Subject: retard,timing for the turbo Att Dave Leonard
From: rotaryeng
Date: 8/23/2012, 11:11 PM
To: AAAA Put this in the To box


  Hey, Kevin, sorry to be slow but you asked for thoughts about retard
  timing for the turbo, and I want to do some more investigating (I care,
  because I'm planning a turbo, too), but I do have a couple thoughts for
  consideration.
      The engine has no clue how the manifold came to have the air
  pressure it has, and doesn't care (with caveats).  So, I agree that
  maximum boost should probably be set at 8 psi, but I think the timing
  retard may bear thinking about.  What mainly risks detonation on an
  engine (assuming no stupid levels of boost) are hot intake charge,
  excessive leaning under load, and excessive cylinder pressure when under
  high load/low RPM conditions.  They are interrelated.
     My gut reaction is aircraft are lucky in not having a lot of the
  problems autos face, and for which autos use huge amounts of retard.  We
  don't have to accelerate from low engine RPM at high load, and we often
  soon escape the hot ground level air temps.  A rotary in particular will
  almost always be at what an auto would consider very high RPM (generally
  calling for larger advance, not less) when it is under load.  And an
  aircraft can be manually set on the rich side when at greatest risk
  (take off), which helps cool the charge and has a slower burn rate,
  again helping to avoid the need for extreme retarding.  I'm assuming no
  one would install a turbo without an intercooler, and of course at
  altitude aircraft have a cooler environment for both initial intake
  charge and intercooler cooling.
      I guess bottom line it seems like a bit of retard is likely wise,
  particularly at high load/low altitude like take off, but probably more
  critical is keeping the boost limited during those conditions so the
  manifold pressure never gets too far above what a great breathing n.a.
  motor might see at sea level (and you hear no one calling for retard
  there).  Remember retarding carries its own problems, primarily that if
  the charge doesn't have time to fully burn, you're going to get a lot of
  extra heat in the engine and especially in the turbo/exhaust as it
  continues burning on the way out.  Seems to me that a retard factor
  should be applied, but perhaps only when the manifold pressure and/or
  temperature is elevated above what a n.a. motor might see.  Well, and
  maybe even at cruise if you have altitude compensated the manifold
  pressure (so it thinks it's back at ground level) but are wanting to
  lean it (some retard should be okay there, because a lean mixture will
  burn much more quickly anyway, but since the RPM is high and the load a
  bit lighter, I still wouldn't think too much).  Even where some retard
  is called for, because of the generally high RPM of the rotary, and
  quick-acting, non-valve actuated exhaust system, maybe not retard on as
  steep of a curve or much total as on a auto.  Just thinking out loud.
  Greg


  Greg;

  Thanks. I agree with you on most points- I have read where boosted engines
  are retarded at high boost to counter detonation, with recommendations for
  boost at 8 psi to have timing at 4 deg BTC. Megasquirt code for the turbo
  rotary has a table with just such a setting.
  I agree that aircraft engines operate in a different environment than
  cars, but I would consider it a more severe environment. Yesterday in
 South
  Florida at X51 the reported temp was 92, with our C172 seeing over 100 at
  the end of runway 10 before takeoff. We used full power for takeoff and
  held this setting until 2000 feet. Our density altitude was 1700 feet
  making climbing a bit slow. We were doing practice ILS approaches at KTMB
  with touch and goes, go around and do it again kind of scenario. The tower
  required max rate of climb until 2000 feet for each takeoff. At max power
  and full rich our CHTs were approaching 400 deg, and our CHTs were high as
  well. The point is that for the first critical minutes of flight, we are
  WOT, rich, hot, and running as hard as we can. It is only later than the
  air cools and we get to pull back to cruise. As far as the intercooler, I
  have seen many GA planes that dont have them because they are used for
  normalizing not extra power, and don't kick in until higher and cooler
 air.
  For my application I will incorporate an intercooler, but I dont expect it
  to be of much use at the end of a 100 degree runway. The efficiency of any
  cooler is dependent on the differential temp of the air outside and the
 air
  inside, as well as the density of the cooling medium. Neither is optimum
  here at the moment.

  Contrast this to a car- a race car sees brutal conditions for 8 seconds
  max. An automobile sees max power and boost for a few seconds to take off
  from a stop light or while passing, again for a few seconds.

  Like you I will keep doing more research, but I have concerns about it.
  Depending on what I discover, I will likely tie my boost (i.e. wastegate
  control) to an adjustment related to a knock sensor or intake temps, with
 a
  manual adjustment. If I use an electronic automatic wastegate, the control
  will be electronically adjusted, manually it could be adjusting a tension
  via a vernier and cable like most planes have as a mixture control.  At
  worst I could reduce the boost by a couple of psi and protect the engine
 at
  the cost of a couple hundred feet of runway.

  Kevin Alderman


 Paul, the rotary RV6 that ran at the Reno races last year, is its timing
 fixed?
 And do you know how much boost he runs?

 Kevin Alderman

 Dave Leonard is on here so I think he will answer.

 Paul Lamar

I usually keep it under 45 in MAP.  Tracy's EC2 does retard the timing as
the MAP rises, but I dont know how much.  I set my original timing
according to Tracy's directions, I cant recall the numbers right now.

I know, not a very exact way to win at Reno...  Best I could do on my
budget of time and money.

-- David Leonard Turbo Rotary RV-6 N4VY http://N4VY.RotaryRoster.net http://RotaryRoster.net
-- The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube key word PaulLamar2 Copyright 1998-2012 All world wide rights reserved.