Hallo: by serendipity, 'chiripa' in Spanish, I've found these
comments by one of the engineers who were involved in the
development of OMC Wankel engines. Hope it's of some interest to you.
Have a good season. Best regards.
Salut Jose Gros-Aymerich; Madrid, Spain
http://vintageomc.webs.com/theomcproduction.htm
"Max Bentle of Curtis Wright is credited with the kinematic
inversion of the engine allowing the housing to remain stationary
with a rotating crankshaft."
Untrue. It was a person at NSU. The name later.
"The pressurized oil system allowed the use of conventional babit
bearings and with the addition of an oil cooler to maintained
internal temperatures adequately."
Are you listening you Wankel heads in Europe? :)
"Curtis had use “D-Gun” tungsten carbide from Linde as their
coating, which was very effective, but extremely expensive."
Interesting.
"It was also hundreds of pounds lighter than the V-8 being used and
as such would out accelerate them even with 100 less hp."
"Both versions meet the design requirement of 100 hrs @ WOT."
"The trochoid coating was still “D-Gun”, as research hadn’t
developed a lower cost suitable coating yet."
"After several months of work, it became apparent an oil-cooled
engine could not be made cost competitive with a 2 cycle and work on
oil cooled engines stopped."
" Unlike a piston engine, the rotor is a captive heat source with
very little heat rejected to the housing walls. As such most of the
cooling had to come from the incoming charge to cool the rotor. The
result is a significant reduction in volumetric efficiency, the
actual amount of air going thru the engine vs its theoretical
capacity. This is due to the significant heating of the charge as it
passes thru the engine."
"Unfortunately he had designed a 2 stage axial blower running at
30,000 RPM and took 35 hp to drive to cool the CW design."
"We knew an axial fan could not generate sufficient pressure that
would result in the velocity required to cool the engine."
"The rotor bearing was the weak link of this engine. Being inside
the rotor, it is completely dependent on the incoming charge for
cooling and lubrication. The bearing was already pretty special. It
had a silver plated retainer and a high temperature temper of the
outer race. Steel grows; get larger, as it gets hotter. That is until
it exceeds the temper temperature where in it gets smaller. As I
figured out after 100’s of tests, there was a lubrication breakdown
between the retainer and the outer race. The result was steel running
on steel at very high speeds generating extreme heat. The result was
the bearing shrinking onto the crank eccentric stalling the engine.
It took a hydraulic press or a sledge hammer' to get them apart. I
took several samples to SKF Research and talked to the chief
metallurgist. He told me this was impossible to do. When I suggested
he come to Waukegan and see for himself, he said the bearing had to
be reaching 1800 F for this to happen. This type failure was
self-destructing. When the bearing got near its thermal breakdown
temperature it would self generate additional heat causing further
oil breakdown, causing additional heat, etc, etc,etc. "
The European Wankel builders have yet to learn a lot of these
lessons. Not Mazda. Mazda is the gold of the Wankel world.
Paul Lamar
Hi Paul!: thanks for your always interesting technical comments.
I mean,
the author of this article is an American working for OMC in the
States; yes,
I was aware that the geometrical inversion that changed the two
parts turning
early Wankel designs was a German engineer close to F Wankel.
I'm not a RCE builder, nor I have more contacts with the
European
producers of these engines than you may have, but as Poul Woelfler of
Aixro is subscribed to this page's e-mail, for sure it's highly
possible than
your comments arrived to them.
I don't understand why Sachs never considered the solutions that gave
good results to Yanmar Diesel, but they are on this business, not me,
I'm just a hobbyist.
I don't know what the situation of current producers of RCEs is, but
initially, all makers having bought a Wankel license transmitted
each other
the results of their research on RCEs, with the exception of
General Motors,
that never signed such an agreement, and whose technical papers
point they
have much more data than they show.
I've got a very kind letter from the man in charge of the
'public relations'
in Alfa-Romeo, near Milano, and he offered to give me the
opportunity of
having a look at the data they obtained after buying a Wankel license,
they have a big box full of it, and the only requirement is that I must
request an appointment at least 30 days before my arrival there.
BTW: I've bought a 'stuck' 35 HP OMC Snowmobile Wankel engine,
seller
told it was stuck because of not in use for long time, if I
remember well.
I'd like having this engine turning again.
Are you aware of somebody specializing in selling parts and
keeping alive
these Snowmobile RCEs? The engine is currently in WI
Thanks for your kind attention. Have a good week.
Best regards. Salud † Jose Gros-Aymerich; Madrid, Spain
No I do not.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux. ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net You Tube
http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2014 All world wide rights reserved.