Paul,
Do you have details on autogiro's running rotaries ? Pardon my
thoughts, but I think a rotary would work well.
Thanks,
Barron
I don't have any dwgs but Gary Buster might help you out.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QOwb8QRHrMY
Paul Lamar
Back in the days of the late Cierva and before the Advent of the
helicopter the autogyro was quite a capable machine. It had heavy two
or more bladed rotor systems which stored a great amount of energy.
Todays autogyros on the other hand in my opinion as a rated Chpl with
IFR must be the daftest thing out there. Flimsy contraptions with
energyretention on the scale of a chopstick. You would not find my
behind in One of them on a calm, stable day let alone in any kind of
turbulence. Surprises me they are legal.
Lutz Strobel
Have you looked at the you tube video?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QOwb8QRHrMY
I filmed the video. Looked pretty good to me. However it was a calm
day.
IMHO the main problem is MPG.
Paul Lamar
Actually the main problem is negative G's When that happens the disk
is no longer loaded and looses momentum, which is where the lack of
stored energy due to the low mass of the rotor system comes in....
the second severe problem is the underslung rotorsystem most of the
nowadays ( refuse to callem modern ) autogyros employ. It can kill
You fast. In summary stay away from them, even if a crash of one of
them would have nothing to do with being powered by a Rotary engine,
it would still rub off. - Lutz Strobel
We are not doing outside loops here :)
There are a lot of them in the States. If the accident rate were much
higher than other experimental aircraft the FAA would be all over
their case.
Paul Lamar
A lot of people think a gyro works by weight shift, it does not, the
teetering rotor and gimbal head allow the rotor to in effect change
pitch around the circle as the advancing blade would have more lift
than the retreating blade if it did not teeter They are not as simple
as they look.
John Evans
Lutz you should try them although I think no one could pursuance you
to do so now. They are fun and safe, and handle turbulence very well.
If fact you do not feel any at all even in very high wind. The
"rigidity" which is the percent of lifting surface in the whole disc
is very small, compared with that of a plane which is 100%, so
turbulence is no issue for a gyro.
Gordon Gao
Thanks for the warning Lutz, but I think if flown properly the gyro's
are as safe as the next aircraft. Many people see the "open cockpit"
and can't imagine flying them. This is because people don’t
understand them, and this is understandable as they are not as common
as their fixed wind counter parts.
Thanks,
Barron
Its not about outside loops or any such stuff. Remember the FAA put a
restriction on R22 Helicopters regarding flight in turbulence ? They
experienced mast bumping ( bet most auto gyro pilots today don't
even know what that is ) and in some instances even cut of their own
tail booms ! Anyone who has ever flown in the mountains with strong
winds, or in the vicinity of thunderstorms ( you'd be surprised how
far away their might extends ) knows that negative G's are NOT a
question of a barrel roll gone wrong..... If you think that negative
G's are something you induce yourself please see your local CFI again
! Better still attend some real helicopter ground instruction.
Fact is: once that rotor disc is not driven anymore by airflow from
below it starts to slow down and when that rotation becomes slow
enough your contraption becomes a not so streamlined anvil. And no, i
don't have anything against light aviation. I am an active glider
pilot and have even participated in the German national championship
in hang gliding back in 1992.
Lutz Strobel
There are 100's flying in the states and I'll bet the accident rate
is no higher than hang gliding. People don't fly them in
thunderstorms and they don't use them for getting from one place to
another. Strictly recreational.
You would not fly your hang glider in a thunderstorm would you?
Just put a tach on the rotor disc and an alarm :)
How people choose to kill them selves is nobodies biz but their own.
When is the last time a gyro crashed and killed some one on the
ground?
Government, get out of my life and I don't want to pay them to do
it.
Paul Lamar
I'd say an autogyro is a rotating wing, that instead of obtaining
lift from the airspeed of airplane's wings, it obtains lift from the
airspeed of blades rotating against the air, in fact, autogyro and
helicopter blades are very high aspect ratio wings, the ones with a
better lift to drag ratio, the trick in autogyro is that once a
certain speed of rotation in terms of rotor rpm is reached, the
turning of rotor is self-sustained by the forward airspeed of flying
machine, no need to apply power on the rotor shaft, although some
models had a clutch that temporarily connected the rotor to the
engine, in oder to make a 'fast jump' takeoff, for example, going
over obstacles in the flight line. Thanks for your attention. Best
regards. Salut †
Jose Gros-Aymerich Madrid, Spain
Sure, I know what mast bumping is and I have seen several videos,
however from what I understand autogyros do not experience this the
same way a helicopter does. That is because there no powered mast
to provide the torque as there is in a helicopter. The rotor if a
gyro spins on bearings. However gyros can still have an issue with
Negative G's thus losing altitude and the loss of rudder authority
means that the gyro can rotate itself right into the rotor, usually
chopping the tail off
Ref: Try_Cyclic
Thanks,
Barron
wow... I'm shaking my head in disbelief!
let's get back onto rotary engines... to reteach the quantity of
misinformation regarding gyroplanes from this thread would take a monumental
effort. (geeeezzzzz!!)
I typically discuss gyroplanes only with people who want real data to
further their knowledge. Reteaching someone's half truths just about does
me in. I'd rather let you go on with your mindset and enjoy another hour of
flying instead of trying to convince you of what I've already learned as
truth. I'm a distributor of Butterfly Gyroplanes, and have a couple of
gazillion hours in two different tandems with bridgeported 12a's. Hollar
at me if you need data about a small gyro. Hollar at me if you need data
regarding the 12a's I've used on the tandems.
Paul... I vote to refocus on rotary engines instead of gyroplanes on this
forum!!
garybuster@gmail.com
Gary Buster
T25 Aero Estates
East Texas
I wonder what took you so long :)
Paul Lamar