The thing about this so-called "race" is the design engineer is
factored out of the equation. Individual cars have the HP and car
weight adjusted to make the performance equal. Unlike Formula 1 where
good engineering design counts.
Not really a car race at all. They should just let all the drivers
run around the track using just their legs for 24 hours and see who
wins :)
Mazda has entered their silly carcinogenic diesel in this race and
within an hour one is having problems.
Another silly car entered is the so called delta wing with a billet
block Mazda Miata engine. The "engineer" that designed this car
does not understand weight transfer in a corner. In the first hour it
spun out once.
Paul Lamar
I thought the Delta Wing had an affiliation with Nissan. Trikes do
not have exceptional stability.
Dale Davies
Last year.
Nissan/Renault wised up :) This year it is a Mazda Miata based
engine but the block is NC machined from a billet.
Paul Lamar
------------------------------------------------------- As of right
now the Delta is 16 laps down and last in class. There is a
difference between handling and cornering speed.
Paul Lamar
------------------------------------------ They interviewed John
Doonan on TV and he mentioned torque and steel pistons. Steel pistons
in a diesel is a drastic way to deal with piston over heating. That
tends to limit RPM and HP because of increased piston weight and
inertia forces on the connecting rods.
I wonder if they tried oil squirter's on the bottom of the heads of
the aluminum pistons? Standard in most aircraft piston engines and
probably truck diesel piston engines.
They could also go with beryllium aluminum pistons, BeAl is .7 times
the density of aluminum pistons and good to 750 F while aluminum
pistons start failing at 500 F. Outlawed in F1 but the Rolex
organizers might not know that.
Cars accelerate and airplanes fly on HP with a good gear box and not
torque.
They could always try talking the Rolex organizers into allowing them
to double the displacement of the diesel engine.
Mazda won the last Rolex race in 2012 with a RX8 rotary engine. Now
they are 12 laps down and running near the back. How the mighty have
fallen.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Diesel engines are limited in their rpm by the delay time between
the injection of fuel and the start of combustion. That's why car
diesels have peak power around 4000 rpm and redlines around 5000.
Even Mazda's racing diesel only revs slightly higher. Therefore any
additional weight imposed by steel pistons has no effect on the
engine's revving capability.
Csaba Csere
Do all diesel passenger cars use steel pistons? I don't pay too much
attention to them. Are new diesel cars required to use urea anti
pollution fluid in California like the trucks?
("The BlueTec system injects water-based urea solution into the
exhaust system. The ammonia produced by the hydrolysis of the urea
reacts with the nitrogen oxide emissions and is converted into
nitrogen and water within the catalytic converter.")
The BSFC of the rotary gets much better when they are leaned to 18:1
but the NO goes way up.
I just found out that the Mazda diesel's are using cast iron blocks.
For some reason I got the idea that they were aluminum. Mazda are not
very fourth coming with the tech.
Last Daytona race info I have is they were 54th in a field of 67 OA.
Even the delta is ahead of them :)
Now that Form 1 is using turbo compound I hope Mazda wakes up and
uses it with the rotary. IMHO a potential 30% reduction in fuel burn
without the pollution problems of the diesel and also without the
exhaust valve problems of the piston turbo compound.
Paul Lamar
I've been watching the Daytona race. Sort of sentimental; the 24-hour
was the last time I drove in a race, in '94. And, this does not make
me a participant in the current diesel/Mazda/steel piston debates,
but something has gone wrong with the Mazda car or cars and at least
one of them is so slow it is dangerous and should be black-flagged
off the track. I have no idea why the organizers allow it to continue
to stay on the track, because it's a bad wreck waiting to happen.
As for the Delta, it might feel nimble to the drivers but that's not
the same thing as cornering speed or exit speed. IMHO the jury is
still way out because no one has yet made the comparison of equal
weight and horsepower with a conventional four-wheel layout compared
to the Delta's modified three-wheel configuration. Until somebody
does that, who knows what the advantage or disadvantage truly is? And
I bet it has more than half the drag of a conventional car and
doesn't have anywhere near the downforce; after all, its frontal area
is not a lot less than a four-wheeler, it's just narrower at the
front. It's like the front end of a Bonneville streamliner and the
back end of a sports-racer.
And the organizer's efforts to have all the cars with essentially
very close top speeds seems to have resulted in them driving around
in packs and passing has to occur with dive-bomb moves through
traffic into crowded corners. I saw Jamie MacMurray make an
absolutely thoroughly professional move to avoid a wreck just because
some bonehead in a Ferrari waited too long to get on the brakes as a
crowd was getting into the chicane.
I hope Pruett wins. The very first time Scott Pruett ever drove in an
endurance race of any kind it was a three-hour end-of-season SCCA
enduro at Riverside, put on by the Cal Club. I believe he was still a
teenager, fresh out of go-karts. There were about 80 or so cars,
anything with fenders, from Showroom Stock C to TransAm Mustangs and,
if memory serves, a Porsche 935. The speed differentials on the back
straight might have been close to 2:1. His co-driver was yours truly.
We won our class. Taught the kid everything he knows.
The rest is history.
But they really ought to black-flag that Mazda and get it off the
track.
Hugs and kisses --
Uncle Don [Fuller]
Paul,
I'm not sure if steel pistons are common on passenger car diesels,
but the urea fluid requirement seems to depend on engine size. The
smaller cars, such as the VW diesels can meet the NOx requirements
without the urea-catalyst. But as the vehicle gets larger, requiring
the engine to develop more power and burn more fuel, NOx emissions
rise and the more complex and expensive urea catalyst is required.
By the way, the other problem with diesel cars is that there isn't
any spare diesel fuel. Over the past thirty years, global demand for
diesel has grown faster than global demand for gasoline. That's why
diesel has gone from being 15 percent cheaper than gasoline in 1980
to 15-20 percent more expensive today. If America really started to
buy lots of diesels, this situation would simply worsen.
Already, diesels make little economic sense. You get 30 percent
better fuel economy, but pay 20 percent more for the fuel. And you
pay $5 grand upfront for the privilege. What a deal!
Csaba Csere
Particulate's 'Black' Smoke from a Diesel necessarily means
something's wrong with it, as a less, it's out of tuning, or has
injectors or injection pump problems, or
a combination of several factors. Smoke in tractor pulling contests is
not at all representative, these engines are tuned to produce a huge
amount of power under
exceptional requirements and conditions, any vehicle going in a street
or road, and emitting that much smoke would be halted by the police,
have a fine, and put
out of circulation permit until reaching an acceptable level of
emissions during inspection.
Thanks, have good season. Best regards.
Salut † Jose Gros-Aymerich
Madrid, Spain
That may be true over there.
The school buses were doing it here in California but not quite that bad.
I still see the occasional truck still doing it. If you adjust the
injector pump to not to
do it you limit the acceleration of the engine. The term "smoke limit"
is used
to describe the adjustment.Millions of French people and other Europeans
are needlessly
dieing of lung cancer because of the widespread use of diesel fuel in
passenger cars.
Many with worn out injector pumps.
It is not only the smoke that causes the problem. The particulates are
still there.
You just cannot see them.
That is why the emissions equipment cost $15,000 to retrofit
to a California truck.
Diesel cars no longer sell in California.
Paul Lamar
Shortly after the implementation of emission standards in North
America, the public was annoyed at the early efforts to reduce
emissions. Poor driveability and fuel economy were the cause.
Then people started to notice heavy trucks spewing grey or black
smoke and legislators felt the heat. Detroit Diesel two stroke
engines had a throttle delay kit. One rocker shaft stand had a
cup on top and a piston bore in the lower side. There was an
adjustable lever bolted to the rack with the piston attached.
There was a fill hole with check valve to allow rapid filling
when the rack returned to idle (out). When the throttle was
stepped on to accelerate there was an orffice to let the oil out
slowly. There is a selection of gap gauges and a go-no go gauge
to set this properly for the engine so that almost no smoke was
visible. Worked OK across the prairies but hills and stop and
go traffic caused problems.
As Paul stated, no fuel the turbo
does not spool up to give boost and the truck will not pull.
With standard transmission it would just start to pull and it
was time to back off to shift. Reboot the scenario. No
computer injection with multiple injections per firing sequence.
Tractor pull engines, Bonneville land speed and race trucks have
monster injectors to enable huge power. Until the turbo spins
up the engine runs really rich producing thick black smoke.
Much different scenario to over the road vehicles. Poor
maintenance is generally the cause of dirty running diesels.
Diesel fuel pump and injector service gets real expensive quick.
Add in oil and filter replacement at double to triple the cost
of a gasoline engine and the cost advantage of ownership does
not look so good. For heavy haul or regular trailer pull, OK.
Dale Davies