed caused irregular surfaces in the
Aluminium Housing, similar to the chatter that you see on used Housings. By
improvements such as this we reduced the operations and deleted the pre
plate grinding operation, final grind still being carried out on our Koppe
Grinder.

In the program you could set the limit of the eccentric shaft angle and see
how this relates to an x,y postion on the Housing surface, or find a certain
y position housing with major axis vertical and run the program to find the
E angle.


Bob
UK
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Here is a graph of the apex seal velocity. Does not change much.

Paul Lamar
---------------------------------
Hi Paul,
On a later Norton Rotary geometry R=69, a=2.5 & e=11.6, I will needto check
my figures but it seems that if we take the first 10 degrees of the
eccentric with the apex seal start at the major axis place x=0,y=83.1mm,
the linear sliding travel is 6.28 mm,

whiles 10 degrees of eccentric rotation from the seal being in the minor
axis place x=59.9, y=0 produces 1.87 mm of linear sliding travel.

But I do agree that comparisons to piston is misleading as end results due
to Rotor Combustion pocket shape, size, depth, position, and spark plug
position had more effect, I remember that in development for well over 10
years we did not change the port shape or sizes at all.

On the older F&S geometry R=71,mm  a=0.5 mm & e=11.6 mm, first for racing
and then for production the little 'a' value was changed to match the seal
nose radius, this reduced the apex seal travel within it's slot (around 0.15
mm four times per Rotor rotation) and premature apex seal spring breakage
and seal bounce, chatter at High sustained (non bedding in, one sighting lap
and up to race speed) Rpm, to carry out this modification we commissioned
new cams for the Koppe grinder, and the Rotor profiles was also changed to
the same geometry values, to keep the profile clearances.
This geometry was also followed up by one US companies that we did
development work with, TCM or Mercury Marine I just forget, but think that
it was MM.

Bob

Silly piston engine comes to a dead stop at bottom and top of
the cylinder. As Poul Woelfle says; imagine the rotary was developed
first and some inventor came up with a piston engine. The world would
die laughing.

BTW Bob you sent a .BAS file. Normally .BAS files are just plain txt but no
editor
I had could open the file. Could you check that and send it again.

Are you using ceramic apex seals? I notice AIXRO offers them as options.

We are in bad need over here of a two rotor 100 HP aircraft engine.
What are the chances you guys could come with a plain bearing, oil
cooled version of your engine?

Next question: Are you using detonation gun coatings for the wear surface?


Paul Lamar
I am no longer working on the Rotary engine, I did help with developing and
testing and riding from 1968 to 1993, BSA, NVT, Norton Motor 1978 ltd.
I have a lot of my GWBasic program, I do have GWbasic.exe so can copy this
over, I do not think that it is covered by license issues?

Bob Rowley
UK
========================
Paul,
I have imported the data into a spreadsheet for the Housing geometry, I am
not certain if the e=15 mm, R=102 mm & a=3 mm, is the correct data to plug
in for the Mazda but it was the most common.
BTW my Son lives and works in New York and he also drives a RX8, and no he
ain't selling it for scrap engines just yet, whenever I visit he takes great
pride in showing me how fast it goes along the freeway in 1 st gear, my 'Son
is not an Engineer', I tell him to stop doing it when my teeth start to
resonate in sympathy.

Bob




-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2011 All world wide rights reserved.