Vespa Piaggio motor scooter stator and rotor has the potential
for a low cost capacitor discharge ignition system.
Milo has done some work on this already using much more expensive
outboard motor parts. Vespa's are made in the millions and the cost
of manufacture is much lower. The parts are pretty much the same as
the outboard parts but smaller.
The secret to this approach is the stator has a high voltage coil that
charges the ignition capacitor. This is a much cheaper and more reliable
way of providing 400 volts for the CD ignition.
Here is a new one on ebay for $105 plus $24 for shipping. Made in Israel.
Complete stator and rotating drum with magnets.
The higher RPM rotary will generate higher capacitor charging current.
This is a very low cost CD ignition system that will also provide a
low current back up
alternator in case the main electrical system fails.
It is conceivable this will fit in my proposed new Ross copy gear box.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
This variant of CDI was used by Kawasaki for years on their 2 stroke
engines. They called it magneto CDI. While the Vespa version was made in
large quantities I would be very cautious about using it unmodified in
an aircraft. The ignition uses a low and high speed coil to charge the
capacitor. The problem with them in high rpm use is that the magnets
overpower the low speed coil above about 2000 rpm. I believe it is
refered to as reluctance. The high speed coil takes over above 2k, but
the low speed coil is still in the circuit, just ineffective. A frequent
failure was the low speed coil would fail with an open circuit. The
engine would be fine until you dropped the rpm below 2k. The engine
would then stall and can't be started unless you can get the rpm over
2k. This failure happened most often when the engine was used a lot at
high revs putting the most strain on the low speed coil. In a plane this
would happen as you were in approach and the engine would die. I
wouldn't mention this if I had not seen it often. We stocked the coils
in bike shops. If your Vespa dies at low rpm it isn't a big deal, but an
engine failure when you need to go around is. The outboard CDI is
designed for constant high rpm. I would suggest staying with it.
Bill Jepson
You have a schematic of that? In theory all you need is one HT coil
like the outboards.
I'll set it up in the lathe and run it at high RPM to see what is does.
The Vespa idles at 1800 RPM :)
I have the Haynes Service and Repair Manual 1991 to 2003 and no mention
of a low speed coil.
The neat thing about the Vespa flywheel is it is made from sheet metal
with no ring gear. Cheap and light weight. Small enough to fit in the
confines
of the gear box.
Paul Lamar
I can probably find a schematic. The Kawasaki ignition was in the
500 and 750 triples. The '73 H1 and the '72-'75 H2. (750) The Vespa has
had the advantage of 30 years of additional development. The other
possibility is that the Vespa limits the maximum rpm. I don't know.
Since the outboards are used at 60% to 100% all the time like aircraft I
was attracted to them years ago. I even contacted Orbital, the company
who did the EMS for Mercury at the time. The coils on the Kawasakis were
in parallel the magnet rotor was small in diameter. Less than 4"
overall. This may have been the limiting factor requiring a low speed
coil. The ignition was advanced for the time. It used a separate
magnetic rotor using hall effect sensors to trigger the ignition and
cause the ignition can to advance. If the Vespa or Outboard system uses
a larger diameter rotor it may generate enough energy to work with a
single coil.
Bill Jepson
The Kawasaki flywheel was hydroformed steel. They kick started so
no need for a ring gear. They mounted on the end of the crank on a
taper. Outside diameter was about 6 inches, and this unit had the
alternator built in also.
Bill
Bike stuff is too pricey. Scooters are in the trillions all over the world.
Two of these $10 high tension coils, a $60 rotor or flywheel, carb and
your 2 rotor
will run without an electrical system. Just like an aircraft engine.
The flywheel and coils replace a high buck, 400 volt switching power supply.
You still need a few parts that come to less than $10.
This replaces 2 MSD CDI 6A systems that are a minimum of $150 each and that
require an electrical system to work.
Paul Lamar