New Subject, Does anyone have a dimension-ed drawing for a 3:1
reduction box modeled on Tracy's Box?
Milo
This is what I have so far.
Paul Lamar
I measured mine up for CAD drawings before I assembled it, but with the
holidays I haven't had time to draw it. I will get to it shortly.
Kevin Alderman
Kevin, would appreciate a copy. I think it is time to do a 3:1
drive. Would like suggestions from one and all on the appropriate
gears by part number if possible. Also design concepts as well,
like integration with the standard bell housings to keep the costs down.
milo
If you build it like this you can use a relatively cheap constant speed
hydraulic prop.
I forget the attachments.
Paul Lamar
I do that also. I thought they were grey hairs overcoming me, but
there is some evidence they may be blonde:-))).
Dale Davies
Paul, Jean Prudhomme has a PSRU similar to your attachment drawn up
in Rhino and made the casting patterns for it. I don't know the
current status but perhaps he will let us know.
george grimes
George, do you know what the part numbers for the bearings and the material
and heat treat for the shaft
Milo
If you copy the Lycoming crank shaft dims you can use the Lycoming
shell bearing and front stretch over oil seal.
That is what I would do. It is a proven design. Some times you can
make the smallest of changes in a design and run into all sorts of
unforeseen problems.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
The real expensive element is the steel shaft, did you price
out a forging blank for the 3:1 setup?.
I have an idea for segmenting that shaft so that it could be
machined out of 4140 stock, but first we have to deal with the
bending loads. Milo
Contact a Lycomming overhaul shop and buy a cracked crank.
They generally crack is the journal fillets.
Cut at the first cheek and tig weld on a flange for the planet carrier.
All the Ross boxes were tig welded flanges for the planet carriers.
That is a low stress area of the crank for our application.
Not a low stress area for a piston engine.
Just 600 foot pounds of torque. No bending.
No prop gyro bending loads that affect the prop flange end.
Or you can do something like this bunch of screws bolt on flanges.
Paul Lamar
THANKS! Paul, that helps quite a bit.
Does anyone have an appropriate sized Lyc. shell bearing good for
230hp kicking around the shop that they can spare?
milo
Milo, As far as I remember Jean got a price of around $300 for a
piece of 4140 billet. He was going to rough out the machining to
some point on the CNC G-code, skip down to the next area and rough
out etc. then delete the code that went between. The idea is to
reduce the CNC machining time.
The bearings are larger diameter than Lycoming as shown on his
drawing. I recall 3.25 diameter and from a big block automotive
engine from Chrysler or GM. Several main bearing shells, one of
which was the thrust bearing. Oil drain back between the shell
locations and one of them isolated the constant speed prop oil which
could be at a pressure different than the engine oil pressure. I
remember Jean had some castings poured and you might get the guinni
pig discount on a pair of unmachined castings I have also designed a
PSRU but heavier than the one Jean has. Same diameter shaft but sperical
roller bearing at the prop flange and timken bearings at the rear of
the shaft and input shaft.There is also one journal bearing that
floats on the prop shaft which is restrained from rotation by the
feed tube that passes through to the outside of the housing. My
patterns are about 90% done and the bearings are in storage. These
patterns as with the engine patterns need a little detail sanding
and surface sealing. I use a borg warner 4407 planetary from the
transfer case of the F-350 truck with a ratio of 2.64:1 which has a
torque capacity three times as high as the F4OD planetary which is
2.85:1 I would not recommend my PSRU to anyone else. It is a one-
off for a turbocharged 4-rotor designed for HP capacity rather than minimum
weight.The roller bearings added 8 pounds of weight, required a
larger diameter casting for another 6 pounds, An integral bell
housing/oil tank which added length (and eliminated the prop shaft
spacer) and added considerable weight compared to Tracy's spacers.
The other planet set in that transmission is I believe 3.17 :1
but I would have to verify the ratio These ratios are all with the
ring gear fixed and drive through the planetary carrier. The
rotation is the same direction as the input shaft. When driving
from the ring gear there is less reduction and and the rotation
direction is opposite the input shaft.
Jean and I sketched up a prop flange attachment that allowed use of
a standard oil seal slid on the front of the prop shaft. The prop
flange with integral hub slid on the front of the shaft. Then there
is a .060 deep depression in the shaft with split locks similar to
what is used on automotive valve springs. The tapered bore flange
around the split locks has a bolt pattern matching the prop bolts
and mounts the hollow dowels for the prop.The prop bolts go through
both flanges with nuts behind the tapere bore flange.. Jean opted
for a large fillet radius on the prop flange and the stretch over
the thrust land oil seal. I went with the large radius one piece
shaft and the standard triple lip seal on the shaft followed by all
the bearings which get progressively smaller bore back to a fine thread
retaining nut.
The starting point is the diameter of the prop shaft at the prop
end sized for the gyroscopic loads. Then select bearings rated for
the speed the shaft turns. At these diameters speed rating drives
bearing selection more than load capacity.. Draw the shaft,
bearings, and planetary and fit the inside of the case around the
parts remembering that you need 2 degrees of draft on the rough
casting to get the pattern out of the sand. Draw the outside of the
casting around everything keeping the 2 degree draft in mind and
generally it is 2 degrees in the opposite direction. Since there
are usually gussets around the outside, thinning down the rough
casting on the inside while in the lathe boring the bearing seats
works to get rid of extra thickness needed to cast the parts.. Some
form of end cover to close off the gearbox and mount the input shaft
will be a second part. If you draw this shaft and it's bearings
along with the prop shaft it will aid in conflict between the two
housing parts..
Unless you require a constant speed prop or a different HP
rating I really don't see a reason to design and test a PSRU as long
as Tracy's box is available.
george grimes
George,
The sketch you showed me of Jeans shaft illustrated thrust rings in two
locations, I believe. If that is the case
what thrust shell bearing did he intend on using?
Does Lycoming use thrust shell bearing on their shafts? If that is
not the case how does Lycoming control the thrust? milo
BTW I want to point out one thing about lower cost hydraulic constant
speed metal
props.
Not only are they $4000 cheaper than the European composite wood
constant speed electric props they are considerably more efficient
as the tips are thinner. Tracy Saylor owner, of the fastest RV6 in
the world at 238 MPH (beefed up tail), tested a metal constant speed
compared to a European wood constant speed and the metal was ten MPH
faster.
Paul Lamar
milo, I haven't posted any sketches of Jeans designs. Possibly it
was posted from something Paul had. Jean was useing the #5 main
bearings from the automotive engine. I think the use of two had to
do with a redundant bearing with a much narrower journal in case the
primary bearing had a problem. The extra clearance allowed ckecking
the clearance of the thrust bearing during preflight and prevent
binding of the two thrust bearings due to thermal expansion. There
is also something to do with a slot across the thrust bearing face
to spread oil as it turns.
george
The thrust bearings have a couple of "scallops" in the thrust areas to allow
oil to get to the sides. These cut out areas do not continue all the way
through the thrust face as that would allow the thrust oil pressure to be
reduced limiting the effectiveness. The crankshaft oil pressure is controlled
be the bearing clearances. Larger clearance drops the pressure; everything
else equal. On the thrust bearings, the side clearance also controls the
pressure and leak-off. The oil flung off the crankshaft is what lubricates the
wrist pins, lifters and cam lobes, cylinder walls and rings. As the bearings
wear the rings get flooded with oil and can not control all of it causing oil
consumption to go up. New bearings for the crank may fix the consumption if
the rest is mechanically sound. Not enough oil coming off the crank will cause
scuffing problems and early failure.
If you hold your foot on the clutch pedal while driving takes out the free
play and loads the thrust bearing slightly. This reduces the oil film and the
thrust starts to warm up. It does not take much of this to causes premature
failure of the thrust bearing. Remember that automotive clutch application is
intended to be for short periods of time and intermittent. In the AC
application this load stays on the bearing possibly for hours. The area of the
bearing surface needs to be vastly increased or a roller/ball bearing used.
Dale Davies
Milo, Whenever we get onto PSRU design there seems to be suggestions about
copying the certified crankshaft designs of Lycoming or TCM which I am
attempting to attach a picture of. It appears to me that it is a plain
thrust bearing on the wider front crankshaft bearing saddle. As reguards
surface area. The automotive crankshafts on large V-8 engines are commonly
3.25" diameter while aircraft cranks are something like .500 less diameter.
Obviously journal and plain bearings in general are up to the job. If
useing automotive bearings there are four non thrust bearings in the set
which can be used side by side on a wide journal with one or two ported for
the constant speed prop.
The plain thrust bearing discussion always reminds me of people who say
they would never fly behind an auto conversion because of the unreliable
points and condensor ignition. Of course auto engines and lawnmowers have
had solid state ignition for thirty years while brand new aircraft engines
still have mags timed by points requiring both internal and external
timeing.Of course they also are comfortable with a bucket full of valves,
guides, springs, rocker arms and shafts, pushrods, tappets and a camshaft
without any form of hydraulic lash adjustment which automotive engines have
had for 60 years.
george grimes
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube key word PaulLamar2 Copyright 1998-2013
All world wide rights reserved.