Subject: Hushpower autopsy-Mazda rotary mufflers
From: rotaryeng
Date: 9/10/2012, 7:27 PM
To: AAAA Put this in the To box




 We'll I finally got some time off to check out my airplane
 after the
 round trip from Everett to Medford. The heat cooked my left brake
 line, and I suspected the muffler had too much back pressure, so I
 resolved to investigate. Here's what I found when I removed my
 Hushpower from the airplane. There is way too much heat coming
 off my
 muffler- the powder coating on my engine mount is cooked near the
 exhaust pipes, even though I coverd them with fiberfrax and
 placed a
 SS heat sheild to cover the tubes from view of the exhaust. The
 muffler was making like a baby rattle so I cut it open and this
 stuff
 came out of the inlet side. I'll send more pictures of the innards.

 What I have is an RV-4 with the radiators and oil cooler hung
 underneath the plane in a scoop that is reminiscent of a P-51.
 I had
 the muffler submerged under the fuselage. I"m thinking that it
 would
 be better to have the exhaust pipes exit the side of the cowl, in a
 reverse scoop that would vent a huge amount of heat from the
 cowl. The
 muffler would be a straight 6 foot muffler like the one Paul
 outlined
 about a week ago. It would be mounted along the side of the
 fuselage.
 I hate to ruin the clean lines of an RV-4, but nothing would
 ruin it
 more than having a mechanical failure due to excessive exhaust heat
 bringing the plane down. My biggest worry about this rotary
 conversion
 is excessive exhaust heat and how to manage it effectively.

 Here is the muffler cut open. The red chunks are what is left
 of the
 melted insulation material between the perforated inner case and
 outer. The outer case showed signs of bulging. The perforated inner
 case was split on the seam closest to the camera. The inner cone
 material which is also perforated was mostly gone, but big
 chunks were
 still left inside the muffler and undoubtedly were causing some
 obstruction.

 Here's the split in the inner perforated case. Not real confidence
 inspiring.


 Crap that I shook out of my baby rattle/Hushpower muffler.


 Brian Trubee

 That will work out OK but I would put it on the bottom like
 Mike did.
 I think you could get the rad under the engine.

 Either that or use a narrower rad and put it next to the rad
 under the
 fuse.

 Paul Lamar


 If you ever replaced mufflers on a 2nd or 3 gen RX7 you would know
 that Mazda built heavy, massive mufflers. I have a couple
 around here.
 Wonder what the inside design is like? Maybe I should cut one open.
 Marc Wiese

 That would be interesting. Measure the sheet metal thickness.

 Paul Lamar

 maybe something like this coating both inside and outside of
 the exhaust
 system would be useful to reduce heat.
 http://www.jet-hot.com/____**coatings/jet-hot-extreme-2500/<http://www.jet-hot.com/____coatings/jet-hot-extreme-2500/

 chris smale

 Paul and Brian,
 It is great watching your "Big Pictures Minds" working together.
 Listening to ideas on turbo compounding, peripheral ports, etc.
  From my perspective of working on GE, Allison/Rolls Royce, and P&W
 turbines for 35 years here are a few ideas to add to the mix.
 I am suggesting using a 8" by 12" muffler called a turbo.
 Ideally for power to weight a turbine engine would be best for the
 hobbyist.
 The hardest part would be making the gear reduction, fuel control,
 governor and burner can.
 A turbo actually turns a normal engine (recip or rotary) into a turbine
 engine (An old perspective from Hugh MacInnes).
 We then have a compressor and turbine section with the exiting engine
 becoming the gear reduction, burner can, Fuel Control and Governor.
 ..... *and with your peripheral port it actually becomes a power
 recovery compound turbo by blowing directly on the rotor!*
 The exhaust is quieted by removing energy and heat.
 The real problem is controlling heat. We would need to use surplus
 compressed air to cool the exhaust. One place air could be injected at
 the exhaust sleeve.
 We would use a balanced system that could operate 'theoretically" with
 no wastegate like the original GM Corvair. (using a extra large exhaust
 housing AR of about 1.34 or larger).
 Your thoughts,
 Barry


 Barry,

 Before we go too much further, we need a PSRU that can handle 500+hp.
 We've already had flywheels [flex plate] disintegrate and my input
 shaft broke the
 lock pin. I would consider installing a turbo, but in my opinion, the
 psru is the weakest link.

 Mark
 P-port 20b

 Mark,
 Have you guys done any vibration analysis on the gearbox and engine?
 Your 20B would be an easy 500hp but a 13B would be just a "25 lb
 muffler" adding a 100 hp.

 Barry Boardes

 My feeling it would be a waste of time as it depends some what on
 the backlash and that is a function of wear. Vibration is not the
 probelm if you idle it above 2000  RPM. The probem was the stock
 flex plate and the joint between the input shaft and the sun gear.
 Fixed by two pins.


 Paul Lamar




 Paul,

 My situation was exacerbated by a lengthy period of tuning issues.
   Turns out it needed diodes on each of the fuel injectors.  There was
 also a problem with the Renesis style CAS, which I later had converted
 back to the stock CAS.  I'm sure the rough running engine didn't help
 the gearbox any.

 Mark

 The RX8 style trigger wheel with one CAS is difficult to handle in
 software over a wide RPM range. It is easier to use two CAS's 180 degrees
 out. The RX8 software must discriminate between 3 different wave shapes. It
 takes a very fast processor and maybe an EFI specialised computer chip to
 do that. Or missing pulse hardware.

 Which CAS system did you revert too? The 2nd gen or 3rd gen?

 Tell me more about the diodes on the fuel injectors.
 FET's usually have them built in.

 Paul Lamar

 Paul,

I reverted back to the 2nd gen CAS... the one that came with the engine.
 My EC-2 was initially set up for the 2nd gen CAS, but I decided to change
to the newer Renesis "crank mount" style.  Tracy had to "convert" my EC-2
to work with that system.  After over a year of trying to tune it, I
finally had it changed back.  It was an improvement, but there were still
tuning problems.  It wasn't until after Tracy told me about the 3-rotor
applications needing diodes in the injector circuits (very near the
injectors) was the problem fixed.  I don't think the diodes are needed on
the 2-rotor engines, or with the new EC-3 controllers.

Mark

That version has two mag sensors. One for the RPM and one for 22 degrees BTC. That is
much easier to deal with in software. I have an early EFI and I will take a look at
the FET's and see if they are the kind with the built in diodes.

Paul Lamar
-- The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube key word PaulLamar2 Copyright 1998-2012 All world wide rights reserved.