Subject: Porting Air Cooled Wankels SAE Paper list
From: rotaryeng
Date: 5/18/2013, 4:00 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng




Anybody know where I can find info on the best way to port them? It
seems that some are ported in such a way that the air flows through
the spinning rotor(s), "cooling" them and is recycled in a way as to
warm the intake air for better fuel burn...? Is PP the best way to
go always? It almost seems to me that it may be best to keep the
stock porting (maybe smooth everything out) AND PP them while also
blocking/rerouting the heated air from "recycling" for better hp.
Thoughts? Links to air cooled wankel porting? Thanks! Dan G.

It depends on how the rotor is cooled and what kind of rotor
bearings are used. If there is an oil cooling system and the rotor
bearings are the plain bearing type, p-porting is best for maximum
power. Unfortunately there are no such Wankel engines in production.

Paul Lamar


Hi!: the subject seems not being much addressed today, but there are
some SAE papers specific on air cooled Wankel RCEs:

Small Wankel Engines -Helmut Keller, Fichtel and Sachs, SAE paper
680572 The Rotary Engines of Yanmar Outboard Motor -Kojiro Yamaoka
and Hiroshi Tado, SAE paper 710581 Outboard Marine Corp.s Production
Rotary Combustion Snowmobile Engine Harry M. Ward et al, SAE paper
730119 Improvements of the Rotary Engine with a Charge Cooled Rotor
-K Yamaoka and H Tado, SAE paper 720466 Analysis of Light-Load
Performance in Rotary Engines, Toshiyuki Kohno et al, from Toyota,
SAE paper 790435 A Review of Curtiss-Wright Rotary Engine
Developments with Respect to General Aviation Potential, Charles
Jones, SAE paper 790621 Syvaros SP-440, Air Cooled, Rotary-Trochoidal
Engine, Andrei Adam, SAE paper 800974 Dvelopment of the Norton Rotary
Motorcycle Engine, D. W. Garside, SAE paper 821068 A Comprehensive
Study of Wankel Engine Performance R. Sierens et al, SAE paper
830332 The Effect of Alcohol Blends on the Performance of an Air
Cooled Rotary Trochoidal Engine, Marcel Gutman and Izu Luster, SAE
paper 840237 The Introduction of a New Ultra-Lite Multipurpose Wankel
Engine, Dankwart Eiermann et al, SAE paper 900035 Rotary Engine
Powered Ducted Fan for Aircraft Applications, Mike Griffith and Paul
Moller, SAE paper 900037 On the Wankel Engine with high Pressure
Recirculation of Unburned Gases Marcos Langeani, SAE paper 921444
(Close to the Yamaha and Kawasaki patents?) A Two-Dimensional
Computer Simulation of Exhaust Gas Behavior Inside a Rotary Engine
System, Yuji Hamai and Eisuke Outa, SAE paper 930681 The
Characteristics of Fuel Consumption and Exhaust Emissions of the Side
Exhaust Port Rotary Engine Ritsuharu Shimizu et al, Mazda, SAE paper
950454 Wankel Engine for Hybrid Powertrain Angelo Butti and Vincenzo
Delle Site, SAE paper 951769 Developed Technologies of the New Rotary
Engine (RENESIS) Masaki Ohbuko et al, Mazda, SAE paper 2004-01-1790
Numerical Analysis of Combustion and Flow Inside a Small Rotary
Engine for Developing an Unmanned Helicopter, Takafumi Yamada, Yasuo
Moriyoshi, SAE paper 2007-32-0098

Papers marked are not solely devoted to air cooling, or even are
not about this.

The general issues of Peripheral Porting vs Side Porting are
addressed in the two editions of the book Rotary Engine, by Kenichi
Yamamoto, Mazda, 1969 and 1981, both contain very different subjects,
and even when its copyrighted material, it can be found and
downloaded from the web.

As you know, SAE papers can be bought and downloaded from www.sae.org
, usual prices are around $24 per paper, and if you become a member a
reduction in prices applies, probably theres much more info than
this, but my envy in spending money just for curiosity is limited,
however, some spend much more with drug dealers, tobacco and alcohol,
and the diseases that come after.

If this is of help to you, and you arrive to build or modify a
working engine, please let us know.

Regards, salut +

Jose Gros-Aymerich Madrid, Spain



Running hot air into the intake will not increase horse power no
matter where you got the heat from. That is why an intercooler is
used on turbocharged engines. A cooler denser air fuel charge will
always produce more power than a hotter thinner air fuel charge. Not
that it matters much with a rotary, but a cooler charge also has less
tendency to preignition.

Air cooling of the rotor has been tried before. Air has a much
lower specific heat than oil so it takes a whole lot more air to cool
the rotor. Pumping all that air sucks up a whole bunch of horse
power. Also, because the air is so much less efficient at cooling the
output of the engine must be constrained to avoid overheating.

The rotor bearings must be lubricated. Blowing the required large
quantities of air through the rotor carries away large amounts of
the oil used to lubricate the bearings. The result of that is either
loss of large amounts of oil, or carrying a large heavy oil separator
along. While I will agree that the weight of the blower and separator
are most likely less than the weight of the liquid cooling system,
I'm quite certain that the additional horse power made possible by
the increased efficiency of the liquid cooling system will far
outperform the lighter air cooled system in climb performance.

There's no point in P porting an air cooled Wankle because it
already produces as much horse power as the cooling system can
absorb. The only purpose for P porting a rotary is to increase the
horse power of the engine by increasing the volumetric efficiency of
the engine. More horse power is produced by burning more air/fuel in
the same time span resulting in more heat that needs to be dissipated
into the cooling system. The cooling system is the limiting factor
in an air cooled engine.


- Mark LaPierre

Dan, The rotaries that send the mixture thru the rotors before combustion
are referred to as charge cooled.  The fuel air charge travels through holes
in the eccentric part of the rotor journal  passing from one side plate to the
other, then around to the port into the intake area of the engine. The fuel
vaporizes as it passes through the engine where the latent heat of vaporization
cools the rotor and shaft.There is no recirculating lubrication to the
stationary gear or rotor bearings and they are lubricated by oil mixed into
the fuel similar to a two stroke.  Changing from side port to P-port could
potentially do something for the entry into the intake port but the
big restrictions the tortuous path the mixture flows through getting through
the inner core of the engine.  An inter cooler would add even more
restriction.If the charge was supercharged there would still be the
limitation of heat rejection from vaporizing the fuel but the HP needed
to drive the supercharger would tax the heat rejection even further
resulting in a net loss of continuous power output.  One company that
tried to get a charge cooled rotary built was ROTAMAX.  They obtained
the rights to the OMC (evenrude) snowmobile and outboard motor rotary.

They
ignored Paul Lamar's suggestion that silicon nitride roller bearings would be
the solution to their bearing failures and the crash of their test airframe, a
Sadler Vampire, into a rock quarry and the resulting fire that destroyed the
aircraft ended their 5 year attempt attempt.  Google Rotamax to learn about
their engine.  There were some air cooled rotaries built with external
cooling ins and a fan like a lawn mower but power output was low and asfar
as I know they are no longer in production.

george.grimes