Subject: Recent flight from Everett to Medford / question for Mark mufflers
From: rotaryeng
Date: 8/30/2012, 2:33 PM
To: AAAA Put this in the To box


  This week I flew my RV-4/13BREW from Everett Wa.  to Medford  Ore. and
  back.
  Headwinds on the way down were brisk- 30 kts at 8500 feet on the way down,
  but 35 kt
  tailwind on the way back. The engine ran flawlessly but the plane is slow-
  true
  airspeed was 110 kts at 19.5 manifold pressure,5600 rpm oil temp 161 and
  coolant 170,
  fuel flow around 8 gpm. My prop is a three blade Catto, 72 dia x 88 pitch.

  For one, the plane is  over propped. I'm going to have Craig Catto cut it
  down a
  little during the winter maintenance. The other thing is that the cooling
  scoop is
  effective, but way too draggy, so I'm going to re-do it this winter.

  Another issue is my left brake line- I"ve melted it twice. It's plastic,
  and although
  it is shielded from the exhaust pipes and insulated with fiberfrax, I
  think that
  heated air from the exhaust pipes is being forced out the opening in the
  cowl where
  the brake line goes to the gear leg. That's where I have found the line
  melted. I
  want to put  a reverse scoop near the exhaust pipes to get the heated air
  out of the
  cowl, and to replace the brake line with stainless steel. Everything
  inside the cowl
  except for the brake line looks OK- I wrapped and shielded everything -
  wires,
  coolant, fuel,and oil lines. There are three NACA ducts bringing air into
  the cowl to
  cool the alternator, the coils and exhaust pipes, and an exhaust eductor
  to suck air
  through the cowl and over the muffler.

  Comments?

  Brian Trubee

  Couple of questions.
  EGT?
  Size of throttle body?
  Is the engine ported?

  The manifold pressure is very low.

  Is the air filter plugged? :)
  Are you getting cold air?

  8 GPH is 50 pounds per hour at 6.25 pounds per gallon. At a BSFC of .47
  leaned that
  is only 106 HP. At a fuel burn of .5 that is only 100 HP. If it is really
  rich and
  the BSFC is .55 and that is only 90 HP.

  You need a p-port Brian :)

  Paul Lamar


  Brian,

  As some of you know my Wheeler will be a blend of certified parts and
  experimental parts. I noticed the issues with the nylon brake lines long
  ago. I went to NAPA and bought (8) 12" standard brake lines that go on
  trucks from the hard line to the wheels. I also bought a 25 foot roll of
  3/32 brake tubing, 24 double flare fittings, and a double flare tool.
 Total
  for all of this was $170.00. After I got back to my plane, within 2 hours
 I
  had the brake lines made up from the master cylinders to the wheels. Galv
  steel line inside the cockpit, 12 inch flex at the master cylinders, at
 the
  turn into the wings (mine are removable) one more at the flex point of the
  gear leg, and the last one at the wheel. I don't anticipate melting my
  brake lines. This is the way my Viking was done, and I had no issues with
  my 1968 Viking until I blew the Continental up.

  My fuel and oil system will be similar. The materials are inexpensive, and
  the labor is minimal. Cheap insurance.



  Kevin Alderman

  brian,
                 This is the blind leading the blind as I have yet to depart
  the earth, but tied to a tree I get MP of 22 at 5000 rpm and from memory
 24
  at 5600 rpm.  Where are you reading it from?  Neil.


  It's been a while since I did any static runs on the ground. I"d just be
  guessing at
  this point to give some numbers for static running.

  Brian Trubee


  Brian,

  You stated "...my EGT temps- they show up to 2000 at times- and above
  1800 most of the time in cruise."  I too experienced very high EGT's
  in excess of 1800* when I was using a muffler that was too
  restrictive.  Also, power was way down, but it was quiet.  ;-)  The
  high temps ended up damaging the o-rings and I had to rebuild the
  engine.  Since replacing the muffler the egt's have dropped down to
  1600 - 1650* range and power is much improved.  I suggest you examine
  and modify or replace your current muffler.

  Mark

  The best muffler for a rotary is 3 to 8 feet long about 4 to 5 inches in
  diameter.
  That gives the lowest aero drag for a given silencing. Lowest frontal
  area. Mufflers
  work by the exhaust gases rubbing on the metal surface losing kinetic
  energy to skin
  friction and losing heat to the metal surfaces. The cooler the gases in a
  pipe the
  lower the gas speed. When high speed gas exits a pipe there is a sudden
  expansion
  that causes the noise. The idea here is to cool the gases before they get
  to the end
  of the inner pipe.

  The inner tube is best done in .045 Inconnel but there is a trade off with
  thickness.
  If you make the inner tube 2 inches in diameter and use 321 SS make it
  .065 thick
  with a bunch of holes drilled in it. The outer tube can be .030" thick 321
  SS as it
  will always run cooler. Also make the front of the muffler look like this.

  Don't drill any holes for the first 8 to 10 inches. The slip stream will
  blow cooling
  air down between the coaxial tubes. At the back end make the inner tube 6
  inches
  shorter than the outer tube. That will act as an ejector to draw cooling
  air between
  the two tubes. Patent applied for:)

  A 2 inch diameter SS tube .065 thick 72 inches long will weigh about 8.8
  pounds.

  A 4 inch diameter SS tube .030 thick 72 inches long will weigh about 7.50
  pounds.

  Here is a dwg.

  A 2.5 inch inner tube and a 5 and 1/2 inch outer tube may give a little
  less back
  pressure for a weight trade off.

  Paul Lamar

   Mark ,
   From what you say and from the performance of my plane, I'm
  starting to think that the Hushpower muffler is causing too much
  back pressure and that would explain the anemic performance and
  high EGTs. What type of o-rings were you using and do you think
  that the high EGTs caused O-ring failure and how so?

   Right now I'm thinking of how I can replace the Hushpower with
  the design that Paul just put forth. Its a bit tricky hanging
  that stuff on an RV-4 and working it around the heat exchanger
  and scoop.


   Brian Trubee

  It might be melting inside.

  Here is what Mike Wills did on the RV4 although the front of the muffler
  outer tube
  is not open for cooling air. This is what gave me the idea for the coaxial
  muffler in
  the first place.

  The subtle point is; cooling the inner tube saves weight as there is a
  high temp
  metal durability trade off with weight.

  For an example Perry Mick has been running an early cast iron thermal
  reactor for
  years. They are very durable but they are heavy.

  For anther example Ed Anderson runs SS pipe hand rail with an .109" thick
   wall and
  it hardly discolors. However you don't need a motor mount as the engine
  can be
  cantilevered off the fuse with the exhaust tubes :)

  Paul Lamar

  Brian,

 I was running TES o-rings inner and outer.  The high EGT's exceeded the
 temp limit of the o-ring, allowing it to ooze out between the mating
 surfaces.  I switched to the SS handrail exhaust with a DNA muffler (no
 longer available) and haven't had any more problems, although the DNA
 muffler is not much of a muffler (pretty loud).  People comment they can
 hear me before they can see me.  I wear a Lightspeed Zulu headset.

 Mark

 Got an pictures of those O-rings? Are you sure about the section size?
 Heated silicone can crack cast iron if there is not enough room to expand.

 http://www.rbwagner.com/pages/Rbwagner.html

 Paul Lamar

 Paul,

I'll have to look around the hanger.  I'm pretty sure that I threw them
out.  You may have to get one from Brian.  ;-0

Mark

Not if he fixes it now :) The more I think about it the more likely it is melting
inside. Partially because it is wrapped with an insulating blanket and is inside a
fairing. Seemed like a good idea in the beginning. I think one can get a drill
extension and go in from the tail pipe end  and drill 3/4 inch holes in any baffles
that may be blocking the flow. The bore scope would be the first step.

I have one I can I can loan you Brian. I'll ship it tomorrow. Send me your shipping
address. BTW We may be up there next week.

BTW this is not unique to the rotary. My C182 muffler spit it's guts out in Valdez on
the ramp after a run up. One of my pax saw it and panicked. I said; "Don't worry we
don't need those parts. It's good that it barfed them." :)

Paul Lamar

-- The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube key word PaulLamar2 Copyright 1998-2012 All world wide rights reserved.