Some of this boils down to the practical application. Yarns ago dump
trucks and farther back all trucks had gasoline engines. All heavy
trucks are powered by diesels due to engine life and economy
dictated the change. We use 3/4 or 1 ton trucks as required by the
contracts with the oil companies. Gasoline trucks must be no more
than 3 years old with diesels allowed 5 years. Most of the time we
have electrical or instrumentation tools and materials in the trucks,
so lightly loaded. The new emsisions diesels are not getting much
better economy than the gasoline trucks with all else equal. Add in
the fact that oil and filter changes are 2 to 3 times the cost. Now
if you are pulling a trailer on a regular basis as you are, a diesel
is the only way to go. It comes down to application and the correct
equipment for the job. Light duty is not likely the place for diesel
engines used in urban settings. Diesel engines converted to run on
natural gas in urban delivery and city buses where fuel can be
readily available and close will come into popularity in time due to
the clean burn. Fuel economy on NG is better than on converted gas
engines due to the compression ratio. NG can be used with 15:1 to
16:1 CR. As Paul stated, all diesels will be equipped eventually.
Dale Davies
Hi folks. I just joined this list, hoping to get some good
information about running rotary engines in aircraft. So far, I've
seen little of that, but I'm still hopeful.
Rotary engines - A long time ago I had a friend, Dan Duncan, who
built aircraft rotary engine conversions, and I came to believe that
they were great airplane engines. In the late 1980's, I designed a
pusher airplane that used a Mazda 13b as the core for an internal
combustion high-bypass fan, dumping heat into the bypass and
expanding the airflow. I never got far enough with the design to
build it. These days I'd like to put a rotary in my airplane and
maybe some day build that other airplane if I get around to it.
Carbon - Carbon is what I like to call the "crack whore" element of
the periodic table (see
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Periodic_table).
It will happily form a covalent or ionic bond with just about
anything, which is why you don't want it in your body in its raw form
- it likes to muck with your DNA. Mutated DNA leads to mutated
cells, some of which grow uncontrollably and lead to death by
cancer.
Diesel Ash - Breathing ash is bad for you. All research shows that
breathing ash is bad for you. Your lungs don't work if you put ash
in them, and if the carbon from the ash makes its way into the rest
of your body, the rest of your body won't work either.
Nature doesn't care what you believe about it.
Cheers, all. Dave Klingler
Did Duncan disappear to Mexico ? Do you know where he is?
Some up set people are still looking for him :)
Paul Lamar
For those who don't know who we're talking about, Dan Duncan was the
owner of Duncan Aviation, purveyors of rotary aircraft engines (not to
be confused with the Duncan Aviation that now crops up in Google). They
made a line of aircraft engines based on some Israeli drone engines on
the bottom end up through a turbocharged Mazda 12A. They did some NASA
SBIRs on rotary engines for aircraft, including some longevity studies.
They were comprised of Dan Duncan, his wife and a few employees, in
Oklahoma.
I'm going to recount what I recall as well as I can remember it.
Apologies if I make any mistakes.
In 1986, Dan heard about a tech company incentive program in New
Mexico. He and his wife inquired to find out whether their company
qualified. It did, so they shut down operations in Oklahoma and moved
to Santa Fe. Unfortunately, by the time they finished the move, a new
governor had taken office, one who had different ideas about incentive
programs. He shut down the program immediately. The tax breaks and
cheap loans dried up just as Dan and his wife finished moving, and they
found themselves in a tight spot. Dan's wife wrote all the customers
and told them there would be a delay in delivering their engines, and
then the two of them set to building engines as fast as they could.
Dan's wife got a side job at JC Penney to earn money for parts.
I had a friend back then who was a retired master machinist from the
nuclear weapons program, and I was helping him to build an amphibious
bushplane. He looked over Dan's little operation, met Dan and his wife,
liked what he saw, and purchased an engine.
At that point Dan had delivered around 70 engines and had a two-year
backlog of orders, including the one my friend purchased. One of the
customers was a doctor in Oklahoma who had ordered an engine just before
they moved. When he got the letter from Dan's wife, he wrote back,
demanding that Dan deliver his engine immediately. Dan wrote him a
reply, telling him that he was going as fast as he could but offering
him a refund on his deposit. The doctor did not reply but went to one
of his friends, who happened to be U.S. Attorney Bill Price of
Oklahoma. Price was readying a campaign for governor the following
year, 1989, and in some of his pre-campaign appearances he began
mentioning Dan, his brother and "ridding Oklahoma of the Duncans of this
world". Dan, unfortunately, didn't know about that.
The feds busted down Dan's door at about 6 one morning, charged him with
one count of mail fraud for each letter they found in his filing
cabinet, close to 400 counts, and extradited him back to Oklahoma. He
had hoped to be gone for a few days, long enough for the hearing and
bail, but he sat in New Mexico for a few weeks before the extradition
took place. When he got to Oklahoma, the guards beat him up and his
hernia started bleeding internally. That landed him in the prison
hospital, and he ended up being gone for several months. Toward the end
of that time one of his wife's coworkers convinced her to file for divorce.
When he finally got out on bail, he lived on baked potatoes in his
hangar, drove a truck for a local moving company, and delivered my
friend's engine. He gave me his dog to care for, and went back to trial
in Oklahoma. He was able to prove that he had delivered engines for all
but three of the letters the Feds had confiscated, the two letters to
the doctor and the reply. They found him guilty of three counts of mail
fraud, not what he had hoped for.
They then kept him in prison for what I remember was around 19 months.
He returned to Santa Fe, rented an apartment from my dad, and took odd
commercial hauling jobs. I watched him struggle pretty hard to pay off
debts and build engines for people when he was able. He lived on a sack
of baked potatoes and a block of cheese for many months before and after
he lost his business, and most of his earnings went into trying to hold
on to his Piper Pacer and buy engine parts. His health and morale
declined considerably during the time I knew him. He missed his ex-wife
terribly, and he spent considerable attention on trying to win her back.
The last time I saw Dan he was leaving town to drive for a Canadian
trucking company. I think he had followed his ex-wife back to Canada.
I think he delivered 79 engines in all, including one for the plane I
was helping to build; the doctor would have been his 80th, had he been
able. I never saw him again, and I've always wondered what happened to
him. I think by now he'd be about 70.
I know a very little bit of what he did to make his engines last. One
thing was that he had discovered that the stock Mazda water pump
cavitates at high RPMs, so he substituted a Ford Escort water pump and
that took care of it. He also dynamically balanced all of his engines.
The engines he tested for NASA hit his target of 3000 hours under load
at 9000 RPMs, not too shabby.
Paul, if you know of some information about Dan Duncan I'd like very
much to hear what you know.
Dave
Its been so long I forgot all the bad things. I do recall he made too
many modifications to the engine.
Now a days we use the engine as is more or less. Except for P-ports.
BTW that is a myth on the water pump cavitation. We don't run the engine
over 7500. It might cavatate
at 11,000 RPM.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.