Subject: Tracy gear box New hollow shaft version
From: rotaryeng
Date: 1/22/2014, 3:55 PM
To: AAA-rotaryeng





Hi Paul, Do you have any more info on Tracy's box, like the shaft and internals, I can't figure out where the thrust goes etc. The box is very chunky, I would say overkill somewhat. Also I can't see any oil supply, in or out. You wouldn't have to saw off the flange, I would do my box and then remove it from the pattern before casting others.
From the side view it lookslike the prop shaft is one piece, is this right ? Also, is the box intended to be bolted up to a plate or a bell housing. Chris.


Tracy used a cut down GM pick up truck rear axle and ball  bearing.
The bearing was retained by a pressed on collar with  several tons of force. Tracy fed the box with oil from the engine. So too the Ross but the Ross had all needle bearing so it required less oil.

Very heavy at 9 pounds, I would not do it that way.

I would use a hollow shaft like the  Ross with a separate prop flange. No forging required. The flange would be retained by special set screws called  "Extended Point" . A relatively new idea and much stronger  than pins that go all the way trough the walls of the shaft (which is what Ross used for years) or splines and much less cost.
Easy to machine with a rotary table.

About a 2 inch OD steel tube with a .190 wall is about right. Just like the Ross box. That is about the largest needle bearing you can buy.

Use about eight or ten of these .25 inch screws and they are almost as strong as a one piece shaft and flange. Here are some pictures.

Do you use a dwg program Chris? If not I suggest getting a Rhino. It will save you money in the long run.

Paul Lamar

Speaking of the Ross PSRU, if one just decided to cast his own housing [perhaps out of an aluminum alloy], what would be the best alloy to use…decent properties and not too expensive or hard to do?
Gene Kahn


356 is the usual casting alloy and the foundry heat treats to T6 hardness.
Paul Lamar

I have been following this discussion as this is something I was thinking of trying. At first I thought it would be easiest to simply copy Tracy's 2.85 box because it seemed easier to plug a shaft into the planet gear rather than build something to drive a planet and 2.85 seems good enough. But as I read through this I can see a definite advantage to building the 3.17, less weight and more horsepower for free. However I am having a problem with the connection of the planet flange and the prop shaft. If I am seeing the drawings and understanding correctly, there will be eight or ten .25 small screws going through the flange and into the end of the shaft with a .190 wall. This doesn't make any sense to me. Is there something welded to the .190 shaft to accept the .25 screws? If the shaft were .250 and tiny #2 machine screws were used there would be enough meat in the end of the shaft to drill and tap but would that be strong enough? I must be missing something or I am not understanding it correctly.
Also how long should the prop shaft be? On Tracy's website he says that a longer shaft is better. What is the length of the Ross and Tracy shaft?
Paul Shamlian

We edm holes in the planet carrier planet shafts. This saves the hard smooth bearing surface for the needles bearings. The existing planet shafts are VERY hard to get out with out destroying the planet carrier.

As I recall the holes are at least 7/16th in dia.. The bolts going through these six holes attach the planet carrier to the aft flange on the hollow prop shaft. The aft  flange is either tig welded on the hollow prop shaft or it is bolted on  with a dozen or more 10-32 screws.
Ross tig welded it on. It is then wise to normalize and re heat treat to at least Rockwell 60.  The loads on the rear flange, unlike the front front prop flange, are pure shear loads. Then the shaft should be ground for the main needle bearings. The reason the prop shaft is so long is to react the gyro bending loads from the prop when the A/C spins or stalls.


Paul Lamar


Paul.
          How would chromoly go for the prop shaft ??   What are the
planetary gears that Tracy uses?    Neil.


Chrome molly tubing would be great.
The same ones I just delivered to Chris in NZ. :) Is your gear box giving trouble?

It is a Ford truck auto transmission rear set.

I can get them for under $200. I'll know more about shipping cost tomorrow. Today was a holiday for the PO. I do know UPS and FedX is very very expensive. I think Parcel Post will be the best bet.
I will also try DHL.

Paul Lamar



Paul,
             Valuable info as usual.  No my g/box is fine, but am just nervous with Tracy being retired.  Have a gap with not much in front of me so looking at making a complete g/box as a trial, which will give exact measurements.  The alloy housing can be cast in China as have found a bloke here in OZ that is getting a lot of work done in china, so eliminates the research in finding someone to do a casting rather than cutting the whole thing out of solid.  All day dreams at the moment, but currently working on suppliers.  Neil.

Not to worry they are not that hard to make.
Do you have a place in Parkes with a lathe about this size?
This is Chris Hoskins lathe in  NZ and he is building a Ford based Gbox.

Paul Lamar


Paul,
           Have access to lathes any size, I actually have one on loan to a
firm in town that can machine Rail engine wheels!!    So machining no
problem, how critical is the alloy for the housing?  Neil.


That wood NC machine you have in the garage is perfect for making sand casting patterns out of high density foam. Do the instructions say it can accept IGES files? Perhaps .STP files  AKA step files. If so I can send you a 3D file for a gear box housing pattern. Then it can be cast in Oz out of 356 aluminum alloy and heat treated by the foundry to  T6.

My friend Russ  MacFarland in NewCastle is shipping tons of Oz aluminum ingots to China so there is plenty of aluminum in Oz.

BTW If you have a sketch of wood artwork you would like to have made send me a jpg and I will draw it in Rhino and send you back a file the machine can use to make the part. No need to buy or learn Rhino.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Here are some pictures of Neal's low cost wood NC machine made and sold in Oz.  Very ingeniously made from high quality plywood.
Those Ozzies are clever blokes.

Ideal for making sand casting patterns.

Robin took the pictures with her cell phone.

Paul Lamar


Paul,
   The best way to make the casting patterns is to print them on a 3d printer.
Tony,
   No, it doesn't weigh a ton, only 1/2 a ton, you do need to be of a certain size to get enough force to make it powerful enough. Besides most if not all EZs can handle a little extra wt in the nose, unless of course you are a fat bastard.
   Chris.

ROFL a little NZ humor there :)

Paul Lamar


 The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
 ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
 You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
 Copyright 1998-2013 All world wide rights reserved.