Subject: Ducted fans and coatings
From: rotaryeng
Date: 5/14/2013, 4:22 PM
To: AAA-rotaryeng



Hi!: are this data from the 1982 booklet by D.W. Hovey on  'Ducted
fans for light aircraft' still of value?The rest is the  Canada
patents by Alfred P Grazen on the coating used for the Suzuki  RE-5
stator. Thanks, regards, salut + Jose Gros-Aymerich Madrid,  Spain

Ducted fans were discredited in WW II by German scientist. The  duct
has drag which negates the alleged advantage. Over about 100 MPH. At
400 MPH and up to 600 MPH they are an advantage for high bypass
turbo  jets.

Paul Lamar


Jose,

There isn't any reason that  Hovey's work wouldn't still be of value.

Apologies if you already know  the following:

In general ducted fans are of limited use for small  aircraft because
it's difficult to either make the fan large enough to be  efficient or
the aircraft light enough to use a small fan. Energy and  momentum
rear their pretty little heads.

That doesn't mean they  aren't viable. There are more ducted fan
aircraft flying today than any  other type. Turbofans are far more
efficient than turbojets, and virtually  all non-supersonic jet engine
aircraft are high-bypass turbofans. For small  aircraft, however, an
Otto cycle engine achieves far better specific fuel  consumption than
a Brayton cycle engine (a turbine).

Dave  Klingler



You must specify speed range. Large fans have large  ducts. Large
ducts have lots of drag. Note this hover craft operating in 60  MPH
speed ranges has no ducts. It was better to just use a  large
diameter prop. I got to ride one across the English channel. Now done
away with.


Perry Mick tried for years. Finally took it off,  put a gear box on
and a larger diameter prop and went 20 or 30 MPH faster  on the same
fuel burn.

Paul Lamar

Hello all, you may have  seen this before but it still makes a
good read.
The really interesting  part of this article is the way he
logically debunks
a lot of theory  previously held as fact. So while I believe there
is room
for  improvement in ducted fans and prop design in general, I sure
don't
have this mans ability or experience and so I am destined to
follow not
lead. I'd rather spent my time flying then trying to get
something new of
the ground.
Graeme  Riley

http://www.eaa.org/experimenter/articles/2009-02_elippse.asp


We  have an old saying in car racing. "When the flag drops the BS
stops."
There are many design factors that make a race winner. Not the
least of
which is the pilot. For those of you that have never been to a  F1
air race
there dozens of competitors. There is nothing stopping  someone from
copying anything. Truly good ideas rapidly get impelented on  all
the racers.
I don't see that happening with Paul Lipp's propeller.  The
question is why?

The late Paul Lipps was a smart man. I have  met him several times.

IMHO he was going fast because of a reduction in  cooling drag.
Not the prop.
The prop  was tried years ago in  antiquity.

Paul Lamar


I want to see winglets on the ends of Paul's rotating wing propeller.
Peter Duffecy


You think that is not possible?  Is this an attempt at sarcasm? :)

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by  Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube  http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights  reserved.