Subject: What the power of a hybrid car range-extender should be?
From: rotaryeng
Date: 11/7/2012, 10:10 AM
To: AAAArotaryeng

AUTOS: Mazda Plans Rotary’s Return

 The unique  engine won’t disappear after the demise of the RX-8, the
 automaker says as it  outlines the future for a rotary-powered sports car.

 The 2017 target for Mazda's next rotary sports car would coincide  with the
 50th anniversary of the first rotary-powered production car, the Cosmo
 Sport.


  Mazda is  working on a new rotary engine expected to debut next year that
 will serve  as a range-extender for an electric  car, which will  most likely be
based on the next-generation Mazda3.

 This seems like a sad future for an  engine that has powered some of the
 greatest sports and race cars, including  a Le Mans winner. According to
 one  of Mazda’s top engineers, the rotary’s future  is actually much brighter
 than simply being a piece of an eco machine.

 Speaking with Car Sales, Nobuhiro Yamamoto, program manager for the Mazda
 MX-5, confirmed that a new RX-7 sports is was in the works and that it will
 be  launched in 2017, the 50th anniversary year of the Mazda Cosmo Sport.
 The Cosmo  was Mazda’s first rotary-powered car and the first volume
 production car to  feature such an engine.

 Yamamoto has a  very long history with the rotary engine. He was the
 power train manager for the  last RX-7, and he designed the engine in the
 Le Mans-winning 787B race car.

 He revealed that the new RX-7 would feature  Mazda’s still-in-development
 16X rotary engine, which will retain the previous  13B’s twin-rotor design
 but will see its displacement increase to 1.6 liters.  Peak output will
 likely come close to 300 horsepower  without the aid of turbo charging.

 Yamamoto explained that special catalytic converters and Mazda’s  latest
 Skyactiv technology will help the new rotary engine be much more
 fuel-efficient than previous versions. He also said there would be no
 hybrid tech on the RX-7 due to its intended  purist sports-car positioning.

 To keep  development costs low, the car is expected to utilize a stretched
 version of the  platform underpinning the next-generation MX-5.
 Overall weight could be less than 2,800 pounds.

 In the U.S., the next RX-7 is expected  to come as a strict two-seater,
 while in other markets a 2+2 seating arrangement  would be offered.
 Although we’ll have to wait five long years to find out.

 http://automotive.speedtv.com/article/autos-mazda-plans-rotarys-return/#

 http://www.motorauthority.com/news/1078803_future-mazda-mx-5-rumors-coming-2015-200-hp-1-3-liter-turbo


 http://www.motorauthority.com/news/1032153_new-mazda-rx-7-to-coincide-with-cosmos-50th-anniversary-report


 http://www.motorauthority.com/news/1078847_rotary-extended-range-vehicle-coming-next-year-says-mazda-ceo


 http://www.motorauthority.com/news/1060292_mazda-787b-four-rotor-race-car-returning-to-le-mans-after-winning-20-years-ago

 Lynn E.  Hanover

Paul,

If the booster engine is slightly bigger than your 27 hp estimate for the
secondary rx8 dual rotary concept, perhaps it might make a great LSA
candidate.

-- Michael S. Francisco

IMHO 27 HP is no where near enough for a range extender. After the battery is dead
the engine must be powerful enough to accelerate a 4000 pound car adequately for
passing at 60 to 70 MPH cruising speed and to climb hills at up to 80 MPH. If it
won't do that it won't sell. It will acquire a reputation of being a dog. IMHO that
is why the GM VOLT is not selling. Surprisingly many auto company executives making
these dumb decisions don't really understand cars. While it is true it only takes 30
HP to cruise at 70 MPH it is absolutely essential that a 3000 pound car has at least
200 HP in reserve for hill climbing and acceleration. The same number for a 4000
pound car is 266 HP.

The weight of the batteries and generator really hurt. If what they say is true about
the most efficient rotary RPM being 2000 then the answer is 7 gears and an automatic
shifting, mechanical transmission like a Formula 1 car. The rotary is a small
displacement, low torque, high HP, high power engine. With any such car engine a good
transmission is essential. Right now the RX8 is cruising around 80 MPH at 3000 RPM
with no noticeable acceleration. It sorely needs to shift down to 6500 RPM for
passing. It would get better MPG if you could cruise it a 2000 RPM and automatically
shift down to 6500 RPM for acceleration and passing..
http://www.rotaryeng.net/RX8-TC-eng3.html

Sooner or later an attempt to recover the 50% of wasted energy in the exhaust MUST BE
MADE in all car engines. If only half the waste heat(HP-fuel) in the exhaust was
recovered the rotary would become the most efficient internal combustion engine in
the world. It has this potential because it has no exhaust valves to fail or to waste
heat (HP-fuel). The best hybrid has two engines. One for cruise and one for
acceleration and hill climbing. Mazda could build a prototype by bolting a small
rotary on the back of the RX8 differential.

Paul Lamar

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is the power of a [electric] hybrid car range-extender should be?

“Hybrid” means that the car has both an electric motor and a thermal engine.
The electric motor and the thermal engine can be used alternatively, or
together at the same time.  The range on electric source only is limited to
fifty miles or so, in some cases like the Toyota Prius, this range is much
less.  The range with the thermal engine running is only limited by the size
of the fuel tank.

But then… If the range is only limited by the size of the fuel tank, why should we
need to add a range extender ?

In fact the word “Hybrid” is used for very different types of powertrains.

Hybrid cars can be divided in two main groups:

1/The  first  group  is “thermal car based Hybrids”. The powertrain is
composed of a thermal engine, gearbox and a mechanical transmission down to
the wheels, and a (small) electric motor-generator is grafted close to the
thermal engine.  This electrical add-on is used to power the car alone, only
for very short distances at low speed.  Most of the time, it adds power to
-or takes power from- the power train so that the thermal engine works on one
of its optimized efficiency charge points.  The Toyota Prius is a typical
example.  Despite the extra weight of the electric motor and the (rather
small) battery, these Hybrid cars tend to be a little more fuel efficient
than their full thermal equivalents but in any case they don’t need any
range extender.

2/The  second  group  is  “electric  car  based Hybrids”. In this group the
power train is composed of one or several electric motor-generators and a
most reduced mechanical transmission to the wheels.  There is no gearbox nor
any thermal engine mechanically coupled to the wheels.  The limited
energy/weight ratio of batteries limits the range of electric cars from 50
to 150 miles.  Adding a thermal engine driven generator transforms the
electric car into an “Hybrid” that has very little to do with thermal car
based Hybrids.  Only electric cars are to be fitted with range extenders.

What is the minimum power required for a range extender?

The  purpose  of  the range extender is to permit almost unlimited journey.
In other words, the range extender shall at least produce enough energy to
compensate for the energy consumed by the extra miles over the normal “only
electric range”.  Thus, the power of the range extender shall be at least
the power needed to cruise at 70 MPH, about 27 HP (20 kW).

What is the maximum power required for a range extender?

The  minimum  power  is  defined  as  the  mean  power  on the complete
journey.  Is a higher power required?  In the case of a completely emptied
battery and a 10% climb, it is obvious that a much more powerful generator
would be necessary : The power for a 2000 kg car to climb this 10% road at
40 m/s (90 MPH) is 80 kW [107 HP], not counting the power needed to roll on flat land
(20 kW [27 HP]). The power of the range extender should then be about 100 kW [134 HP].

Obviously,  to keep good BSFC, these 100 kW can be produced by an 80 kW
auxiliary generator added to the continuously running 20 kW range extender.
But in any case the total weight of these generators would be about 5 times
the weight of the 20 kW range extender alone.  To keep the total weight of
the car in a reasonable range, the battery size, and thus the “only electric
range”, should be reduced.

Are those 100 kW really necessary?

The  “standard”  20 kW [27 HP] range extender produces the power of the car cruise
at 70 mph on flat road.  The energy to lift the car in altitude shall be
taken from the battery.  Lifting a 2000 kg car on top of a 2000 meter (6000
ft) mountain corresponds to 40 MJ or 11 kWh.  This represents about the
third of the energy of a fully charged battery – about 40 kWh-.  This means
that unless the driver deactivates this function, the range extender should
start automatically when the battery is still at half or third of the max
range.  This means also that unless the driver deactivates this function,
the range extender should not stop before the battery is back up to half or
third of the max range.


But what happens if there are several mountains to climb?

Usually  roads  don’t climb several 2000 m mountains without any comparable
descent in-between.  During this descent up to 70% of the potential energy
can be stored back in the battery, and in the same time the range extender
still produce 20 kW.


But what if anyhow the battery is dead?

With  the  20 kW [27 HP] of the range extender alone the 2000 kg car would climb
the 10% slope at 20 mph.  There are several reasons that can lead to this
case: range extender voluntarily deactivated or battery failure, but both
should be reasonably seldom.

A Wankel rotary based 20 kW range extender?

“Mazda  rotary car engine… …has about the same continuous power to weight
ratio as an aircraft engine but is far more robust and longer lasting is
the exception in car engines duty cycle capability wise. The fact alone
that the rotary has no exhaust valves makes it ten times more reliable and
durable than aircraft piston engine.” (Paul Lamar – How to Cool your Wankel
page 8)

These  qualities,  as well as its “omnivorous” characteristics and its very
good BSFC when used in a turbo compound cycle make the Wankel rotary the best
choice to develop a range extender.

No wonder why at least two different Wankel rotary engine based range
extenders are currently being developed in Asia.


Philippe Dejean

Thank you for that excellent analysis  Philippe. That took a lot of work.

I agree with most things except "During this [hill] descent up to 70% of the
potential energy can be stored back in the battery, and in the same time the range
extender still produce 20 kW."

I tested this hypothesis on a hill between Ventura and the San Fernando valley here
in CA with my Honda Odyssey. From an 80 MPH cruising speed I placed the transmission
in neutral and coasted down the hill. If there were potential energy to be recovered
over and above tire rolling resistance and aero drag the vehicle would have sped up.
That did not happen. That indicates that not much hill climbing energy can be
recovered at US cruising speeds. I also tested this in Beverly Glen with a steeper
hill at a lower starting speed with more less the same result. This is a test that
anyone can easily perform.

In South East Asia there are not many hills :)

Also don't forget to factor in the combined efficiency of the generator and the
motor. If each are 90% the net is .9 times .9 or 81% that means that up to 20% of the
net HP out of the thermal hybrid engine is wasted in the conversion.

There is also the issue of repeated passing on 2 lane road. If you deplete the
battery with several consecutive passes it could be a safety issue when
attempting an additional pass.

IMHO a electric hybrid or range extender is not worth the additional weight and cost.
I think the majority of the car buyers in this country agree with me considering
the succeeds or lack thereof of the 4000 pound GM Volt.

Bolt the same small thermal engine rotary on the back of the differential :)
Patent applied for :)

Paul Lamar


The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube key word PaulLamar2
Copyright 1998-2012 All world wide rights reserved.