Subject: Coax muffler sound. With MP4
From: rotaryeng
Date: 6/23/2014, 5:11 PM
To: AA-1-Me



Now that we have the sound of Neal's muffler documented  we can
compare it with the coax muffler sound of Brian Trubee' RV4 muffler.

As you can tell the coax tone is lower and more IMHO pleasing :). It
is also a combined muffler and thrust augmenter. One pound of thrust
at 200 mph or 300 feet per second is 300 lb ft/second.


The /mechanical horsepower/ of exactly 550 foot-pounds per second is
 one HP.

Since thrust HP is net HP you don't have  all the losses in the gear
 box and prop. My guess that amounts to 80%. So one pound of thrust
becomes 300/.8 or 375 lb ft/second.

Now we still don't know how much thrust the coax muffler provides so
 if Neal measured the top speed with his current muffler and then
installed a coax muffler we would find out :)

BTW  equivalent flat plate area (EFPA) for a Van RV6 is about 2.32
square feet.

EFPA is equal to the drag factor times the frontal area.

The RV4 is about the same as the RV6.

Drag is equal to EFPA X .0026 X MPH^2 So RV4 drag at 200 MPH is about
240 pounds. Net HP is 72000/550 or 131 NET HP out of the prop or
about 164 engine HP.

Brian is reporting good numbers with the coax but so far not back to
 back with a good conventional  muffler. His old muffler was
partially melted inside. A common occurrence with rotary muffler.
They must be inspected with a bore scope from time to time.  On the
other hand a visual inspection of the open coax is all that is
needed.

Paul Lamar

The "piccolo tube" muffler on the YO-3A "Quiet Star" in your picture is
similar internally to what you have drawn. Do you have calculations for
the various lengths and diameters in this new design or is it by eye? I
wonder if the scalloped edges are doing anything -- there are a couple
of papers on how NASA and Boeing arrived at them for the 787 shown. I'd
be really surprised if there were any actual thrust augmentation but
that would be a neat surprise! I am working on just this sort of muffler
for my low noise prop design effort, so very interested in the details.
There are a few papers on the YO-3A design and test available but not
very much info on its muffler. There is a supposedly complete set of
drawings at the Museum of Flight in Seattle with their YO-3A, which has
been restored and is on display -- it's the same Army 18005 in your
photo which was rescued after sitting on the ramp north of Seattle for a
long time.

David Josephson

Mark i eyeball :)

2 inch pipe inside 5 inch outside 6' long.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
Copyright 1998-2014 All world wide rights reserved.