Subject: turbocompounding a 20B with a DD15 power turbine-interested too
From: rotaryeng
Date: 5/6/2013, 7:04 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng


Paul,

Did you ever run the turbo compound Mazda with the gearbox shown
in the pictures? If you did, were the results published? Looks
like a neat project but it probably consumed lots of time and
money.

Gary Knutson

Not yet. The box cost a bunch. I spent so much money on that I had
none left over for dyno time :) It is actually cheaper to use a
turbo compound system from a mass produced truck engine. Detroit
Diesel DD15. Almost bolt on with a three rotor. You would no happen
to have access to a dyno would you.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

Do you have a plan for dyno testing a turbo compound setup? Are
all the parts and a suitable test engine available? How about a
exhaust system, etc.

I do have access to a well instrumented and equipped test cell but
my "run time" is somewhat limited. A test would have to be laid
out and documented and as much of the hookup stuff done ahead of
time as possible. The facility is local (to me).

Let me know what you might have in mind. It would be an
interesting test!

Gary Knutson

I have a simple plan. Run 500 RPM increments for one minute each
with
out the TC and measure and record the fuel flow and HP. Then
repeat with the TC.

I have a stock 3 rotor but it is not complete and running. It has
the
stock turbo's. It needs a Motec installed. We can get help on that
because Jim Medere of Racing Beat has done it several times.

I don't currently have a Motec. He sells them I think.

We can buy the DD15 TC system new for about $4000. I can rig a cog
belt drive from the DD15 gear box out put to the 3 rotor out put
shaft if I have dwg of the dyno bell housing bolt pattern. I would
entail cutting slots in a stock Mazda bell housing for the belt to
pass through. The belt HP would be in the range of 30 HP plus or
minus 20. The DD15 GB puts out 1800 RPM or so max when the turbine
is going 40,000 RPM. That means would would have to step it up 1 to
3 or so.

I can fly up there and spend the time hooking things up.
I think the data output from the Motec would be all we need.
We would have to monitor engine temperature of course and RPM but
even
that the Motec would know.

I would probably be cheaper for me to deliver the engine than
crating
and shipping. Which would run about $1000 as I just had a 400 pound
engine shipped from Or and that is what it cost.

1500 miles at 20 MPG and $4 a gallon is $300 each way.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

Am I missing something here? I thought you were located at the
Santa
Paula Airport near Ventura. I'm in Laguna Niguel and the dyno is in
Huntington Beach. If I'm correct on your location, things aren't
all that far apart.

This dyno, unlike a Superflow or similar, mounts the engine on
adjustable
stands. It uses a CV coupling that bolts to a flywheel or adapter
plate
on the flywheel end of the output shaft. A short drive shaft
couples the engine to the absorption unit. No bell housing is
involved. The dyno had a built in starter.

As the output end is exposed, it should be possible to install a
driven
pulley from the TC unit.

Any required engine mounting plates and the coupling adapter should
be made ahead of time. I can supply pictures and dimensions for the
parts.

I can look around and see if I can find a "loaner" Motec. I can't
promise
anything there.

From your description, it sounds like you would run with a
turbocharged
engine, is that correct?

The cost of the TC system is a pretty big hit for a test. I suppose
that it could be reused if all went as planned. The belt drive
won't be that bad. I assume that the TC unit could be mounted on
the engine.

Anyway, lots to think about. I hope I cleared up some of the
"travel" concerns.

Gary Knutson

I was missing something :) That's great. I thought for some reason
you were in the Detrot area. Come on up to SZP and see my
collection. Email me before you come so I can get out to the hangar.

That $4000 includes the DD15 turbo. If we use the sequential turbos
on the 3 rotor we won't need the DD15 turbo. In theory we wont get
as much HP out of the blow down turbine due to a bit of energy loss
in the second 3 rotor turbo. I would be ecstatic with just a 5%
improvement in the BSFC. That would drop the rotary BSFC from .47 to
.446 more than demonstrating the potential.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

I may take you up on that offer. I "escaped" from Livonia at the
end of 1987. :-)

Which way would make the most sense - Mazda turbos and the DD15
without the
turbo or the other way around? The DD15 looks like a nice package.
Would there be drawbacks to using it complete?

As I mentioned, this could be a interesting & helpful project. Who
knows, it
might even be a bit of a money maker. I will look forward to
hearing more of your thoughts on things.

Gary Knutson
--
As a 20B owner and a bit of a rotary fanatic, I too would like to
see this as a working item, along with that Lycoming cs psru ---
-together they would make nice long distance cruise packages for a
kit airframe meant for traveling.....? More pics and stats if you
guys really do this (and parts), please!!! Marc W

Maybe you could use some tax payers money Paul, at least they will
get a return via something that "actually works" ha ha ha. would be
a first !! You might be able to get a TC unit on loan, DD might
be pursuaded if you promise to get some data for them and return
the unit afterwards. I reckon if you can give them some figures
they can redesign a turbine and turbo for minimal extra cost that
would suit our purposes better, 20B 13B etc. Maybe let DD deal with
govt funding if you are prepared to work with them. Could work
yes?!?! Just a thought BTW Motec supply the ecu 's for V8
supercars, as per the torque meter.

Graeme Riley


I would be highly surprised if Detroit Diesel would co-operate with an AC
application of their technology, and using R&D time for this application
would definitely be off the map.

The cast iron construction is a drawback. Maybe TiAluminide could be used for
the turbo housings.



Dale Davies

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.