Subject: Porting Air Cooled Wankels SAE Paper list
From: rotaryeng
Date: 5/18/2013, 3:50 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng





Anybody know where I can find info on the best way to port them? It
   seems that some are ported in such a way that the air flows through
   the spinning rotor(s), "cooling" them and is recycled in a way
 as to
   warm the intake air for better fuel burn...? Is PP the best way
 to go
   always? It almost seems to me that it may be best to keep the stock
   porting (maybe smooth everything out) AND PP them while also
   blocking/rerouting the heated air from "recycling" for better hp.
   Thoughts? Links to air cooled wankel porting? Thanks! Dan G.

   It depends on how the rotor is cooled and what kind of rotor
 bearings
   are used. If there is an oil cooling system and the rotor bearings
   are the plain bearing type, p-porting is best for maximum power.
   Unfortunately there are no such Wankel engines in production.

   Paul Lamar

 Hi!: the subject seems not being much addressed today, but there are    some
SAE papers specific on air cooled Wankel RCEs: Small Wankel Engines -Helmut
Keller, Fichtel and Sachs, SAE paper 680572 The Rotary Engines of Yanmar
Outboard Motor -Kojiro Yamaoka and Hiroshi Tado, SAE paper 710581

Outboard
Marine Corp.s Production Rotary Combustion Snowmobile Engine Harry M.  Ward
et al, SAE paper 730119 Improvements of the Rotary Engine with a Charge
Cooled Rotor -K Yamaoka and H Tado, SAE paper 720466 Analysis of Light-Load
Performance in Rotary Engines, Toshiyuki Kohno et al, from Toyota, SAE paper
790435

A Review of Curtiss-Wright Rotary Engine Developments with Respect to
General Aviation Potential, Charles Jones, SAE paper 790621 Syvaros SP-440,
Air Cooled, Rotary-Trochoidal Engine, Andrei Adam, SAE paper 800974


Dvelopment of the Norton Rotary Motorcycle Engine, D.  W.  Garside, SAE
paper 821068 A Comprehensive Study of Wankel Engine Performance R. Sierens
et al, SAE paper 830332 The Effect of Alcohol Blends on the Performance of
an Air Cooled Rotary Trochoidal Engine, Marcel Gutman and Izu Luster, SAE
paper 840237 The Introduction of a New Ultra-Lite Multipurpose Wankel
Engine, Dankwart Eiermann et al, SAE paper 900035 Rotary Engine Powered
Ducted Fan for Aircraft Applications, Mike Griffith and Paul Moller, SAE
paper 900037

On the Wankel Engine with high Pressure Recirculation of
Unburned Gases Marcos Langeani, SAE paper 921444 (Close to the Yamaha and
Kawasaki patents?) A Two-Dimensional Computer Simulation of Exhaust Gas
Behavior Inside a Rotary Engine System, Yuji Hamai and Eisuke Outa, SAE
paper 930681

The Characteristics of Fuel Consumption and Exhaust Emissions
of the Side Exhaust Port Rotary Engine Ritsuharu Shimizu et al, Mazda, SAE
paper 950454 Wankel Engine for Hybrid Powertrain Angelo Butti and Vincenzo
Delle Site, SAE paper 951769 Developed Technologies of the New Rotary Engine
(RENESIS) Masaki Ohbuko et al, Mazda, SAE paper 2004-01-1790

Numerical
Analysis of Combustion and Flow Inside a Small Rotary Engine for Developing
an Unmanned Helicopter, Takafumi Yamada, Yasuo Moriyoshi, SAE paper
2   Papers marked  are not solely devoted to air cooling, or even are not
about this.

The general issues of Peripheral Porting vs Side Porting are
addressed in the two editions of the book Rotary Engine, by Kenichi
Yamamoto, Mazda, 1969 and 1981, both contain very different subjects, and
even when its copyrighted material, it can be found and downloaded from the
web.

 As you know, SAE papers can be bought and downloaded from www.sae.org
, usual prices are around $24 per paper, and if you become a member a
reduction in prices applies, probably theres much more info than this, but
my envy in spending money just for curiosity is limited, however, some spend
much more with drug dealers, tobacco and alcohol, and the diseases that come
after.  If this is of help to you, and you arrive to build or modify a
working engine, please let us know.

007-32-0098




   Regards, salut +
   Jose Gros-Aymerich
  Madrid, Spain


 Running hot air into the intake will not increase horse power no matter
 where you got the heat from.  That is why an intercooler is used on
 turbocharged engines.  A cooler denser air fuel charge will always produce
 more power than a hotter thinner air fuel charge.  Not that it matters much
 with a rotary, but a cooler charge also has less tendency to preignition.

 Air cooling of the rotor has been tried before.  Air has a much lower
 specific heat than oil so it takes a whole lot more air to cool the rotor.
 Pumping all that air sucks up a whole bunch of horse power.  Also, because
 the air is so much less efficient at cooling the output of the engine must
 be constrained to avoid overheating.

 The rotor bearings must be lubricated.  Blowing the required large
 quantities of air through the rotor carries away large amounts of the oil
 used to lubricate the bearings.  The result of that is either loss of large
 amounts of oil, or carrying a large heavy oil separator along. While I will agree that the weight of the blower and separator are most
 likely less than the weight of the liquid cooling system, I'm quite certain
 that the additional horse power made possible by the increased efficiency
 of the liquid cooling system will far outperform the lighter air cooled
 system in climb performance.

 There's no point in P porting an air cooled Wankle because it already
 produces as much horse power as the cooling system can absorb.

 The only purpose for P porting a rotary is to increase the horse power of
 the engine by increasing the volumetric efficiency of the engine. More
 horse power is produced by burning more air/fuel in the same time span
 resulting in more heat that needs to be dissipated into the cooling system.
 The cooling system is the limiting factor in an air cooled engine.




 -  Mark LaPierre


More on air cooled Wankel Rotary engines: The SAE paper 830332 deals with all the possibilities existing:charge cooled rotor, air cooled housing, liquid cooling housing with charge cooled rotor, and so on, explaining the maximal efficiency that can be expected from each basic design, and proposing their own approach as cheap to build and efficient.


The first Norton two rotor engine had open air air cooled housing and charge cooled rotor; to increase volumetric efficiency, a 'Plenum chamber' under the pilot's seat was added, acting as anintercooler; the designs that came after preserved the charge cooled rotor, but added liquid cooling for the housing. Norton stated that liquid cooling made  engines less sensible to 'operator's variations in handling the engine', a period of warm up of some minutes was advised for the totally air cooled engines, as Mazda does today in  their car engines, that they say not to race or extract the maximum  power until the whole engine is adequately warmed, as in any internal combustion engine.


The Austro single rotor, liquid cooled housing engine used charge cooling for rotor, but in the aim of improving the volumetric efficiency, they suppressed it in favor of a fan that blows air inside the rotor, this Rotor still has the same basic design and dimensions of the Norton and MidWest Aero engines series of engines; as Mark LaPierre says, this swallows some 5 kw in an engine giving 80-90 kw, it's up to the user deciding if the result pays, but there's little addtional choice.



It seems severa persons tried adding a Peripheral Port directly connected to the carb in some Sachs engines, total power output was increased, butI don't know more, the Sachs engine with the Norton high compression ratio LDR recess rotor emits exhaust gases at lower temperature than thelower Compression Ratio, this was observed in the early ICEs, thatdidn't admit high compression ratios because of the poor quality of gasoline and the then unknown cause of the phenomenon of detonation, that was adequately addressed and solved by Harry Ricardo, the high temperatureof the exhaust gases in this early engines was one of the reasons thatmade mandatory the substitution or grinding of exhaust poppet valves aftersome thousands of hours of use, be it in car or aircraft engines.


Does the higher temperature of exhaust gases in Wankel engines have a connection to the actual or effective compression ratio being lower thanin reciprocating engines?
If volumetric efficiency, specially at low rpm / partial load is not too high,a real compression ratio lower than the geometrically calculated compression ratio may result, and this making that under partial load or in the low rpm range, exhaust gas temperatures are higher than at full open throttle and high rpm, the subject is addressed in an article published in Wankel
Newsby Reiner Nikulski, entitled 'Gluhendes rohr' = 'Glowing tube', that deals with the possibility of adding a catalyzer to the Sachs engine of the DKW Hercules W -2000 motorcycle, I have a translation of it that I attach, but sorry, translation is into spanish, perhaps Google translate can be of help.


  Does Mr La Pierre have a connection to the writers Dominique LaPierre and Larry Collins, who wrote some very popular books inthe 70's and 80's?
I received as gift a signed copy of one of their books, because I met in Madrid one of his relatives, having Moro as surname.
Enjoy the weekend, best regars, salut +
    Jose Gros-Aymerich    E-28033 Madrid, Spain


 The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
   ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
   You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
   Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.