On Thu, Jun 19, 2014 at 8:22 AM, rotaryeng <
rotaryeng@earthlink.net
<mailto:rotaryeng@earthlink.net>> wrote:
Hallo: by serendipity, 'chiripa' in Spanish, I've found these
comments by one of the engineers who were involved in the development of
OMC Wankel engines.
Hope it's of some interest to you. Have a good season. Best regards.
Salut Jose Gros-Aymerich; Madrid, Spain
http://vintageomc.webs.com/theomcproduction.htm
<http://vintageomc.webs.com/theomcproduction.htm>
<
http://vintageomc.webs.com/theomcproduction.htm
<http://vintageomc.webs.com/theomcproduction.htm>>
"Max Bentle of Curtis Wright is credited with the kinematic
inversion of the engine allowing the housing to remain stationary with a
rotating crankshaft."
Untrue. It was a person at NSU. The name later.
"The pressurized oil system allowed the use of conventional babit
bearings and with the addition of an oil cooler to maintained internal
temperatures adequately."
Are you listening you Wankel heads in Europe? :)
"Curtis had use “D-Gun” tungsten carbide from Linde as their
coating, which was very effective, but extremely expensive."
Interesting.
"It was also hundreds of pounds lighter than the V-8 being used and
as such would out accelerate them even with 100 less hp."
"Both versions meet the design requirement of 100 hrs @ WOT."
"The trochoid coating was still “D-Gun”, as research hadn’t
developed a lower cost suitable coating yet."
"After several months of work, it became apparent an oil-cooled
engine could not be made cost competitive with a 2 cycle and work on oil
cooled engines stopped."
" Unlike a piston engine, the rotor is a captive heat source with
very little heat rejected to the housing walls. As such most of the
cooling had to come from the incoming charge to cool the rotor. The
result is a significant reduction in volumetric efficiency, the actual
amount of air going thru the engine vs its theoretical capacity. This is
due to the significant heating of the charge as it passes thru the engine."
"Unfortunately he had designed a 2 stage axial blower running at
30,000 RPM and took 35 hp to drive to cool the CW design."
"We knew an axial fan could not generate sufficient pressure that
would result in the velocity required to cool the engine."
"The rotor bearing was the weak link of this engine. Being inside
the rotor, it is completely dependent on the incoming charge for cooling
and lubrication. The bearing was already pretty special. It had a silver
plated retainer and a high temperature temper of the outer race. Steel
grows; get larger, as it gets hotter. That is until it exceeds the
temper temperature where in it gets smaller. As I figured out after
100’s of tests, there was a lubrication breakdown between the retainer
and the outer race. The result was steel running on steel at very high
speeds generating extreme heat. The result was the bearing shrinking
onto the crank eccentric stalling the engine. It took a hydraulic press
or a sledge hammer' to get them apart. I took several samples to SKF
Research and talked to the chief metallurgist. He told me this was
impossible to do. When I suggested he come to Waukegan and see for
himself, he said the bearing had to be reaching 1800 F for this to
happen. This type failure was self-destructing. When the bearing got
near its thermal breakdown temperature it would self generate additional
heat causing further oil breakdown, causing additional heat, etc, etc,etc. "
The European Wankel builders have yet to learn a lot of these lessons.
Not Mazda. Mazda is the gold of the Wankel world.
Paul Lamar
Kinematic inversion.
The Gentleman at NSU was Mr. H, D, Paschke, Hans Dieter.
http://www.der-wankelmotor.de/Wankelmotor/wankelmotor.html
<http://www.der-wankelmotor.de/Wankelmotor/wankelmotor.html>
Rolf Pfeiffer
Hello Paul,
Here is a translation. The two moving pictures of DKM and KKM fit
above and besides the name H.D. Paschke.
Felix was just 25 when he wrote this in his diary:
“The huge difference between the efforts by BBC (no reference is
cited) and my own is that I do not want to replace steam or a water jet
with a jet ignited gas, but I would like to make use of the same power
generation by the gas expansion as it occurs in the reciprocating
engine, however in rotating motion. Intake, compression, power and
exhaust shall remain as is since I trust that ignition and expansion of
gasoline etc. is best suited for power generation. Only the mechanical
volume variation is to be achieved under full rotation instead of a
reciprocating motion. This is my task.”
>From this entree in his diary to the first working Wankel engine,
the DKM 54, was a long and thorny road ahead.
It was Feb. 1, 1957 when the DKM 54 first came to life on a test
bed. After some adjustments of ignition timing and gas mixture its
running became smooth. For the external rotor and for the internal rotor
only pure rotation exists where the inner rotor solely functions as
valve to control intake and exhaust. With this running engine the
possibility of a working rotary engine was confirmed. For practical
applications this form of engine was unsuitable, e.g. the spark plugs
were located in the pockets of the inner rotor.
It was H.D. Paschke of NSU who succeeded in achieving the kinematic
inversion from the DKM to the KKM (DKM = Drehkolbenmotor, Dreh=
Rotation, KKM = Kreiskolbenmotor, Kreis = circle, where the centre of
the inner rotor describes a circle and the outer rotor becomes stationary.)
Mr. Paschke worked under strict secrecy to make the outer rotor
stationary.
Now there was no longer pure rotation, but two rotations
superimposed on each other. Negative accelerations occur on the short
axis pointing to the inside. Problems arise to remove the cooling oil
from the rotor as it churns with loss of energy inside the rotor just
moving back and forth. Felix Wankel snubs the idea as he becomes aware
of it, however it is too late when he grudgingly makes that famous
statement: “You made a plow horse out of my race horse.” To which he
was told: “I only wish we already had the plow horse.”
Now the problems with the KKM begin to appear. Chatter marks occur.
At times it is only a so called chatter shadow. Chrome coatings of the
housings flake off and the engine die off in short order. At Mazda it is
being recognized that the weight of the apex seals is to blame. Bores
are drilled through the cast iron seals thereby finally reached long
duration runs. In first production models NSU and Mazda use
coal-graphite seals. NSU applied carbon-antimony, Mazda carbon-aluminum
materials. Mazda advanced the seal technology to later to return to cast
iron seals and chrome coating in the housing. A steel insert is added to
the Al housing with precision chrome plating where the chrome layer is
so thin that no grinding is required and high durability is still
obtained. The cast iron seals were later replaced by ferrous seal.
During the oil crisis in the 1970’s more and more licensees leave the
scene. Only Mazda as the only car manufacturer remains faithful. As
Audi-NSU stopped production of the RO80 in 1977 production of the Wankel
as car engine ends in Germany.
With the development of the Renesis Wankel engine in the RX8 a
‘race horse’ engine was yet achieved from the ‘plow horse’. The present
version (I am not sure when it was written) the Renesis delivers 231 hp
at 8500 rpm. The Renesis RX8 apparently requires 50% less lubricating
oil and 40% less fuel than its predecessor. Besides that it meets the
Euro-4 emission regulations. The side exhaust port was only possible
with a ceramic insert cast into the housing. The housing running surface
is now of a chrome-molybdenum alloy. Molybdenum is one of the few
materials where chatter marks do not occur and it has excellent running
properties.
Rolf
Hi Jose,
I see what you mean. However, I do not think that these statements are
correct.
Wankel GMBH was located at lake Constance who made a deal with NSU for a
60/40 split where Wankel had much too good a deal receiving 40% without
needing to do any more work after providing the base concept that could
not be used in practice. After that, Wankel GmbH had no more rights to
sign any licenses. Mr Hutzenlaub was his promoter who negotiated on
behalf of Wankel GmbH.
The exclusing license with Curtis Wright was between NSU and CW. Even
the name Max Bentele is spelled wrong in this article.
The point that CW was not interested in its development but rather to
mainly sell licenses is quite correct, however. NSU was desperate at the
time and the lure of a million dolars was just to great to refuse. CW
also went public with the idea without the knowledge or agreement of NSU
who were furious at the time as CW broke their word.
A very good book on it all is this one:
http://www.amazon.com/Wankel-Mut-Autoindustrie-Anfang-einer-Antriebsalternative/dp/3894041455/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1403197214&sr=1-2&keywords=Wankelmut
Wankel-Mut in der Autoindustrie. Anfang und Ende einer
Antriebsalternative (German) Paperback – Import, January 1, 1994
by Andreas Knie
<http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=dp_byline_sr_book_1?ie=UTF8&field-author=Andreas+Knie&search-alias=books&text=Andreas+Knie&sort=relevancerank>
(Author)
It is in German, however.
Mr Max Bentele's role is described therein as well. He did not make the
kinematic inversion to the KKM.
Rolf Pfeiffer