Subject: Sorting the trees from the forest in megasquirt.
From: rotaryeng
Date: 3/30/2013, 6:29 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng

Paul, For those of us watching from the outside: What should we expect from
the Megasquirt project?  I'm comparing the ultimate result to a stone-simple
Holley carb setup in a twin-rotor p-port.

Holley carb:
  Cost:  About $500 in brand-new parts
  Reliability: Outstanding.  If the engine is drawing air, the fuel will
flow at the proper rate.  Some aircraft will be able to fly without any fuel
pump at all, other designs will require a simple low-pressure pump. Carb
ice can be a problem, avoid it with carb heat as we've been doing for
decades.
  Efficiency:  Good.  Install a leaning block and lean the engine out
manually.
  Maintainabilty:  Excellent.  The parts and function are well understood
and documented.  Help is as close as a well-informed auto mechanic.

Megasquirt: Cost:  Approx $300+ for the board, chips and software (ready to
assemble--get out the soldering iron and don't make any mistakes), another
$200 for the injectors, $100 for a high pressure fuel pump, additional cost
for fuel return lines not required in a carb setup.  Miscellaneous
additional costs for sensors, patch cords for tuning with a laptop, etc.
   Reliability:  ??.  Redundancy can be designed in.  Power spikes can
affect all systems under power, loss of electric power affects fuel pumps,
controllers.
   Efficiency:  Probably excellent.
   Maintainability:  ?? Maybe not so good if you're not the guy who designed
and assembled it.  Get out the laptop and VOM, try to hook it up right, and
start the quest. "What does 'Var6QP=98' mean?"

 I can see the attraction for electronics hobbyists/tinkerers or those who
want a high-fidelity engine monitoring system.  Will there be advantages for
those just wanting to achieve a reliable, simple, inexpensive Rotary
aviation installation?  Can we quantify how much additional power or fuel
efficiency is likely to result from use of the final Megasquirt system in
place of a carb?

Mark W.

Yes you are right on. Not much in terms of BSFC. However people still
perceive they need EFI.

I will have to research "Var6QP=98" :)

Paul Lamar

Paul: In a set up for the Holley 2 barrel carb  with the leaning block
installed.

How would you suggest to do the "Carb heat" installation? If you have any
simulations  drawings could you sent it to me.

Regards

Le Roux Breytenbach

There is plenty of heat to work with. Just put a metal 180 bend on the end
of the muffler cooling tube and take it forward about a foot. From there you
can use silicone hose to a ram air box for the carb.


Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
 ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
 You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
 Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.