Subject: Boeing 777 Captain Opinion
From: rotaryeng
Date: 3/22/2014, 4:42 AM
To: AAA-rotaryeng




  From a retired USAF Col now flying 777s: Just a quick update with
   what I know about the Malaysia 777 disappearance.  The Boeing 777 is
   the airplane that I fly.  It is a great, safe airplane to fly. It
   has, for the most part, triple redundancy in most of its systems, so
   if one complete system breaks (not just parts of a system), there
   are usually 2 more to carry the load.  It’s also designed to be easy
   to employ so 3rd world pilots can successfully fly it. Sometimes,
   even that doesn’t work…as the Asiana guys in San Fran showed us.  A
   perfectly good airplane on a beautiful, sunny day…and they were able
   to crash it.  It took some doing, but they were able to defeat a
   bunch of safety systems and get it to where the airplane would not
   help them and the pilots were too stupid/scared/unskilled/tired to
   save themselves

   There’s many ways to fly the 777 and there are safety layers and
   redundancies built into the airplane.  It is tough to screw up and
   the airplane will alert you in many ways (noises, alarms, bells and
   whistles, plus feed back thru the control yoke and rudder pedals and
   throttles.  In some cases the airplane’s throttles ‘come alive’ if
   you are going to slow for a sustained period of time)  All designed
   to help.  But, it’s also non-intrusive.  If you fly the airplane in
   the parameters it was designed for, you will never know these other
   things exist.  The computers actually ‘help’ you and the designers
   made it for the way pilots think and react.  Very Nice.

   Now to Malaysia .  There are so many communication systems on the
   airplane.  3 VHF radios. 2 SatCom systems.  2 HF radio systems. Plus
   Transpoders and active, ‘real time’ monitoring through CPDLC
   (Controller to Pilot Data Link Clearance) and ADS B(Air Data
   Service) through the SatCom systems and ACARS (Aircraft
   Communications Addressing and Reporting System) thru the VHF, HF and
   SatCom systems. The air traffic controllers can tell where we are,
   speed, altitude, etc as well as what our computers and flight
   guidance system has set into our control panels.  Big Brother for
   sure!  However, most of these things can be turned off.

   But, there are a few systems that can’t be turned off and one, as
   reported by the WSJ, is the engine monitoring systems (not sure what
   the acronym for that is, but I’m sure there is one….it’s
   aviation…there has to be an acronym!).  The Malaysia airplane, like
   our 777-200s, use Rolls Royce Trent Engines (as a piece of
   trivia….Rolls Royce names their motors after rivers….because they
   always keep on running!)  Rolls Royce leases these motors to us and
   they monitor them all the time they are running. In fact, a few
   years back, one of our 777s developed a slow oil leak due to partial
   equipment failure.  It wasn’t bad enough to set off the airplane’s
   alerting system, but RR was looking at it on their computers. They
   are in England, they contact our dispatch in Texas.  Dispatch sends
   a message to the crew via SatCom in the North Pacific, telling them
   that RR wants them to closely monitor oil pressure and temp on the
   left engine.  Also, during the descent, don’t retard the throttle to
   idle…keep it at or above a certain rpm.  Additionally, they wanted
   the crew to turn on the engine ‘anti ice’ system as that heats some
   of the engine components.

   The crew did all of that and landed uneventfully, but after landing
   and during the taxi in, the left engine shut itself down using it’s
   redundant, computerized operating system that has a logic tree that
   will not allow it to be shut down if the airplane is in the air…only
   on the ground.  Pretty good tech.Anyway, the point was, that RR
   monitors those engines 100% of the time they are operating.  The WSJ
   reported that RR indicated the engines on the Malaysia 777 were
   running normally for 4 to 5 hours after the reported disappearance.
   Malaysia denies this.  We shall see.

   Parting shot.  If you travel by air, avoid the 3rd world airlines.
   Their operators and maintenance are substandard.  Substandard when
   traveling by Bus or Boat isn’t so bad when the engines quit. You
   just stop on the water or by the side of the road.  Not so in
   airplanes.  My piece of advice….if traveling by air use 1st world
   airlines.  So, that leaves USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, most
   of Europe, Japan and just a few others.  Avoid the rest….just my
   opinion.  If you get a real deal on air fare from ‘Air Jabooti’…skip
   it.  Oh, there are a lot of the ‘developing’ countries that use
   expatriate pilots from the 1st world.  Emirates and Air Jordan come
   to mind and are very safe.  As is Cathay Pacific.  Air Pakistan and
   Egypt Air…not so much. Do the research or just drop me a note. I’ll
   give you my opinion.

   And don't EVER get in an Airbus!!

   That is all!

   [ signed ]

   A retired Boeing 767 captain friend agrees with him regarding
   Airbuses - DWM.

   Thanks for the very interesting info. As living in an EU country,
   and many governments here invested in Airbus, I can't be free of
   bias, but: May I ask you about the reasons for your dislike or
   negative feedback about Airbus?

   Besides two relatives working in Airbus related companies, another
   one working as an Aeronautical Engineer for Iberia, another relative
   that was formerly the president of SEPLA, the airline pilot's union,
   and a not much close relative working as airline pilot, and myself
   having done my mandatory army service in the Spanish Air Force as
   Physician, I have no direct connection to the aviation industry.

   Thanks for your kind attention, have a nice weekend, best regards.

   Salut † Jose Gros-Aymerich Madrid, Spain

   By the way: does anybody have an explanation or info about the
   reasons why the German Air Force didn't get rid of the F-104 fighters
   bought with the help of a bribery, until more than 250 pilots were
   killed flying it?


   ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

   The government "investment" is probably the problem. It is not the
   business of government to "invest" in anything. They can't govern or
   operate a medical service efficiently let alone run a manufacturing
   business. The exorbitant tax rate in Europe proves this.

   Private companies invest to make money. If they make a bad product
   they go out of business. With all due respect for a doctor you sure
   don't know much about economics. I recommend reading this book.

   "Economics in One Lesson"

   The Shortest and Surest Way to Understand Basic Economics. by Henry
   Hazlitt

<http://www.amazon.com/Henry-Hazlitt/e/B000AP5TAQ/ref=ntt_athr_dp_pel_1


   Over a million copies have been sold.

   Maybe the German pilots were incompetent or poorly trained. The F104
   did not kill 250 American pilots.

   Who had super sonic fighter planes other than America at the time?
   Nobody but the Russians.

   Germany needed to defend themselves from the communist Russians.

   BTW Vladimir Putin  is a communist. The communist realistically
   believe that communism won't work as long as people have an
   alternative so therefor they must control the world with guns. If you
   let the government take your guns you deserve what you are going to
   get.

   The Ukraine  is learning that lesson now. Those that fail to learn
   from history are doomed to repeat it.

   Our current stupid president understands none of this.

   Paul Lamar


   I remember the delamination of flying surfaces discussion in this forum, years ago, related to American Airlines Flight 587 <http://www.airfleets.net/crash/crash_report_American%20Airlines_N14053.htm

   Numbers can be confusing but important to know that B-737's (which had their share of accidents) have been flying since 1970, when NO AirBus was on the air until 1982 (use it for a longer time, more mishaps accrue). OTOH next gen. 737's seem to have had a brilliant record since 2005.

   Can anybody give some info about hours of flight vs. # of mishaps? I couldn't find that.

   In the mean time, I fly Boeing, period (and NOT the O'Bozo's periods).

   Alfonso Lebron


The 737 has the best record of miles traveled and passengers carried without deaths. It is also the most used passenger carrier giving it more exposure. Very few aircraft have 1000 examples sold. The 737 is either close to or past 3000 units!
The 777 had NO FATALITIES until some dummies actually flew it into the ground at San Francisco.
When you sell your product for PROFIT you need to keep your customers happy. A bad crash record will not fill the order sheet. No government extortion to keep building them.

Bill Jepson

I might add that government run businesses are not efficient because the bureaucrats
making the decisions have no vested interest in the outcome. In the US they cannot be fired.
If a CEO in  private corporation made a bad decision he would lose his job. He gets paid
big bucks based on his track record of making a profit.


If a small business owner made a bad decision he would lose his investment.


Paul Lamar

    The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
    ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
    You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
    Copyright 1998-2014 All world wide rights reserved.