Subject: Traditional Megasquirt aircraft problems better
From: rotaryeng
Date: 7/12/2012, 3:46 AM
To: AAAA Put this in the To box


     The Megasquirt was initially rejected for aircraft use as there
   was no
     method of
     manually leaning it. The other problem was the Megasquirt relies
   on the O2
     sensor to
     set the mixture. O2 sensors are damaged by 100LL. A third problem
   was the
     throttle
     position sensor TPS was required.

     As I recall Tracy used these problems years ago as the rational
   for doing
     his super
     simple system that uses only manifold air temperature MAT/IAT and
   manifold
     air
     pressure MAP to set the mixture at any RPM. Therein lies part of the
     problem tuning
     Tracy's system.  Some people have taken a year of flying to get it
   right.

     The last thing was the Megasquirt rotary engine ignition problem.
   The
     rotary engine
     ignition problem could be solved using extra hard ware and was
   solved but
     it was a
     messy kludge.

     I agreed with him at the time. That was years (10) before I had
   the idea
     of using one
     cheap Megasquirt per rotor. One per rotor is likely to eventually
   simply
     solve the
     ignition problem using off the shelf computer trigger inductive
   coils like
     the LS1
     and the RX8 coils with out using one CD system per plug. One CD
   system per
     plug is
     more expensive than a computer triggered inductive coil like the
   LS1 or
     RX8.

     I know Motorola/FreeScale  68K asm code so in theory I can fix these
     problems by
     recoding the chip.

     Another way of leaning the Megasquirt is trick the MS computer by
   manually
     adjusting
     the O2 sensor input voltages and simulating the TPS as wide open
   with
     voltage
     dividing potentiometers.

     Perry Mick does something like that using a stock RX7 computer and
     probably has over
     1000 hours on it.

     The siren song of the Megasquirt was and still is the built in
   simple
     EFIS, easy
     tuning using a note book computer and data logging.

     Time and new technology and new ideas tend to change old rational.

     Paul Lamar


         I've thought about the leaning problem with MS for the past
   couple years
         since the issue has come up. Seems you could leave out the O2
   sensor and
         replace it with a pot after the running parameters have been
   programmed.
         Then read your egt for best mix.

         Seems we could also modify the injector dwell time similarly.
   I have a
         couple MS2 boxes and will loan you one if you like. I'm all
   for using two
         crank triggers, optical, hall, or whatever for a CD setup.

         Ed Carver

         Yes! I would like to test them Ed. I can come over and pick
   them up.

         Paul Lamar


       Any time I guess, give me a heads up the night before.

       Ed Carver

       OK Ed.

       Paul Lamar



     Hi   Paul,
       I have been using two MS systems on a 4 cyl
     opposed engine for some time, am about to test on a dyno. I run
   the two
     MS with two complete system sensors,ie., TPS, IAT,CYL temp, MAP,
     seperate fuel pumps ect.,with RPM triggered from two separate
   sensors. I
     was running using the original ignition system, but one failed so I
     upgraded the MS board with a daughter board which enabled me to
   control
     ignition timing, which for me involved relearning how to control the
     ignition advance.

     The two systems run on the same injectors, two leds on
     the dash tell me if both are triggering the injectors,(you can
   switch
     either system off using either the ignition trigger or the power
   to the
     MS system without affecting the running of the engine), BUT, I
   have not
     figured out why when you switch either MS system back on with what
   you
     had switched off the motor runns like SH--t, until you turn off the
     system again that you had originally switched off!!


     I think it is
     something to do with MS on switch on looking at the MAP sensor and
   maybe
     not being able to get a steady voltage from the ignition sensor?? I
     reasoned that as the systems were switching the earth on the
   injectors
     that the left hand would not know what the right hand was doing,
   and it
     seems to be the case, except when one switches off one system!!! I
   have
     used the O2 sensor to program the fuel mixture, the thinking was
   that
     I would remove the O2 sensor after programming. I must be missing
     something with what people are saying about leaning in flight,
   surely
     that if you have a system that adjusts mixture for altitude, and
   load why
     would you want to fiddle in flight, after programming the mixture
   to be
     progressively richer at higher and higher manifold pressures, and/
   or RPM??


     If starting again I would buy the later system with the ignition
     controller built in, even if I was not using the ignition part of
   the
     system, the systems are so well assembled (when bought fully
   assembled)
     I do not think it is worth the bother to assemble oneself.  MS
   does not
     rely on the O2 sensor to set the mixture, that is set with the VE
     tables, you can of course use the Megatune to autotune using the O2
     sensor, but i do not know that I would trust it to tune the range of
     power/manifold pressures in aircraft in flight.
        John Burey

     It is one thing to maintain stoichiometric mixture with changes in
   altitude and quite
     another to lean. Leaning an engine will improve the BSFC at any
   altitude and also
   at the
     expense of power. Most car engines will maintain stoichiometric at
   all times.
     This is a fundamental difference with aircraft engines. Every
   licensed pilot is
     taught this.

     My implementation of two MS systems on a rotary are entirely
   independent.
     The rotor one system never tries to control rotor two and vice
   versa.

     Paul Lamar
     -

     John,
     Thanks for relating that experience!  But even if your injector
   was steady on
     as long as the plug was still firing, there was still combustion
   taking place in
     the combustion chamber instead of the exhaust system unless the
   resultant
     mixture was just too rich to combust properly...dont know...
     Gene Kahn



       Hi  Gene,
                       I guess I forgot to say I have 2 spark plugs per
   cylinder, so the seperate systems are completly seperate (except for
   the
   injectors), I, when changing the mixture tables, and ignition
   tables, do
   it on one MS system, save then download to the other system keeping
   them
   both the same, (timing and mixture). Then restart the engine on both
   systems. There should be a difference when running one spark plug and
   one system but there seems not to be a difference, I guess I will
   notice
   it when running on the dyno.
                  John Burey

   Since both MS systems are in parallel on the injector lines, you
   should
   have an isolation diode in each injector wire from the MS to the
   injector. Without it, voltage may be backfed into the MS system thru
   the
   injector output circuitry, possibly causing the processor to arrive at
   an undetermined state.  This could account for the improper operation
   when power to the MS is restored, as it may bypass the power-on reset.

   Victor Roberts


 John, Victor, Paul and all...thanks for your help!  I would be
 interested
 in adding a second independent leading plug to each rotary
 combustion chamber since we dare not depend on just a trailing plug
 [see prior thread on red hot exhaust systems!], and I appreciate
 Victor's
 circuitry planning for failure mode for 2 plugs.  Mazda's LeMans engine
 had 2 lead plugs per rotor [plus the trailing plug for 3 total per
 rotor]...
 but I am guessing they used a different rotor housing casting.  The
 second leading plug might be positioned close enough to the first one
 [perhaps near the leading plug, and between the leading and trailing
 plug, giving three plugs total per chamber], that the flame front still
 works with the existing rotor face design.  I will investigate this
 with an
 old rotor housing.  If I am barking up the wrong tree someone can feel
 free to set me straight.  Meanwhile, I will take a close look at my
 housing to inspect the coolant passages, and then make a slice or
 two through the housing to get a better look at what metal might be
 available for another plug etc.

 I am also planning on being at Mazdatrix on Monday morning August
 20th and will ask them about this and other things.  If anyone has
 anything else specific they would like me to ask, please let me know.

 Gene Kahn




     Hi   Victor Roberts,
                                      Yes I had thought of the
possibility of backfeed from injectors, and installed diodes, but it made
no difference so for the time being I do not turn off a system, I have
brought out a lead from the MS injector pulse to the dash panel which
indicates if MS is triggering the injectors, does not tell if it is
actually injecting fuel:-( . I had it setup at first with a priming
pulse at switch-on that was too large and if I had switched it off and
on a couple of times it would not start, I overcame that by deleting the
prime pulse whilst fiddling, then restore the prime pulse, the motor
starts instantly hot or cold.:-D
      John Burey


-- The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube key word PaulLamar2 Copyright 1998-2012 All world wide rights reserved.