Subject: : Diesel status in California
From: rotaryeng
Date: 5/3/2013, 9:10 PM
To: AAA-rotaryeng



They discovered a way to sell pig pee to the general population
and convince them they are happy accepting it. Just call it DEF
instead of pig piss that your new knockometer runs on.



Dale Davies

I think you guys are looking at diesels from the wrong angle- My
truck is a crew cab 4 door 2500 Dodge 4WD diesel. It weighs just
under 9K lbs with all my tools and stuff in the bed. It gets 24.2 MPG
at 65 mph. It has the cummins 5.9 diesel in it. In contrast, my Tahoe
weighs in around 4K, and with its 5.3 liter gas burner gets 16 mpg on
a good day. I can haul it cheaper than I can drive it. My truck has
almost 220K miles on it, and the computer shows 6K+ hours. And before
you guys say that automobiles use only a fraction of HP to run down
the road- consider this- my truck has been licensed for 34K lbs since
it was driven off the lot pulling everything from 24' enclosed
storage trailers to 19K lb trackhoes on a 35 foot gooseneck trailer.
With the directional boring machine or the trackhoe, she crossed the
scales at around 33,600 lbs.

Now before you crucify me, read on-----

There is a big difference between reducing emissions and increasing
efficiency. HUGE.

My construction company had lots of really large equipment- cranes,
trackhoes, etc. We had a Freightliner that was modified- it had a Big
Cam 350 Cummins bored and stroked to around 525 HP. With a gross
weight of 120,000 lbs hauling our crane, the truck pulled in an
impressive 7.4 mpg. No DEF, no catalytic converter, just a 6 inch
chrome pipe from the turbo to the top of the truck.

In contrast, I bought a new 2007 Sterling dump truck with a 425 HP
Cat, with compound turbos- not turbo compound, I am talking about 2
turbos one feeding the other. It had 2 catalytic converters and was
the epitome of clean burning. And it never got more than 3.5 mpg,
ever.

Now, I have to ask just how much cleaner can it be burning more than
twice the fuel?

Next question- when was the last time you saw a gasoline engine go
over a million miles? Even the low HP requirements of running down
the highway, gasoline engines never ever get that high of mileage. My
boat weighs 81,000 lbs and has a pair of 12V 71 Detroit diesels in
it. Each with over 8000 hours on them. My last gasoline engines, in
addition to a 4 times higher fuel burn- went out at 1100 hours. So
again, how bad can the emissions be if the diesels are burning 1/4
the fuel? The boat was a 13000 lb 27' Albemarle with twin 350 GM
engines rated at 270 HP. With these engines, she got .6 MPG at 20
knots. When I changed to the 3056 Cat engines rated at 305 HP, I
upped the props in size and pitch, and at 2100 rpm she would run 26
knots with a fuel burn of 2.5 MPG. No smoke, no soot, nada.

In my current boat, we have a 16KW generator- diesel. We dont have to
worry about dying in our sleep due to carbon monoxide poisoning.
Diesels dont make that. You never ever want to go to sleep in a boat
with a gasoline generator- if the wind changes you might not wake
up.

The next issue is energy density. Diesel fuel has appx 10% higher
energy density per gallon than gasoline. So, BSFC aside, an engine
will go 10% farther on a gallon of diesel than a gallon of gas. There
are reasons that airliners burn jet fuel- a slightly more refined
version of diesel- higher energy density, cooler burning temps,
slower controlled burn, etc. Cargo and other large ships burn what is
known as "bunker" because of its high energy density. This stuff
looks like tar and has to be heated to around 400 degrees F to get it
to go through the injectors. These engines are as big as warehouses,
make thousands of HP, and turn at 300 RPM. Note they don't burn gas.
And, LNG has a lower energy density than gasoline, making it even
less of an option to replace diesel.

My diesel truck makes more power on less fuel, with a lower exhaust
temp than the rotary, and lasts longer doing it- Instead of
condemning this, we can learn from it- I asked once before has anyone
tried a 20% blend of diesel in the gas just to see what the numbers
come out to be.

In my not so humble opinion, the answer to the rotary being the end
all/ be all would be to make one that has no throttle, is turbo and
runs on jet fuel. Lower BSFC, leaner running, and much cooler EGT,
the fuel itself is a lubricant which would make the apex seals very
happy. And JetA is usually cheaper at the airport. There is no
downside to it. I have heard that the gov't has jet fuel burning
rotaries in UAV's, so the technology is there we just need to look
into it. The downside to a real turbine is they eat too much. An
engine that makes power like a turbine, has the benefits of a
turbine, and burns half the fuel of a turbine would be a game
changer. I just dont think you can do that on gasoline.

If you spend much time at the airport you will see- real planes burn
jet fuel- Planes meant to get up and go and go and go, not just fly
for the $100.00 hamburger.

Kevin Alderman

You are not in California yet :)

Just wait! So goes California on these emissions matters so goes
the rest of the states  not far behind.

Paul Lamar



-- 
--
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.