Subject: Adoption of the rotary turbo compound
From: rotaryeng
Date: 11/20/2013, 9:18 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng


Paul,

FYI from GreenCarCongress: http://www.greencarcongress.com/2013/11/20131118-mkc.html

From the article: "Advanced boosting systems with active and compounding components;"

My question is how do they define "compound?", more below

"Ford is currently slightly past the midpoint in a 4-year, $30-million project ($15 million from the US DOE) with Michigan Technological University (MTU) to demonstrate a 25% fuel economy improvement in a mid-sized sedan using a downsized, advanced gasoline turbocharged direct injection (GTDI) engine with no or limited degradation in vehicle level metrics, while meeting Tier 2 Bin 2 emissions on FTP-75 cycle"

my best,
Anthony

The US DOE has no business financing ("investing in" Obama speak :)) product innovation.
That is communism PERIOD :) Solyndra ect..

When the market is ready for it it will be developed by private money.
Not my tax money God dammit :) Venture capitalist make money when
they know something about what they are investing in. Politicians
only know how to get elected.

I am getting close to testing this 3 rotor TC engine on a engine dyno.
I have about $20,000 in the project so far.

Paul

Paul,

Yes I agree about the $, Ford  has it now to do it internally IMHO,
but in  a way they have to kiss DOE's ass etc as somebodies brother in
law is working their, you know the drill....

I have an email out to my gnome on this subject, although I doubt he
will spill the beans if they are going TC. However, he is impressed by
what you are doing with the TC as I forward the emails with pictures
to him. We had a very interesting conversation about 4 or 5 years ago,
a pre-cursor to Eco-Boost when they were about to go production and
were tinkering with DI of Ethanol with a firm from MIT. We distilled
down what Ford might be doing and that is with Mulally's aerospace
background they were going back to Pre-Jet-engine Zenith of Fighter
Piston Engine Technologies, i.e. DI, Supercharging etc and
incorporating them into test and ultimately production engines with
today's electronics. The one technology they haven't tried yet is
Turbo-Compounding. IMHO with Mulally still @ the helm for a year or
two, my gut feel is he just might dip his toe into this water if you
will...

My best,
Anthony



It is going to take a well educated car company CEO in engine  tech and
vision  to implement TC, Detroit Diesel (AKA  Daimler) has such a CEO  and they are highly
successful.  They are selling engines like hot cakes. I have a friend that works for
one of their dealers. The 15% reduction in fuel burn is an extraordinary
reduction  in the cost of operations for truckers.

What is really sad is the CEO of Mazda is no longer that kind of
person. Kenichi Yamamoto retired. The TC rotary, due to the lack of
exhaust valves, is potentially the most efficient internal combustion engine
in the world. CW in the 1950's discovered the exhaust valve was dissipating half the
potential energy in the  IC exhaust.

Paul Lamar

Hi Paul,

Getting someone to pick up on a TC Rotary will be quite difficult IMHO. Most
businesses are so short-sighted nowadays, not many want to take a risk, it's
still shareholder value and thinking in quarters (and less) though we should
be beyond that. I don't see much curiosity either. If you talk to automotive
OEMs about rotaries they all get scared, because they have no idea how the
engines really work. They just know the state of the art that was achieved
30 years ago and the typical rumours (fuel burn, sealing issues, emission
issues, etc.). There is massive potential, you and I and a few others know
that. But getting an OEM to work on a TC rotary will be tough.

Still if there is proof that the efficiency is as good as we all hope, there
may be potential. One way is going through the media, the other is to find
the right contacts. I prefer to go for the latter first, because if the OEMs
do something they want to look as if they have at least been part of the
idea themselves. I have the address of a guy who is in Ford Europe's board,
basically responsible for all engineering within Ford Europe. So if you have
some data to build on, I can forward this.

Best Regards,

Poul Henrik Woelfle

Woelfle Engineering GmbH
Randstraße 109 • D - 47804 Krefeld • Germany
Tel +49 2151 151020 • Fax +49 2151 151019
www.woelfle-engineering.com
HRB 7369, Amtsgericht Krefeld • Director / Geschäftsführer: Paul A. Woelfle


I put a note in the Ford idea page (a repository for all employees to post innovative concepts) about the rotary turbo-compound quite a few years back. It was favorably commented on. However, as I was working in the R&E center at the time, I did not see any rotary activity in my building. The super secret stuff was done across the street, where all the PHDs were kept.
That said, if you can get the TC working, have test data and a working prototype, I'm sure the interest would suddenly blossom. I still have contacts there at R&E. A working prototype and actual test data showing the improved BSFC should be enough to kickstart a project. The final kicker though is emission standards, and I believe that is the current stumbling block for investment in the rotary. There is still some misunderstanding by engineers of the rotary itself, but 15% gains in BSFC in one fell swoop can be quite an eye opener. Hell, I'll send an e-mail right to Mark Fields and Allen Mulalley, as well as any other names I can dig up in the top technology movers.
Unfortunately the EPA regulators hold the trump cards in automobile manufacturing, that's just the reality of the situation.
C. Smith


Hi Paul,

I'm following the newsletter closely when there's info on TC. If you told an
OEM that it took you $ 20000 they would be puzzled... ;-)

Best Regards,

Poul Henrik Woelfle

Woelfle Engineering GmbH
Randstraße 109 • D - 47804 Krefeld • Germany
Tel +49 2151 151020 • Fax +49 2151 151019
www.woelfle-engineering.com
HRB 7369, Amtsgericht Krefeld • Director / Geschäftsführer: Paul A. Woelfle


The secret was to use a TC system from the DD15 that was in low cost mass production.
It was pure luck that it happened to be a close match to the 3 rotor.
I was also lucky enough to buy the used 3 rotor at a cheap price.
That $20,000 does not include my wages:) I have hundreds of hours in the
construction already.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net.
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas.
Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.