Subject: Yet another wanna be rotary
From: rotaryeng
Date: 7/23/2014, 11:44 AM
To: AA-1-Me



Interesting new type rotar, wow, if they ever manufacture.
http://liquidpiston.com/


RODNEY BINGHAM

Hardly Wow :) The monthly new rotary engine :)

Not a real practical rotary engine. No thought on cooling or sealing and reciprocating motion.

=========================================

"By Kenichi Yamamoto from his book "Rotary Engine" 1981

1.3     REQUIREMENTS FOR A PRACTICAL ROTARY ENGINE
        Although various types of rotary engines have been developed to date, there are few that do not qualify as internal combustion engines or do not qualify as a practical engine even if they satisfy the qualifications of an internal combustion engine.
        The requirements for a rotary engine to be qualified as a practical internal combustion engine can be summed up in the following five items. The practicality of various ideas on rotary engines can be judged by evaluating them by these
criteria:

(1) Every moving part, including the timing mechanism, should make a rotating motion. A mechanism having a reciprocating inertia will increase mechanical noise and vibration, and will work against high speed and high revolution.  [In addition mechanisms that reciprocate generate reversing loads. Reversing loads lead to reversing stresses. Reversing stresses lead to metal fatigue and limited life. The Wankel rotary engine has no reversing stresses therefor the life of the major parts such as the eccentric shaft and rotor are unlimited unlike, crankshafts, connecting rods, pistons and poppet valves. Paul Lamar]  Accordingly, structures that require intake and exhaust valves and mechanisms using the rotors oscillatory motion are not desirable.

(2)     Gas seals or the working chamber should be three
dimension-ally reliable.  The gas seal mechanism of a rotary engine should be constituted by connecting the individual seals three dimension-ally. Among the many ideas we come across are those that don't show such three dimensional thoughts.

(3)     Appropriate gas exchange of intake and exhaust should
take place. Together with having a mechanism that can correctly open and close the ports, sufficient time for intake and exhaust should be provided especially for high speed and high revolution.  Among the ideas on rotary engines, there are some that ignore this point.

(4)     Every component part should have the strength to endure
high speed and high pressure.  As the component parts are exposed to high pressure, high sliding velocity and high heat load, every part should have sufficient allowance in size and in shape.

(5)     Sufficient cooling and lubrication should be provided.
In order to qualify as an internal combustion engine, although this is related to above (4), durability against high heat load, high sliding velocity, etc. are required. Therefore, the structure should be simple, and the ideas on rotor cooling, lubrication of seal parts, and oil seal structure should be those that are given adequate thought.

        Also, it is desirable for a practical rotary engine to have a simple and compact structure. When we evaluate the various type's of rotary engines devised to date in view of the above mentioned requirements, the NSU Wankel type rotary engine is the engine that best satisfies the above mentioned requirements."



 Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,

As president of Ultra Engines with Zimmer Corp. in Boca Raton, Fl. In the early 80's.  I had personal contact with Kenichi Yamamoto thru our VP of sales who had set up all of Mazdas US distribution. My purpose was to have the lightest and most powerful aircraft engine and I thought the Rotary was the best possibility. He was very frank with me and said, all that was necessary to make a reliable aircraft version of the engine was to "redesign every single component in the engine for aircraft use".

I also was US ultralight distributor for Limbach motors of Germany. They made an aero version of the Volkswagen auto engine. They are the most successful in the business. Herr Limbach said all he had to do was to "redesign every single component in the engine for aircraft use".

Molt Taylor did the same with a Kawasaki motorcycle engine. In the end. He said the same thing.

Anyone who thinks Aero engine use of the Rotary is easy need only to look at all of the out of business co's that have tried so far. Those that are still in business, Rotron, Austro, Wolfe, Aixro, NWUAV, etc. make highly modified versions of the Wankel for other uses and they are not actually available for manned flight.

I hope someone soon can make one available to us that is safe, and reliable for manned experimental aircraft. I will be first in line. Good luck on the Liquid Piston Rotary.

Larry Gordon

Two possibilities.

One he was talking about certified aircraft engines that require a FAA paper
trail from the mine to the air on all parts. That is where Mistral stumbled.

Two he was worried  about Mazda product liability.

The Mazda rotary has been in the air in experimental aircraft since 1973.
Tens of thousands of hours or more have been accumulated.
The biggest problem was cooling it. Now solved by my book How to Cool
Your Wankel. The remaining problem is slightly higher fuel burn. We are working
on it with our new ignition and turbo compounding. Due to the lack of exhaust
valves the TC Rotary is likely to be the most efficient ICE of all times.

TBO is apparently more than 3000 hours as nobody has worn one out yet.

Austro Engines and several UAV manufactures are selling and using Wankel rotary
engines as we speak. 500 have been sold and more are being sold to Alexander Schleicher.
Austro Engines is working on a more powerful model.


Not to mention the powered parachutes and ultralights..

The news letter is 16 years old and still growing in reader ship.
You are obviously a newbie :)

Paul Lamar

 The Rotary Engine News Letter. Powered by Linux.
 ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
 You Tube http://tinyurl.com/beqqxas
 Copyright 1998-2014 All world wide rights reserved.